honoluluadvertiser.com

Sponsored by:

Comment, blog & share photos

Log in | Become a member
The Honolulu Advertiser
Posted on: Tuesday, August 16, 2005

Letters to the Editor

spacer

STADIUM GAMES

ELIMINATING DRUNKEN CHAOS IS NO SMALL IDEA

I enjoy Lee Cataluna's column and appreciate her point of view. However, let me strongly state that banning alcohol at Aloha Stadium games and in the parking lot is not a small idea. It is a beginning.

Freedom from having our families, our young children witness "sloppy drunks beefing in the stands, rolling down the cement stairs, throwing stuff at the opposing team ... " is no small idea. There is a strong message to our children when they see that part of going to Aloha Stadium is having to see this behavior and that we adults, in our collective consciousness, are not drawing the line clear enough.

It's about time that we send the message that families, youth, children and our community can enjoy sporting events without alcohol. After alcohol is banned from games at Aloha Stadium, the next policy that needs to be re-evaluated is why liquor is sold on the University of Hawai'i campus. That, too, is no small idea.

Elaine Wilson, MSW, MPH
Retired chief, state Department of Health Alcohol and Drug Abuse Division

BOAT HARBOR

DLNR SHOULD LOOK AT L.A. SUCCESS STORY

In the late 1970s, the Department of Defense determined that what was then known as the Fort MacArthur Lower Reservation — at the west end of Los Angeles Harbor and adjacent to an old run-down small-boat harbor with a hole-in-the-wall yacht club — to be surplus and ceded it back to the City of Los Angeles.

The city saw big dollar signs with the thought of expanding its oil docks, but soon found that the too-shallow bottom was mostly rock and would be cost-prohibitive to blast and dredge. So, what else to do but build a small-boat marina.

As a past commodore of that hole-in-the-wall yacht club, and as a party to its reformation in this new marina, which incidentally is just around the corner from Roy Disney's prestigious Los Angeles Yacht Club, I watched a shabby, run-down assortment of rickety old docks become a first-rate, substantial, income-producing, upscale marina with a thousand, give or take, slips and with the new Cabrillo Beach Yacht Club, its 10,000-square-foot clubhouse and 188 slips of its own as its crown jewel.

Instead of our having to go hat-in-hand to the L.A. Harbor Department for whatever our needs as we once did, the L.A. Harbor Department now solicits the yacht club's advice and counsel on nearly all recreational boating-related issues.

Just maybe the state of Hawai'i's Department of Land and Natural Resources with its Ala Wai Small Boat Harbor could take a page out of L.A.'s Cabrillo Marina success story.

Mike Kennedy
Kapolei

KAMEHAMEHA

RULING REFLECTS AGE OF POLITICAL CORRECTNESS

I'm wondering why anyone would be surprised by the 9th Circuit's decision concerning Kamehameha Schools' admissions policy. After all, we live in a day and age of political correctness, where the wishes of a selfish few outweigh the masses, in the name of equality.

History and tradition are a thing of the past; judges will continue to make rulings on behalf of the selfish few in the name of equality, whether it's the admissions policy of an institution or other more controversial social issues.

For those of you still surprised by this decision, get used to more decisions like it. I have.

Philip White
Mililani

WAIKIKI

DEMONSTRATION WOULD ONLY HURT HAWAIIANS

Concerning Hawaiian activist Keali'i Gora's comment about going into Waikiki and telling the tourists to leave ("Hawaiians uniting in anger," Aug. 4): You'll hurt the Hawaiians, as much or more, than the 9th Circuit Court of Appeals by implementing your type of vendetta.

Do you have any idea how many thousands of Hawaiians and part-Hawaiians are in the travel industry? Let's work together! I'm sure the majority of the visitors who hear about our plight will stand up for our rights and beliefs. Gather and conquer! Don't destroy Hawaiians' livelihoods. I mua!

Jimmy Borges
Entertainer, Honolulu

FOLLOW WILL

KAMEHAMEHA CASE RAISES SEVERAL POINTS

Regarding the Kamehameha Schools case:

  • Why would anyone want to be where they are creating such an explosion of anger?

  • Why does this attorney claim this boy is going to suffer if he can't have his senior year at Kamehameha, when he's never been there and has no attachment to it?

  • If Pauahi's will can be overridden by our courts, where does it end in us crying "discrimination"? Do we eliminate all-girl or all-boy schools?

  • If the intent of the will was to provide for the orphans and indigent of Hawai'i, then Kamehameha Schools needs to do its part, too, by actually honoring that part of her will, instead of selecting only those at the upper echelon of income.

  • I wonder about the parents' motives and actions in angering so many people to put their child in a place he is not truly wanted.

    This school has operated under its policy as long as it has stood and has an important role to play in keeping alive the Hawaiian culture and history. Pauahi understood that need and willed it, but for the most needy as well. Let all sides honor her will.

    Caroline Viola
    Kailua

    NOT RAIL

    HIGH-OCCUPANCY TOLL LANES THE ONLY ANSWER

    What is all the fuss about fixed rail? Has anyone been to Chicago, Dallas, Atlanta or New York? These cities have a fixed-rail system and they still have a traffic problem. Because not many people use it, they still drive their cars. So having a rail system will not work in Hawai'i.

    I believe that high-occupancy toll (HOT) lanes will work. An expressway is needed that will start from downtown Honolulu and end at Makakilo and Mililani. It should not have any on-ramps, just off-ramps at Kunia, 'Ewa Beach, Mililani and Makakilo. It should have at least three lanes.

    Since the plans call for having it above existing freeways, it will work. Having the right plan and the right idea, the HOT lanes will solve Hawai'i's traffic problems — and fixed rail won't.

