honoluluadvertiser.com

Sponsored by:

Comment, blog & share photos

Log in | Become a member
The Honolulu Advertiser
Posted on: Monday, August 8, 2005

Sweatshop memories linger

By LAURA WIDES
Associated Press

Win Chuai Ngan and his wife, Sukanya Chuai Ngan, own two restaurants, including this North Hollywood eatery in Los Angeles. The couple received a legal settlement for their work at a sweatshop and used the money to open their first restaurant.
spacer
spacer
In this Aug. 26, 1997, photo, a living room in a Los Angeles-area apartment building is shown after it was converted to a sewing room in a garment sweatshop. A decade ago, authorities stormed the complex where 70 Thai immigrants were forced to work 16-hour days.
spacer
Sweatshop survivor Sangwan Jane spoke about her experiences on Aug. 2, marking the 10th anniversary of a raid on an illegal L.A.-area garment shop.

Kevork Djansezian | Associated Press

spacer
In this Aug. 26, 1997, photo, a living room in a Los Angeles-area apartment building is shown after it was converted to a sewing room in a garment sweatshop. A decade ago, authorities stormed the complex where 70 Thai immigrants were forced to work 16-hour days.
spacer
In this Aug. 26, 1997, photo, a living room in a Los Angeles-area apartment building is shown after it was converted to a sewing room in a garment sweatshop. A decade ago, authorities stormed the complex where 70 Thai immigrants were forced to work 16-hour days.
spacer
In this Aug. 26, 1997, photo, a living room in a Los Angeles-area apartment building is shown after it was converted to a sewing room in a garment sweatshop. A decade ago, authorities stormed the complex where 70 Thai immigrants were forced to work 16-hour days.
spacer
In this Aug. 26, 1997, photo, a living room in a Los Angeles-area apartment building is shown after it was converted to a sewing room in a garment sweatshop. A decade ago, authorities stormed the complex where 70 Thai immigrants were forced to work 16-hour days.
spacer
In this Aug. 26, 1997, photo, a living room in a Los Angeles-area apartment building is shown after it was converted to a sewing room in a garment sweatshop. A decade ago, authorities stormed the complex where 70 Thai immigrants were forced to work 16-hour days.
spacer
In this Aug. 26, 1997, photo, a living room in a Los Angeles-area apartment building is shown after it was converted to a sewing room in a garment sweatshop. A decade ago, authorities stormed the complex where 70 Thai immigrants were forced to work 16-hour days.
spacer
In this Aug. 26, 1997, photo, a living room in a Los Angeles-area apartment building is shown after it was converted to a sewing room in a garment sweatshop. A decade ago, authorities stormed the complex where 70 Thai immigrants were forced to work 16-hour days.
spacer
In this Aug. 26, 1997, photo, a living room in a Los Angeles-area apartment building is shown after it was converted to a sewing room in a garment sweatshop. A decade ago, authorities stormed the complex where 70 Thai immigrants were forced to work 16-hour days.
spacer
In this Aug. 26, 1997, photo, a living room in a Los Angeles-area apartment building is shown after it was converted to a sewing room in a garment sweatshop. A decade ago, authorities stormed the complex where 70 Thai immigrants were forced to work 16-hour days.
spacer
In this Aug. 26, 1997, photo, a living room in a Los Angeles-area apartment building is shown after it was converted to a sewing room in a garment sweatshop. A decade ago, authorities stormed the complex where 70 Thai immigrants were forced to work 16-hour days.
spacer
Sweatshop survivor Sangwan Jane spoke about her experiences on Aug. 2, marking the 10th anniversary of a raid on an illegal L.A.-area garment shop.

Kevork Djansezian | Associated Press

spacer
Sweatshop survivor Sangwan Jane spoke about her experiences on Aug. 2, marking the 10th anniversary of a raid on an illegal L.A.-area garment shop.

Kevork Djansezian | Associated Press

spacer
Sweatshop survivor Sangwan Jane spoke about her experiences on Aug. 2, marking the 10th anniversary of a raid on an illegal L.A.-area garment shop.

Kevork Djansezian | Associated Press

spacer
Sweatshop survivor Sangwan Jane spoke about her experiences on Aug. 2, marking the 10th anniversary of a raid on an illegal L.A.-area garment shop.

Kevork Djansezian | Associated Press

spacer
Sweatshop survivor Sangwan Jane spoke about her experiences on Aug. 2, marking the 10th anniversary of a raid on an illegal L.A.-area garment shop.

Kevork Djansezian | Associated Press

spacer

LOS ANGELES — Ten years after she was freed from a suburban sweatshop prison, Nantha Jaknang still has nightmares about being locked behind its razor-wire fence, sewing for 16 hours a day without seeing the sun or moon.

In her dream, the men who held her captive demand that she work harder.

"Tomorrow we need more work," they tell her. "We need more."

