Breadmakers rally against low-carb fad
By David Sharp
Associated Press
PORTLAND, Maine — Low-carb bread? That's so 2004.
Pat Wellenbach • Associated Press
The bread industry, hoping for a comeback after last year's low-carb fad, is trying to get people to eat bread because it's good for them — especially when it's made with whole grains the government says we should all have.
With the low-carb diets looking like they are on the decline, American breadmakers are striking back. A new campaign looks to promote bread as a key part of an overall healthy diet. But the industry faces an uphill battle. In 2003, Americans ate 10 pounds per person less of wheat flour than they did three years before that.
Bread makers learned from the low-carb craze that they need to market themselves better. So, three weeks after the government issued guidelines calling for adults to have three 1-ounce servings of whole grains a day, the industry is promoting whole-grain products and starting a campaign promoting the health benefits of bread.
Industry officials say dietary trends are working in their favor, as low-carb peaked early last year. By year's end, they say, sales of fresh bread in supermarkets were down by less than a percentage point in dollar terms, although volume sales were down 4 percent.
"There was an all-out assault on our industry, but people are coming back to bread and are realizing why they loved it in the first place," said Lee Schwebel of Schwebel Baking Co. in Youngstown, Ohio. "Try making a peanut butter and jelly sandwich without bread."
The industry launched a low-carb counterattack last week pointing to benefits of grains as part of an overall diet. The $3.5 million Grains for Life campaign was announced in New York and Washington with billboards, posters and people dancing in bread costumes.
"The message we're trying to get out is it's the calories, not the carbs," said Lori Sachau of the Wheat Foods Council in Colorado.
Critics contend it was predictable that fickle American consumers would eventually tire of the latest diet, but bread industry officials were surprised at how quickly low-carb seemed to fall out of favor. A survey by NPD Group, an independent marketing information company, found the number of American adults on any low-carb diet peaked at 9.1 percent last February and dropped to 3.6 percent by mid-November.
"The path low-carb has taken is not unlike a lot of other stuff except that it burst so fast. It went up very fast. Sometimes when things go up fast, they come down just as fast," said Stan Osman from Interstate Bakeries Corp., maker of Wonder Bread, Twinkies and other baked goods.
But that's not to say the nation is about to see a bread boom. Bread sales were flat even before the obsession with the Atkins, South Beach and other carb-limiting diets, and the industry can't make up for the lost ground overnight.
While bread is still a staple for most Americans, they're not eating it as often as they used to, causing a slow decline that has been offset only by a growing population.
On average, Americans ate 136 pounds of wheat flour in 2003. That's a drop of 10 pounds over a three-year period, Sachau said.
In Portland, Maine, Stephen Lanzalotta opened his Italian bakery in 2000 with bread accounting for about 80 percent of sales. Business dipped in part because of low-carb diets, and bread now accounts for 20 percent of sales.
Lanzalotta stayed in business by increasing his offerings of sandwiches and pastries and expanding his menu with breakfast and Sunday brunch.
"I'm becoming more of a restaurateur than a baker. It's wearing on me. From an ideological point of view, I don't enjoy cooking as much as baking," he said.
Around the corner, the number of low-carb dieters at Anthony's Italian Kitchen has dropped, and they're drifting back to pizza, pasta and panini sandwiches. Owner Tony Barassa used to sell about 50 low-carb lunches a day; now he's lucky to sell a dozen.
Barassa said his customers tell him they got bored with Atkins-style diets, which are heavy on salads, meats, cheeses and eggs. White bread, pasta, potatoes and other carbo-loaded foods are blacklisted.
"It's something you get tired of," he said. "How many omelets can you eat?"
Across town, Big Sky Baking Co. owner Martha Elkus said she's not surprised that whole grains are winning customers.
"We've always maintained that all carbs are not created equal. Whole-grain is a complex carbohydrate. Complex carbs are the best source of energy," she said.
Overall, the shift away from low-carb diets is drawing people back not just to bread but to other products that took a hit, like orange juice, cereals, potatoes, bagels and pasta products, said Joel Crowder of grocer Kroger Co. in Cincinnati.
Meanwhile, many consumers have given up on the diet-inspired products companies created, such as low-carb bread or pasta.
"There were a lot of low-carb products that were rushed to the market that didn't taste good," Crowder said. "That's probably what turned a lot of consumers off."
