Updated at 11:53 a.m., Thursday, May 30, 2002
Tourism authority to pay for Aloha Stadium turf
By Catherine E. Toth
Advertiser Staff Writer
The National Football League, which said it would help pay for the cost of installation, will accept only FieldTurf as a replacement for the 3-year-old AstroTurf.
Should the state not change the field by the 2003 Pro Bowl, the NFL has threatened to take its annual all-star football game, which has been played in Honolulu since 1980, elsewhere.
"I don't think we should take their threats lightly," said HTA interim executive director Rick Humphries.
According to a five-year, $22 million contract brokered in 1999, the playing surface was supposed to have been changed for the 2002 Pro Bowl. If FieldTurf is to be ready in time for the next Pro Bowl, it must be installed by mid-August before the start of the high school and University of Hawai'i football seasons.
FieldTurf CEO John Gilman has assured the state that the turf can be installed in about two weeks, pending weather conditions. That doesn't include the time it would take to prepare the field for the new playing surface.
"If we don't do it by then, it won't be ready for the Pro Bowl in February and the NFL wants it changed," Humphries said.
FieldTurf officials have estimated the cost to install its product at $877,000 a discount of about $100,000-$150,000 with the balance to be paid by the NFL, Humphries said.
HTA's portion comes from existing money in the current fiscal year, some from canceled events. The tourism authority said it is not taking money away from other programs or contracts to pay for the turf change.
The Aloha Stadium Authority, which has the final say on the matter, met today to decide whether to replace the AstroTurf and discuss the conditions under which the change could be made at the 27-year-old stadium. The authority, however, decided to meet again on June 13 for more discussion and asked the tourism authority to substantiate claims that AstroTurf is dangerous.
"This is not a done deal," Humphries said. "Not until the ink is dry ... But I'm optimistic."
The NFL named only FieldTurf as an alternative to natural grass. Other similar products, such as AstroPlay and NextTurf, are not options although an AstroTurf representative told The Advertiser his company was willing to install AstroPlay at a reduced cost.
Putting in natural grass on a per-game basis is still an option, Humphries said, though an expensive one. He said estimates to install grass are between $200,000 and $500,000 per game.
Because the HTA is exempt from the state's bidding and procurement requirements, it can award the contract to FieldTurf without having to consider other options.
The Stadium Authority was not involved in deciding the terms of the contract between the HTA and the NFL, though its facility has been affected. Authority chairman Larry Price has been vocal in his opposition to replacing the current AstroTurf, citing its relative newness, $2.4 million price tag and the five years of warranty that remains.
The HTA agreed to the turf change to accommodate the NFL, whose players have been concerned about sustaining injuries while playing on the AstroTurf. (Brigham Young University also complained about the AstroTurf, claiming it caused 16 injuries in a Dec. 8 loss to the University of Hawai'i.)
AstroTurf officials have denied the link between its turf and injuries, saying there is no evidence AstroTurf is more dangerous than comparable surfaces.
But the HTA feels it must honor its agreement with the NFL to exercise "best efforts" to replace the current playing surface, pointing to the marketing and branding benefits of staging the Pro Bowl.
The state paid the league $4.75 million this year for the opportunity to play host to the game. FieldTurf is an artificial grass product that uses layers of sand and rubber infill.