honoluluadvertiser.com

Sponsored by:

Comment, blog & share photos

Log in | Become a member
The Honolulu Advertiser

Posted on: Monday, September 13, 2004

Drivers seeing success in small, smart traffic fixes

 •  Solutions big and small

By Mike Leidemann
Advertiser Transportation Writer

It seemed like such a small thing, but when city officials made a 50-yard stretch of Kailua Road into a one-way street, good things started happening.

A recent Federal Highway Administration report recommends that local officials consider using these approaches to reduce congestion:

• Meter traffic onto freeways.

• Synchronize traffic signals.

• Improve response to traffic incidents.

• Provide travelers with information on road conditions and alternate routes.

• Improve management of work zones.

• Provide real-time information on transit schedules and arrivals.

• Anticipate and address special events that increase traffic.

• Reversible commuter lanes.

• Movable median barriers to add capacity during peak periods.

• Restrict turns at key intersections.

• Roundabouts and other geometric improvements to roads and intersections.

• Converting streets to one-way.

The report also suggests ways to make better use of existing systems:

• Encouraging ride-sharing and use of public transit.

• Encourage flexible work hours and telecommuting.

• Develop fees for heavily used routes.

• Regulate parking fees by number of riders, time of day or location.

Source: Federal Highway Administration

Frequent accidents at a nearby intersection all but ended. Traffic on adjacent South Kalaheo Avenue, which used to back up quickly, suddenly started flowing better. And city officials saved hundreds of thousands of dollars they planned to spend on a new traffic signal in the area.

"A lot of high-priced and complicated solutions were considered, but when everything is said and done, the fix will probably end up costing no more than $5,000," said Don Dymond, who owns the Kalapawai Market fronting the problem area. "Ask anybody who lives in Lanikai, and they'll tell you they're happier now."

The improvement is an example of what some people are describing as a change in the way state and county officials deal with traffic congestion across the state. Instead of relying on large, multimillion-dollar highway construction and widening projects, officials increasingly are thinking small, looking for ways to fix problems without throwing heaps of money at them.

"At long last they are finally looking for commonsense solutions to our traffic problems," said Sen. Fred Hemmings, who has lobbied state officials for years to take such an approach. "There are hundreds of other things we can do like this, to provide tremendous relief for those stuck in traffic."

Hemmings and other officials credited small-scale changes such as synchronizing traffic signals, starting a contraflow lane on Nimitz Highway or adding an extra turn lane here and there with easing problems in specific areas.

Cumulatively, they may add up to bigger things.

A national report released last week found that Hawai'i drivers spend 40 percent less time stuck in peak-hour traffic jams than they did 10 years ago. While many drivers doubt details of the report, officials said it's clear traffic would have gotten worse without the fixes already undertaken.

"We're looking at things we can do quickly, cheaply and effectively. We're looking at things we can do right now," said state Transportation Director Rod Haraga.

The idea is one endorsed by national transportation officials, who say local engineers are realizing they can no longer just build their way out of traffic problems.

"To make real progress, it's critical that we pursue all transportation solutions, including short-range, small-scale projects and policies," said Tim Lomax, who wrote last week's Urban Mobility Report from the Texas Transportation Institute.

Lomax noted that many of the cities that fared best in the report have tried to improve traffic in creative ways, such as synchronizing lights, expanding car pool lanes, improving highway communications and creating fast-response highway incident teams that clear backlogs quickly.

Similar projects have been implemented or are being planned in Hawai'i, said DOT spokesman Scott Ishikawa.

In the past year, the state has opened a contraflow lane on Nimitz Highway and closed an on-ramp on the H-1 Freeway during morning rush hour. Both projects significantly have reduced travel time for morning commuters at minimal construction cost, Ishikawa said.

The state plans two more congestion-relief projects that don't involve building new roads. One calls for a new freeway service patrol of roving tow trucks that would handle minor problems and clear stalled vehicles. The service, expected to start within two years, would be free to motorists.

The state also is taking more interest in ramp metering, Ishikawa said. Many communities use a small traffic signal that allows vehicles to enter a freeway at five-second intervals, creating a more even flow of traffic.

"We're really trying to think outside the box," Ishikawa said.

Similar ideas have been proposed before, but got bogged down in bureaucratic wrangling, or held back by dissent in the community, said Hemmings, R-25th (Kailua, Waimanalo, Portlock).

"A lot of time, especially in politics, there are nearsighted people who can't see beyond the immediate squeaky wheel," Hemmings said. "It takes a tough

political will to see past the protesters and do what's right for the majority of the people."

Lanikai resident Dymond believes bureaucrats and elected officials finally are getting that message. "They're realizing that you can't fix everything simply by throwing money at it," he said. "And they're finally listening to what people have to say. After all, we're the ones who live here and deal with problems every day."

Haraga said part of the change has been a willingness to work with community leaders and sell them on projects, some of which had been stalled for years because of community concerns.

"The Nimitz contraflow plan was a sure-fire winner, but we had to work for months to package it and sell it the community. We did it by starting with a demonstration project that helped people see how it works," he said.

The emphasis on quick fixes doesn't preclude longer-term, more expensive highway building and widening projects or planning for a mass transit system on O'ahu.

"Eventually the big projects will come on line to alleviate some of the problems, but they take years to plan and complete," Haraga said. "Meanwhile, we need to keep working on the stuff we can do now."

Reach Mike Leidemann at 525-5460 or mleidemann@honoluluadvertiser.com.

• • •

The short stretch of Kailua Road at Kalaheo Avenue near Kalapawai Market is now one-way heading mauka, a small change that has eased traffic out of Lanikai turning left.

Bruce Asato • The Honolulu Advertiser

Solutions big and small

Recent congestion-relief projects from the state Department of Transportation:

  • H-1 Freeway zipper lane, $16 million.
  • Nimitz contraflow lane, $1 million.
  • Lunalilo on-ramp closure, $200,000.

Major current or planned road-building projects:

  • H-1 Freeway widening at Waimalu, $55 million.
  • Fort Weaver Road widening, $24.3 million.
  • New North-South Road in Kapolei, $120 million.

Planned congestion-relief projects:

  • Freeway service patrol to clear stalled vehicles from the roadway.
  • Ramp metering to control freeway access.
  • New lane connecting zipper lane and Nimitz contraflow lane.

Recent congestion-relief projects from the Honolulu Department of Transportation Services:

  • Realignment of Kailua Road to ease traffic leaving Lanikai.
  • New or planned protected left-turn signals at six intersections from Palolo to Kaka'ako.
  • New bus pullouts in Hawai'i Kai, Kaimuki, Honolulu and Kailua to reduce backup of traffic behind buses.
  • Equipping all buses with two-way radios to report traffic problems.
  • Live radio and TV broadcasts from Traffic Management Center, which monitors congestion by video camera.