honoluluadvertiser.com

Sponsored by:

Comment, blog & share photos

Log in | Become a member
The Honolulu Advertiser

Posted on: Friday, June 27, 2003

Verizon rival's risky venture getting noticed

By John Duchemin
Advertiser Staff Writer

Compare package deals

How does new provider Hawaii Direct Telephone stack up against Verizon?


Hawai'i Direct's cheapest package includes local phone service; blocking, forwarding and returns; call waiting with caller ID; three-way calling; the ability to cancel call waiting; and all taxes and fees.

The cost: $40 per month

Verizon offers a package with a choice of at least four of those features, plus others like speed dialing and distinctive rings.

The cost: About $40 per month, when fees and taxes are included

Both packages save about $20 per month off the cost of separately ordering each of the packaged services.
Hawaii Direct Telephone has set itself up as a local phone service competitor with Verizon, but it's hardly another Baby Bell. There's no army of telephone workers and no massive investments in equipment.

Instead, Hawaii Direct Telephone is a couple of guys from Texas with a knack for vacuuming pennies. They make their money by buying phone service at a discount from Verizon, then reselling it to Hawai'i residents for a few dollars more. They outsource their customer service, and don't own much besides their company's name.

It's a risky venture, with profit margins thinner than rice paper. But Hawaii Direct Telephone, which opened last fall after getting Public Utilities Commission approval, does offer an alternative to Verizon, and the newcomer's rate packages have caused consumers and their huge local competitor to notice. A recent promotional blitz offers "bundled" services, including local service, long-distance minutes, caller ID and voicemail, at a rate far cheaper than buying the individual service from Verizon.

Verizon has responded with new rate packages of its own, though it says Direct Telephone has barely scratched its customer base.

"Price isn't the only consideration when shopping for telecom services," said Ann Nishida, Verizon's local spokeswoman.

Still, Hawai'i's dominant telecommunications carrier says it has lost some market share in the past year, either to land-line competitors such as Hawaii Direct Telephone or Time Warner Telecom, which offers telecommunications services to businesses, or to increasing wireless use.

Hawaii Direct Telephone is trying to be the first Verizon rival to survive as a provider of residential land-line telephone service. Until the mid-1990s, dominant local phone companies such as Verizon and its predecessor, GTE Hawaiian Tel, had a monopoly on land-line phone service, protected as utilities by the federal government.

New laws have since forced the main local carriers to open their networks to rivals, which can buy services for resale. Typically, a competitor will lease a batch of phone numbers or lines, getting a bulk discount from the main local carrier.

For example, say a phone company charges $20 per month, tax and fees included, for no-frills residential service. Along comes a rival, which purchases a few thousand lines for $17 a month — a 15 percent discount.

The rival can then make money by selling those lines for, say, $18 per month — meaning it's undercutting the phone company by $2 per month, meanwhile making $1 per line in operating profit.

That's what Hawaii Direct Telephone is doing. Verizon has given Hawaii Direct Telephone a 15 percent general discount, according to a contract approved last September by the Public Utilities Commission.

Pulling this off, however, is one of the most difficult feats in the cutthroat telecommunications industry.

Many line-leasing competitors have become victims of the industry crash of 2001, when dozens of huge, free-spending companies simultaneously ran out of money. Plus the economy has slowed, competition from wireless providers has increased and the huge financial hangover facing the telecom industry has caused many phone companies to raise rates.

All of this puts immense pressure on the bottom line of companies such as Hawaii Direct Telephone, which will see its profits rapidly vanish as costs increase.

"If you're dependent on reselling someone else's services and facilities, it's much more difficult to be successful," said Galen Haneda, general manager of Time Warner Telecom in Hawai'i.

Despite the risks, Hawaii Direct Telephone has taken steps indicating it wants to stick around. The company has hired Summit Communications, a bankrupt but still operational telecommunications firm in Honolulu, to provide local marketing and customer service. Radio ads and a Web site urge customers to sign up for service packages, which cost between $40 and $60 per month.

"We've tried to lay real low until now," said Jared Grugett, a Summit employee who oversees Hawaii Direct Telephone's customer service.

Hawaii Direct Telephone president Nik Thomas, a Texas resident, did not respond to requests for comment on his company's strategy. But the all-outsourced, shoestring-budget approach appears to be one that Thomas and two other Texan businessmen are using in many states.

Direct Telephone Co., based in Katy, Texas, near Houston, has line-leasing agreements in at least 10 states from Texas to Florida.

Along with Thomas, key officials include company founder E.B. "Tommy" Thomas, a former Meineke Muffler franchise executive and real estate owner who plunged into telecommunications in 1997, and chief operating officer Seth Block, an accounting professional who has served as controller for several Texas companies.

Reach John Duchemin at jduchemin@honoluluadvertiser.com or at 525-8062.