honoluluadvertiser.com

Sponsored by:

Comment, blog & share photos

Log in | Become a member
The Honolulu Advertiser

Posted on: Wednesday, January 26, 2005

TASTE
Sharpen up your knowledge of Japanese knives

 •  Graphic: Japanese-style knives

By Wanda A. Adams
Advertiser Food Editor

Chefs and gourmets in the United States are turning East — spending hundreds, even thousands of dollars for Japan-made knives that are fiendishly difficult to keep sharp, disastrously prone to rusting and challenging to learn how to use.

Grant Sato teaches both knife skills and Asian-style cooking at Kapi'olani Community College.

Photos by Deborah Booker • The Honolulu Advertiser


Sato uses various Japanese-style knives for cooking. This shows the thickness of this knife.

The Misono-brand santoku is one of Chef Sato's favorites. He bought one in Japan for $450 some years ago.
A bit farther back from the cutting edge, the trend is expressing itself in a new class of affordable-to-expensive knives, manufactured both in Japan and in the West, that are influenced by the classic styles of Japan, but graced with the easy-care features of Western-style knives.

It's time, in short, to learn your santoku from your gyutou, your yanagi from your usuba.

Santoku is the most common term being used (and misused) to describe a new family of multipurpose knives based on Japanese designs. But the subject is a bit more complex than that — OK, a whole lot more complex, if you're a fanatic, as some chefs have become.

But we'll try to keep this introductory lesson simple.

In western Europe and the United States, the standard everyday kitchen knife is the 10-inch chef's knife — a long, medium-weight knife with a blade shaped like a very elongated triangle, sharpened from both the right and left sides to create a sharp "V." Other knives, such as short-bladed parers, serrated bread slicers, and flexible boning knives play a role. But most Western professionals consider the chef's knife an extension of their arms.

In China, the cleaver plays a similar role, with skilled chefs able to turn this seemingly unwieldy tool to even the most delicate tasks.

In Japan, however, there is a trio of common knife types, any one of which can become a chef's favorite tool, depending on how they were taught, and by whom. The three are: lightweight vegetable knives called santoku, usuba or nakiri; heavier chef's knives known as gyutou or deba; and long, slim slicers known as yanagi, sujihiki and by other names.

"In Japan, we're really trained to use one type of knife for mostly everything," said Japan-born and -trained chef Hiroshi Fukui of Hiroshi Eurasion Tapas at Restaurant Row. "If it's a small thing like peeling vegetables, we're not going to change the knife for that. We're taught to use whatever we have."

LEARN MORE

To find out more about Japanese-style knives and for online sales:

• BladeGallery.com offers knives in price ranges from affordable to stratospheric (Hattori gyutou, $1,250), plus artisan knives made by sought-after craftsmen.

• Japanese-knife.com. This is the site of the Manhattan Japanese knife store, Korin. More than a dozen brands are illustrated, described and sold, including Suisin, Nenox, Glestain, Misono, Masamoto and MAC.

• Worldknives.com offers knives from around the world, including Japan (Masahiro and Hattori/Ryusen).

Because the choice of a knife depends so much on personal feel, all of these sites allow you to return a knife within seven days, provided it hasn't been used.

Bladeforums.com and knifeforums.com are Web sites that delve deeply into such issues as blade geometry and steel recipes. These offer in-depth reports and individuals who answer your questions via postings.

— Los Angeles Times

Fukui's standard knife is a slim-bladed yanagi (sashimi slicer), though he also often uses an usuba (thin-bladed vegetable-cutting knife). Both were given to him by chefs from Japan with whom he worked here; it's common practice, he said, for departing chefs to bequeath their knives to colleagues. He treasures these gifts — as well as a $600 honyaki ("pure steel") yanagi, an extraordinarily hard-bladed knife he bought in Japan, which remains at home, on display, too precious to use.

Grant Sato, chef-instructor at Kapi'olani Community College, who teaches both knife skills and Asian-style cooking, loves the Misono-brand santoku he bought in Japan for $450 some years ago. It is the classic Japanese all-purpose vegetable chopper, with a round handle of long-lasting magnolia wood and a single-bevel blade of carbon steel. He is as careful with it as a mother with her baby, faithfully washing it clean after every use, drying it thoroughly, and literally tucking it into bed — wrapped in a silk cover and placed inside its own case.

Two features of Fukui and Sato's knives characterize classic Japanese cutting tools: the single bevel and the carbon-steel blade.

• The single bevel — an angled blade edge sharpened only from one side — is the key difference between a classic Japanese knife and newer fusion styles. Chefs say this angle has the advantage of causing the food to slide up and out from the blade, rather than sticking to it, so that sashimi, for example, shingles out readily into a beautiful display. Fukui says single-bevel blades allow you to slice more thinly, and the cutting edge is smooth and shiny, an aesthetic difference valued in Japan.

• Carbon-steel blades. Carbon-steel blades take an extremely thin edge, slicing "like buttah." But carbon steel has its drawbacks. The blades need frequent sharpening and therefore wear down more rapidly (though a good knife is going to last many, many years). The ultra-thin edge is more delicate and brittle, and it can become pitted and uneven readily if mistreated. And Sato said a carbon-steel blade will rust literally within hours if it stays wet. "This is not a knife you're going to just slam into the butcher block," he said.

Japanese single-bevel knives are most often designed to be used by the right-handed (left-handedness traditionally had a negative connotation), but you can buy left-handed versions now, Sato explained. And these knives are ideal for the Japanese cutting motion, he said, which employs a down and back (toward the cutter) direction. (Western-style cutting is more up and down.)

The latest trend blends features of both East and West: They are double-bevel knives made of high-carbon stain-resistant steel with Western-style ergonomic handles. Fukui said younger chefs at his restaurant have taken to these. Purists say you get a longer-lived edge at the expense of truly thin and smooth slicing.

You can literally spend whatever you want on a Japanese knife, from as little as $30 for traditional, single-bevel knives of everyday quality to the stratosphere of four-figure prices for hand-made pure steel knives imported from Japan. For a good-quality knife, either Japanese or Western style, you'll have to budget at least $100.

There's one reason in particular for Islanders to pay attention to the Japanese knife trend: These knives are often shorter of blade (7 inches is common for santoku, 8 inches for gyutou), lighter of weight, and more ergonomic of handle than their European counterparts.

For years, my everyday chopping and slicing tool was a 10-inch French-style chef's knife made by Henckels in Germany. I kept it well-sharpened and away from the dishwasher, but it was overlarge for my stubby-fingered hands and an extended bout of chopping left me with a fatigued wrist and arm.

Then one day I was watching a chef in a sushi bar cutting impossibly thin slices of carrot at a pace that made my eyes go blurry. And I knew what I wanted: a shorter, lighter knife with a thin blade.

Today, my everyday knife is a rather attenuated but well-balanced instrument with a molded handle that comfortably fits my hand. It works very well for most purposes. The only time I pull out a different knife is when I'm boning meats or hacking through an entire carcass.

• • •