honoluluadvertiser.com

Sponsored by:

Comment, blog & share photos

Log in | Become a member
The Honolulu Advertiser
Posted on: Saturday, August 6, 2005

Horrors of Hiroshima fading

By Bruce Wallace and Hisako Ueno
Los Angeles Times

Mourners pray in front of the Peace Memorial Park cenotaph, dedicated to those who perished.

Kyodo News via Associated Press

spacer
spacer
Mourners pray in front of the Peace Memorial Park cenotaph, dedicated to those who perished.

Kyodo News via Associated Press

spacer
Mourners stage a symbolic "die-in" in front of the Atomic Bomb Dome at Peace Memorial Park in Hiroshima. The City of Peace fell silent at 8:15 a.m. today, 60 years after the atomic flash vaporized the heart of Hiroshima and dragged the world into the nuclear age.

Itsuo Inouye | Associated Press

spacer
Japanese Prime Minister Junichiro Koizumi bows before the cenotaph as he pays respects to victims during a ceremony marking the 60th anniversary of the atomic bomb attack in Hiroshima.

Junji Kurokawa | Associated Press

spacer

HIROSHIMA, Japan — Heads bowed in prayer and memory, the citizens of this self-styled City of Peace fell silent at 8:15 a.m. today, 60 years from the instant of the atomic flash that vaporized the heart of their city and dragged mankind over the precipice into the nuclear age.

Temple bells that had been ringing for the dead stopped to mark the moment when an American B-29 bomber dropped its atomic cargo over Hiroshima, killing 70,000 people on the spot from concussion and fire and debris. Another 70,000 died within months from the effects of radiation.

It was also an act that many argue hastened an end to a world war that had already slaughtered millions.

A one-time garrison town for Japan's Imperial Army, Hiroshima has since turned its tragedy into a platform for peace and nuclear disarmament. The cry was made more poignant this year by advancing ages of the hibakusha, or "bomb affected people." Hiroshima Mayor Tadatoshi Akiba called the ceremony a "time of inheritance, of awakening and of commitment, in which we inherit the commitment of the hibakusha to the abolition of nuclear weapons and recommit ourselves to take action."

But there is also an uneasy sense among many here that Japan's collective pacifist voice has become shaky with age. The last witnesses to the atomic attacks are increasingly infirm or dying, with little sign that the country's unique experience of having been attacked with atomic weapons resonates with younger generations.

"I think they regard preventing war as someone else's problem," said Taichi Ueno, 24, part of a small group of peace activists called P-Souls who traveled to Hiroshima for the ceremony. "About war, they say: 'It wouldn't happen to me.' "

Indeed, peace activists note a ritualistic feel to the annual commemoration at Hiroshima. The national broadcaster, NHK, broadcast the ceremony live but cut away from the speeches appealing for peace after just 20 minutes, returning to its regularly scheduled drama series called "Fight." Even some residents of Hiroshima, where what the Japanese call peace education in schools is more intensely followed than elsewhere, sound jaded by their international image.

"Only on this day are people enthusiastic about peace — that's it," said Yuki Shibazaki, 17, as she gossiped with friends around the Peace Park Museum after the ceremony. Her high school class was supposed to designate two representatives to attend today's ceremony but there were no volunteers.

"I don't have any clear sense about war or peace," she said. "To be honest, for the locals, it is an inconvenience and annoying to have a ceremony like this."

That complacency worries Hiroshima survivors, who warn that complacency about the lessons of the atomic bombs make war and even the use of nuclear weapons more likely.

"Japanese people are surprisingly passive," says Yasuhiro Okudaira, 76, who heads the Article 9 Association, a coalition of civic groups battling to guard the constitutional clause that renounces Japan's right to wage war or use the threat of force to resolve international conflicts. "I don't think youngsters are necessarily nationalistic. It is just that they are sort of free riders, interested only in their own small lives, not the larger philosophical questions."

The apathy is measurable. Annual attendance at the Hiroshima Peace Park peaked at 1.59 million in 1991 and has fallen to barely more than a million in each of the past five years, with foreign visitors accounting for one-tenth the total.

Some school administrators complain their students get bored spending a full day in Hiroshima's museum looking at photographs and reading eyewitness accounts. There are some in Hiroshima who now argue the Peace Park needs other diversions for students visiting on day trips (a zoo is one suggestion) to try stimulate attendance.

Older Japanese argue an atomic blast site should be enough of a theme park to hold a teenager's attention.

"I have heard the argument that there is nothing to see at the Peace Park other than the museum, and I think that misses the point," says Motofumi Asai, 64, a former diplomat and now director of the Hiroshima Peace Institute. "The students must see the materials in detail. They must be moved fundamentally by the Hiroshima victims."

This has been a somber year for World War II anniversaries in Japan, with nothing but calamity to commemorate: the March 1945 firebombing of Tokyo that killed an estimated 100,000 citizens, gruesome losses during battles for Saipan and Okinawa, and this month, the incineration of Hiroshima and Nagasaki followed by capitulation.

But even the most devoted peace activists acknowledge the diminution of the Hiroshima experience in the Japanese consciousness. And they note that the increased cases of vandalism at the Peace Park — origami paper cranes made by children in memory of victims have been set on fire — show a diminishing reverence for the particular tragedy of that August 1945 morning.

In the vacuum left by apathy, right-wing activists have taken the wheel of the political agenda, pushing for a re-assertive Japanese nationalism.

Junior high school history textbooks are being rewritten to soften Japan's wartime role. And there is a strong push to rewrite the pacifist Article 9 clause of the constitution.

The drive is to make Japan a "normal" state again, with real armed forces capable of projecting Japanese power in Asia and beyond, not the constitutionally neutered Self-Defense Force.