Posted on: Sunday, August 15, 2004
ING Direct winning over customers
By Eileen Alt Powell
Associated Press
WILMINGTON, Del. While most banks are spiffing up branches and launching new products to deepen relationships with customers, ING Direct has set off in the opposite direction.
If traditional institutions are the Saks Fifth Avenue or Macy's of the retail banking world, "we're the factory outlet mall," said chief executive Arkadi Kuhlmann.
"Everybody else wants to customize and personalize, to develop relationships, that kind of thing," he said in a recent interview. "My idea was always that a savings account is just a savings account. If I make it a commodity product meaning that it is standardized, it is simple, it is straightforward then I can basically produce thousands of them at a good price."
The strategy seems to be working. Since ING Direct was launched at www.ingdirect.com in September 2000, it has drawn more than 2 million customers and collected $26 billion in deposits, putting it among the top 40 deposit-taking banks and thrifts in the nation.
And it's pulling in new money at a rate of $1 billion a month.
ING Direct is an online banking subsidiary of the Dutch financial giant ING Group, which is headquartered in Amsterdam.
Kuhlmann joined the company in the mid-1990s, first launching ING Direct Canada in 1996 and then moving to the states four years later to get ING Direct USA going.
The American operation has no bank branches or automated teller machines, though it does have a handful of cafes in New York, Philadelphia and Los Angeles with more to come in Washington, D.C., and Miami. They're mainly marketing outlets with coffee on the side.
Its major draw is no-frills savings accounts with no fees, no minimum balance requirements and very competitive interest rates. The Orange savings account is paying 2.2 percent interest, about double the rate at brick-and-mortar banks, while its CDs are close to or above national averages in their yields.
Catherine Graeber, an e-banking analyst with Forrester Research, said ING Direct's challenge is getting consumers to break long-held banking habits.
"For most consumers, where their branches are located and ATMs are located is very important," she said. For ING Direct to continue growing, it must find "consumers who are in a mind-set to start saving."
She thinks the bank has set up to do that by "harnessing the Internet" in ways other institutions haven't. For example, nearly one-third of ING Direct's automatically deposit their paychecks or automatically transfer surplus funds into their accounts every month, she noted. "And they've made it easy to link their accounts to a (traditional) bank, so they can transfer money in and out if they need it," Graeber said.
For Kuhlmann, simplifying the banking process for consumers translates to a simplified business model. ING Direct operates nationally with a staff of just 1,000, and his operating costs are about one-third of traditional banks, he said.
But that also means that to remain a high-volume, low-margin business, Kuhlmann sometimes "fires" customers. It's generally because they call too often or write too many letters or need too much hand-holding.
"We basically tell them, 'You're not ready for this yet,' " Kuhlmann said. "You're better off at a (traditional bank) branch. Please go back to a branch because I'm not keeping you."
He compares the situation to a diner who goes into a McDonald's restaurant and asks for linen and silver.
"Consumers understand that, but they don't necessarily understand that it's the same in banking," Kuhlmann said.
Such talk has led some to characterize Kuhlmann as "the anti-banker's banker," and he doesn't totally reject that description.
He eschews suits, preferring to work in an open-necked white shirt, khaki pants and loafers. His office is not in a major city but on the sixth floor of a 200-year-old converted warehouse overlooking the Christina River south of Wilmington's downtown. He posts his phone number and e-mail address on the ING Direct Web site and answers consumer queries himself.
Kuhlmann says he's not trying to be different just for the sake of being different but because it's good for business.
"There are 16,000 banks out there, and the choice was, 'Do we want to be another bank or do we want to be different,' " he said. "The point is, if we're not different we're not going to get noticed, and if we're not noticed, nobody's going to see what we really have to offer. So we do need to be different."
His bank's motto is, "Lead America Back to Saving," and a sign with those words is on the desks of all his workers.
"I am creating an alternative conversation," he said. "I'm saying that among all the other things being talked about out there about consume here, buy there, charge here I'm actually saying, 'Why don't you save something?' I think that's good for people. And I think that's good for society."