Posted on: Thursday, October 14, 2004

EDITORIAL
Bush wins on style, Kerry on substance

Presidential debates such as the final meeting last night between George Bush and John Kerry can be measured against two very different standards.

The first is subjective: What kind of person presented himself on stage? Was he likable, sincere? Did he come across as the kind of person one would want as a friend, neighbor, president?

The second is more objective: Was he in command of the facts? Did he make his points clearly and well? Was there a coherent narrative throughout those difficult 90 minutes before the nation?

In our view, President Bush won the first test last night, Sen. Kerry the second.

Bush overcame the smirky nonchalance of his first debate performance and the somewhat stagey aggressiveness of his second appearance to present himself as himself. He was resolute, warm, human and humbly aware of the awesome burdens he carries as president.

Kerry was presidential, direct and commanding. But he had more trouble than Bush in communicating what kind of human being he is.

On the objective test, Kerry prevailed. He presented a clear list of areas where he believes the current administration has failed and he offered concrete solutions. His domestic agenda is clear and his position on the core issue of Iraq has become coherent and convincing.

Kerry handled difficult questions with aplomb, including the tough one of abortion. As a Catholic, he said, he has strong feelings about this issue but cannot and will not legislate what to him is a personal article of faith.

It must be said that both candidates, weary after weeks of campaigning and two previous debates, fell back on previously heard talking points. Those who followed all three debates closely heard statements last night that were virtually word-for-word the same as in previous appearances.

Still, the three debates offered Americans a clear picture of where the two candidates stand on most of the key issues of this campaign and how they differ.

If you didn't have an opportunity to watch the debates, make an effort to view repeats or read transcripts or straightforward accounts of what was said and who said it.

It is by far your best bet, if you are still undecided, to make an informed choice in this most important election.