Shortly before dawn on Aug. 2, 1995, authorities stormed the apartment complex where Jaknang and some 70 other Thai immigrants slept on mats, 10 to a room, in El Monte, a gritty, working-class suburb east of Los Angeles.

Their slavelike treatment shocked Americans and sparked lawsuits, new regulations and even a Smithsonian exhibit.

The case brought dramatic changes but hasn't eliminated wage and safety abuses in the garment industry, where the vast majority of workers are undocumented immigrants.

"Unfortunately, abuse is still an everyday occurrence," said Kent Wong, director of the UCLA Center for Labor Research and Education. "Many are unaware of their rights, and even if they are aware they're being victimized, they have no confidence that they can do anything about it."

Many of the El Monte workers still find satisfaction knowing their plight helped shed light on sometimes deplorable conditions.

"I never thought it would be that big," said Sukanya Chuai Ngan, 44, who runs two restaurants with her husband Win, another former worker. "People, customers, see me and still say 'El Monte, El Monte.' They remember."

The workers won more than $4 million in lawsuit settlements against firms such as Mervyn's, Montgomery Ward & Co. and B.U.M. International for which they allegedly made clothes through subcontractors. The companies admitted no wrongdoing and said they had no knowledge of the conditions.

After sharing money with Hispanic workers at another site run by the same employer, each Thai worker pocketed between $10,000 and $80,000, depending on their time at the complex.

They moved as far away as New Hampshire and Florida but remain a tight-knit group. One man started his own garment factory, employing former El Monte co-workers. Several women opened spas, and more than one romance between workers spawned marriage and children.

"We are locked together now," Jaknang, 47, said. "We are close like a family."

Meanwhile, Congress has approved the granting of visas for immigrant victims of human trafficking and made it easier for investigators to get search warrants targeting suspected sweatshops.

In California, home to the largest segment of the U.S. garment industry, manufacturers must now guarantee that subcontractors pay workers fairly. Under that law, Araceli Castro, one of the Hispanic workers from El Monte, recently won back wages in another suit.

El Monte was the first of several high-profile sweatshop cases a decade ago. The negative publicity led companies such as Nike, Gap and even Kathie Lee Gifford's clothing line to start issuing their own reports about working conditions at factories.

"It used to be see no evil, hear no evil. Now apparel companies have whole divisions for corporate responsibility," said Julie Su, a lawyer at the Asian Pacific American Legal Center who represented the Thai workers.

The workers were lured to the United States with fake visas and the promise of earning $1,000 a month at a garment factory. But once inside the concrete walls of the apartment building, they were threatened by bosses who confiscated their passports and guarded them around the clock.

The little money they were paid went to buy food from a company store at jacked-up prices.

Win Chuai Ngan, 48, said many workers were afraid to try to escape because they spoke no English and owed money to their captors for visas and tickets to the United States.

"My brothers had come before me," Chuai Ngan said. "They told me to accept my fate."

But he refused to give up hope and eventually escaped over a wall in 1992. The complex was raided after a woman fled through an air vent three years later and went to authorities. Eight people were convicted in the case. Two remain at large.

Chuai Ngan became a manager at a sewing factory and offered jobs to other El Monte workers. The hours were long, and they barely scraped by. Eventually, he and Sukanya used a small business grant and some of the legal settlement money to open their first restaurant.

Most of the other workers remain in the garment industry.

In the decade since their plight was revealed, investigators haven't seen another case as egregious. Still, abuse continues amid industry downsizing, as more and more work is moved overseas.

El Monte worker Sirilak Charasri, 45, said she had to move to Phoenix because she couldn't support herself sewing in Los Angeles. The work paid too little and was too irregular. She took a maintenance job in a casino, where she receives benefits for the first time.

About 500,000 garment industry jobs remain in this country, compared to more than a million a decade ago, said Pietra Rivoli, a business professor at Georgetown University and author of "Travels of a T-Shirt in the Global Economy."

While larger retailers are careful to protect their brand name from workplace scandals, small boutiques, Internet and catalogue retailers — a growing share of the market — are less likely to make sure that suppliers follow labor laws, said Ilse Metchek, executive director of the California Fashion Association.

And while state and federal enforcement efforts spiked after El Monte, payouts for overtime violations have declined in recent years.

Last year, federal investigations resulted in about $4.8 million in back pay to 6,722 employees, most of it for overtime, according to the Department of Labor. That's less than half of what was paid in 2000.

Metchek applauded Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger's new push to enforce state labor laws but said even the 62 new positions he intends to add will be like "swatting the problem with a fly swatter."

Jaknang said things are better at her sewing job now that she has a green card. She is proud to be protected by laws that her ordeal helped create.

But she still sees many undocumented workers paid less than minimum wage.

"They accept whatever the owner pays," she said. "They hide when the inspection comes."