    Alan Kim
    'Aiea

    AFTER INCREASE

    GENERAL EXCISE TAX WILL REALLY BE 4.7%

    The current GET of 4 percent is really 4.166 percent since the state Tax Department considers all revenues collected, including the 4 percent tax, to be subject to taxation.

    This means that the proposed GET tax increase of .5 percent for a total of 4.5 percent results in a new tax rate of 4.712 percent if the same method of tax computation is used.

    Brice Conquest
    Kahala

    EDUCATION

    DUE PROCESS HEARINGS HURT PARENTS, TOO

    Rebecca Rosenberg states in a rebuttal to Larry Geller that due process hearings are so scary for some teachers, they've changed jobs (Letters, Aug. 3). As a parent of a special-needs child, my heart bleeds. I can't change jobs! Who's going to look after my child if I burn out? While I have to take time off — without pay — to attend my child's due process hearings, DOE personnel don't have to do this; it counts as a workday for them.

    It is also true that if my child hadn't been reading at just under first-grade level at the end of third grade, she'd still be in public schools. My husband and I were completely educated in public schools and saw no reason to do otherwise for our daughter until they failed her dismally.

    Irene Newhouse
    Kihei, Maui

    HAWAIIAN AIR

    COSTLY 'SUCCESS FEE'

    The Hawaiian Airlines bankruptcy resolution appeared to be highly successful right up to the point where they had to pay the bankruptcy trustee a "success fee" of $8 million.

    Jack M. Schmidt Jr.
    Kailua

    FUNDING MAKIKI LIBRARY MUST LOOK TO CITY

    Recently I had the opportunity to tour the Makiki Community Library, a nonprofit facility that operates out of a city building at Makiki District Park. I appreciated spending time with the dedicated volunteer staff and board members to learn more about the operations of this community gathering place.

    The Makiki Library is not part of the State Public Library System, and based on my discussions with the board members, it does not wish to become a certified library under the state system. Instead, their vision seems to focus on creating a community learning center, where residents can access donated reading material.

    I admire and appreciate the volunteers and board members for all the time and effort they have dedicated to the Makiki Library, but I was struck by the poor condition of the building. It appears that years of neglect, vandalism and lack of funds have resulted in severe deterioration. In addition, the building suffers from a lack of basic upkeep, maintenance and renovations, and does not comply with the Americans with Disabilities Act requirements.

    I was glad to see that the city is investing $1.7 million in needed repairs.

    The state Legislature appropriated a $4.5 million grant-in-aid in state funds for renovations and improvements to the Makiki Community Library. After visiting the facility and weighing all the information available, including the lack of ongoing operational, maintenance and security funding, I do not believe releasing the $4.5 million in state funds is in the best interest of the state taxpayers.

    The building that the Library operates out of is city-owned and city-operated. The city, not the state, is responsible for the building's upkeep and any desired renovations or improvements. While I admire the board's commitment and desire to have this type of "reading room" available to their community, the facility is not a functioning full-time state library with a full-time paid staff to serve the needs of the area, as is the McCully-Mo'ili'ili Library, which is only 1.1 miles away down King Street.

    The state has many pressing needs, and I have the responsibility of balancing those needs against the availability of funding. Although the state revenue outlook is positive and we now have more money to repair and renovate the many state facilities that have been neglected over the years, our state funds are not unlimited.

    Although I am not able to approve the use of these state funds to renovate and repair a city building, my administration is willing to work with the board and the city to locate funding to help with various community-focused programs that the board spoke to me about.

    Linda Lingle
    Governor

    WASTE RECYCLING

    MAUI HOTEL DEMOLITION WILL KEEP DISRUPTION TO MINIMUM

    In response to the Aug. 1 letter "Maui hotel demolition will cause problems": Kapalua Bay LLC (owner of the Kapalua Bay Hotel) and Maui Land & Pineapple Co. would like to assure the author and the Maui community that we are actively evaluating all measures available to minimize the noise, dust and overall disruption the restructuring of the Kapalua Bay Hotel may have on the immediate neighbors and surrounding community.

    In addition, Kapalua Bay LLC has designed a preliminary plan to address the amount of debris our project will generate, with the ultimate goal being to minimize the amount of waste disposed of at the Maui County landfill.

    The preliminary plan calls for much of the rubble generated by the hotel to be processed on-site for reuse as structural fill for the new facilities. Kapalua Bay LLC has begun discussions to salvage materials from the Kapalua Bay Hotel for use at other projects throughout the island. We have also met with local nonprofit organizations to see what materials, such as furniture, they may be able to use at their facilities.

    All material suitable for recycling, such as metals, rubble, drywall, wood and green waste that we will not reuse, will be taken to appropriate recycling centers. While the amount of material not suitable for recycling is currently unknown, our goal is to reuse or recycle up to 90 percent of the material from the existing hotel, thus significantly limiting the impact of our activities on the county landfill.
    The preliminary plan, which will be finalized once a general contractor is hired and is ultimately subject to approval by the County of Maui, was outlined for our employees in the May 13 issue of Ho'omana'o, ML&P's employee newsletter. A copy of this article may be found by visiting http://www.mauiland.com/pdf/vol2issu10.pdf.

    Maui Land & Pineapple Co. is dedicated to protecting and preserving Maui's beauty and natural resources. As we reshape our company and work with Kapalua Bay LLC and our other resort partners to make improvements to the Kapalua Resort, we promise to do so with continued respect for the 'aina and our neighbors.

    Ryan Churchill
    Vice president, community development, Maui Land & Pineapple Co.