honoluluadvertiser.com

Sponsored by:

Comment, blog & share photos

Log in | Become a member
The Honolulu Advertiser

Posted on: Tuesday, March 22, 2005

Tree trimmers get busier

By James Gonser
Advertiser Urban Honolulu Writer

Tree-trimming companies are seeing a slight increase in the number of calls from people worried about large trees on their properties after a 12-year-old girl was critically injured when a Norfolk Island pine crashed through her second-story bedroom wall in Manoa.

Worried about a tree?

• To ask questions about a tree that is on city property, call the city Department of Parks and Recreation, 971-7151.

• On state land, information on trees depends on whether it is in a state park or other areas. Call 587-0320 to be directed to the correct division.

• If you are concerned about a tree on private property, arborist Mark Leon recommends calling a qualified, certified arborist. For a referral, ask a trusted arborist, the Outdoor Circle or a community group such as Malama O Manoa.

Mark Leon, a certified arborist with Sunshine Landscape Co. Inc., said calls to his company are up about 10 percent since the March 15 accident.

"They want to know what are the risk factors," Leon said. "They ask for an evaluation and if I can do a visual inspection."

It costs about $175 for a visual inspection and $375 for a documented evaluation, Leon said.

Wilbur D. Dorothy of AB Tree Care Inc. said he has had only two calls, but one of the trees he looked at in Saint Louis Heights should be cut down.

"It's a good example of someone being concerned about their tree," Dorothy said. "I would take it out. If anything happened, it could wipe out a whole bunch of houses."

There are many Norfolk pine trees in Saint Louis Heights, and the soil is not deep on the rocky hillside, meaning reduced stability, he said.

"There are a lot of pine trees out there that should come down, but it costs money," he said, adding that the typical cost to remove a large pine tree is $3,000 to $4,000.

In Manoa, the city-owned tree that fell was inspected for disease and stability in November. The tree fell about 4:50 a.m. in the 2300 block of Beckwith Street, leaving Julia Engle with head injuries, according to police. The girl is still unconscious, but improving slightly, according to her family's attorney, Rick Fried.

Tree experts for the city and the family are studying the dead tree to try to determine why it suddenly fell. According to city officials, the tree was "topped" more than a decade ago. That may have contributed to it becoming diseased, Leon said.

The city is responsible for maintaining about 225,000 trees. The city Department of Parks and Recreation Division of Urban Forestry has about 110 employees who maintain trees in city botanical parks, regular parks, medial strips and along city streets throughout the island.

City spokesman Bill Brennan said there have been a few calls from residents asking for trees in their neighborhood to be inspected. That tree and others in the area were deeded to the city 11 years ago from the state Department of Land and Natural Resources, he said, and the tree was topped before that.

"Instead of cutting a tree from underneath and thinning it out, there was a practice back then where they just chopped off the top to make it shorter," Brennan said. "I guess it was a somewhat accepted practice until they realized that after you cut them off it doesn't grow back exactly the same way."

Arborist Leon said topping often leads to the death of a tree.

"Topping is the number one worst thing you can do to a tree," Leon said. "I'm really hoping (this incident) will bring more awareness to topping of trees. That you actually might have taken an otherwise healthy tree and now just created a hazard."

Reach James Gonser at 535-2431 or jgonser@honoluluadvertiser.com.