honoluluadvertiser.com

Sponsored by:

Comment, blog & share photos

Log in | Become a member
The Honolulu Advertiser
Posted on: Friday, August 12, 2005

Unabomb defender signs onto Talia case

By Peter Boylan
Advertiser Staff Writer

DEATH-PENALTY-ELIGIBLE CASES

Hawai'i has had at least five federal death-penalty-eligible cases in the past 10 years.

In the first case, Richard Lee Tuck "China" Chong was charged with first-degree murder, ice and firearm counts in the 1997 shooting of William Noa Jr. at a Makaha beach over what prosecutors say was a $100 drug debt.

Chong pleaded guilty and was sentenced to life in prison.

In the second, Keala Leong and Bryson Jose were charged with first-degree murder in the shooting death of Army helicopter pilot John Latchum Jr. at the Army's Wai'anae recreation center in 1998. Roberto Miguel, who was 17 and not eligible for the death penalty, allegedly fired the fatal shot.

Jose and Miguel were convicted of murder in December 2000 and sentenced to life without possibility of parole. Leong pleaded guilty to attempted burglary. In exchange for that plea, prosecutors dropped the murder charge. Leong was sentenced to 10 years.

In the other three cases:

  • Renee Beth Smith a Navy wife, is serving a 17 1/2-year prison term for smothering her 13-week-old daughter at their Pearl Harbor home.
  • Francisco Davalos and Hector Lopez are serving life terms without possibility of parole for a drug-related double murder on the Big Island in 1997.
  • Eugene Frederick Boyce III is accused of murdering Steve Makuakane-Jarrell, a Big Island park ranger, who was shot on Dec. 12, 1998. Last year, Boyce was declared fit to face trial.

    Source: The Honolulu Advertiser archives

  • spacer
    spacer
    The federal public defender who represented the Unabomber has been retained to help defend the stepmother of a 5-year-old girl who died of suspicious injuries last month.

    Judy Clarke, a federal public defender from San Diego has been brought in as a attorney certified for death-penalty cases to help with the defense of Delilah Williams, the stepmother of 5-year-old Talia Williams, who along with her husband, Army Spc. Naeem Williams, has been charged by federal authorities with murder in connection with Talia's death.

    If convicted, both face life in prison or the death penalty under federal sentencing statutes. U.S. Attorney Ed Kubo said Tuesday that it is too early to decide if a death penalty recommendation is warranted and that the investigation into Talia's death is open and continuing.

    It is at least the sixth time the death-penalty option has been available to federal prosecutors in Hawai'i in the past decade, according to Advertiser archives.

    In addition to serving as co-counsel on Theodore Kaczynski's legal team during his 1998 trial on charges of murdering three and wounding 23 with homemade bombs, Clarke made national headlines by helping to convince a jury that Susan Smith didn't deserve the death penalty for drowning her two young sons in a South Carolina lake in 1995.

    Federal statutes say defendants facing a possible death sentence must be represented by two attorneys, one of whom must be certified to handle capital cases, as Clarke is.

    Lawyers must take courses and follow certain procedures to become certified to defend a case where the death penalty is an option. Naeem Williams' attorney, David Klein, said yesterday he is seeking a second attorney who is certified in handling death-penalty cases.

    Hawai'i is one of 12 states that do not have the death penalty and few, if any, local attorneys are certified for capital cases.

    If Delilah and Naeem Williams are indicted by a federal grand jury, it would trigger an automatic review by the U.S. Department of Justice to determine if the death penalty should be sought. Kubo is required to make a recommendation in the case, but it would have to be approved by U.S. Attorney General Alberto Gonzales.

    Talia died July 16 after she was beaten and knocked to the floor of the family's Wheeler Army Airfield apartment. An autopsy found she died of "inflicted head trauma due to battered-child syndrome."

    The military charged Naeem Williams, 25, with murder on July 28. Delilah Williams, 21, was indicted in federal court on a charge of first-degree murder on July 18.

    On Tuesday, Kubo successfully transferred the Army's case against Naeem Williams to federal court so that the soldier and his wife could be tried before the same judge and jury. He said the transfer was made primarily to prevent a "he said, she said" situation and not because of the death-penalty option.

    The death penalty was abolished in Hawai'i under territorial law in 1957, and later under state law, but the federal death penalty was reinstated in 1988 only for murders in the course of a drug conspiracy, according to the nonprofit Death Penalty Information Center in Washington, D.C.

    The statute was expanded to cover 60 offenses in 1994, including deaths resulting from carjackings and drive-by shootings.

    Last year, Congress further amended the first-degree murder statute to include any "pattern and practice of assault and torture against a child" that results in the child's death.

    Naeem and Delilah Williams are the first defendants in the nation to be prosecuted under the new provision, Kubo said Tuesday.