Unlikely folks find respect for Eminem

By Nekesa Mumbi Moody
Associated Press

Eminem's MTV Music Award for his song "Without Me" is among many accolades the controversial rapper has received. Advertiser library photo • Aug. 29, 2002

Politicians condemned his obscenity-laced and violent lyrics. Gay and women's groups blasted him as a homophobe and misogynist. The Grammy-winning Detroit rapper had millions in album sales, but little love from mainstream America.

Well, he's still not America's sweetheart. But some of the vitriol directed at Eminem has diminished — replaced not just by grudging respect, but by downright enthusiasm from some unlikely quarters.

"The guy is funny, smart and sometimes shocking," author Stephen King gushed on his Web site. "Those are all things I look for in rock 'n' roll."

Randy Newman called Eminem a "kindred spirit."

Writer Paul Slansky, a self-described middle-aged white guy, penned a New York Observer column titled, "Guess Who Thinks Eminem's a Genius? Middle-Aged Me." He recently sounded the same theme in an essay on NPR.

Whether the 30-year-old rapper has softened or America has just grown more accepting, "he has started to interest serious, grownup audiences that would have dismissed him as a teenage hip-hop phenomenon," said New York Times critic Janet Maslin, who spent time with Eminem on the set of his upcoming movie, "8 Mile," for Premiere magazine.

"He's moved out of the youth ghetto."

Interest in Eminem, whose real name is Marshall Mathers, should grow even more with the release Friday of "8 Mile," loosely based on his troubled youth. The movie, directed by Curtis Hanson of "L.A. Confidential," and Eminem's performance have received early critical acclaim.

"I think he's just going to earn a lot of respect from people," said Sia Michel, editor in chief at Spin magazine, which has Eminem on its December cover. "They're going to see that he's clearly a talented guy."

Not that people doubted Eminem's talent. His first disc, 1999's "The Slim Shady LP," was praised by critics for its twisted, demented but humorous wit, and earned him the first two of his five Grammys. He was the first white rapper since the Beastie Boys to enjoy street credibility and admiration from both blacks and whites.

But there was anger over his lyrics, which included violent fantasies about his estranged mother and his wife and anti-gay slurs. The late Billboard editor Timothy White dedicated one of his influential music columns to excoriating Eminem.

The rapper's personal battles didn't help. He was arrested twice in 2000 for weapons violations (he received probation). He went through an ugly divorce and custody battle over his young daughter, and his mother sued him for defamation.

When "The Marshall Mathers LP," which sold 8 million copies in the United States, was nominated for album of the year in 2001, there were howls of protest — even more so when openly gay star Elton John agreed to perform with him at the Grammy ceremony.

Scott Seomin, entertainment director of the Gay and Lesbian Alliance Against Defamation, said that controversy helped Eminem's career: "All of that attention has brought him more into the mainstream."

Slansky said that before the duet with Elton John, on the song "Stan," "I was aware of (Eminem), and I kind of thought, and most people my age probably thought, he's not for me.

"When I heard that song, I thought, this was one of the best songs I ever heard."

He hasn't been able to stop listening to the latest album, "The Eminem Show," which came out in spring. After his Observer column, Slansky said, "I've gotten tons of e-mails ... it was like a general sigh of relief, like, 'Oh, a smart person (understands).' "

A USA Today article earlier this year compared Eminem's lyricism to Bob Dylan and other rock greats.

Not everyone is raving, however. Star, a popular New York disc jockey on the hip-hop-R&B station Hot 97, speculated that many of Eminem's new fans have never listened to the same kind of clever, angst-driven rhymes from black rappers such as DMX or Jay-Z.

"He's not the best. That's an insult to black people who have created this art form. It's an insult to Spanish people ... He's just the Elvis Presley of hip-hop, and that's it."

Eminem has said he probably wouldn't have sold as many albums had he been black.

As for his lyrics, fans say Eminem has been misunderstood or misrepresented.

"When you quote his lyrics out of context, or you just paraphrase the songs ... it sounds pretty bad," Maslin said. "But if you listen in context to the rhymes, to the presentation of it and the things beyond just lyrics, there's a lot going on. It's not as raw as that. It's actually a lot more witty."

"The Eminem Show" is more introspective, barely has an offensive word against gays and — although it still slams his mother and ex-wife — explains more of the bitterness.

"I think he was very aware of trying to change his image a bit with his last record," said Spin's Michel. "He showed a wider range of emotions, and concerns than you hadn't seen from him in the past."