Posted on: Saturday, May 7, 2005
Wall Street's 'sheriff' aims at spyware purveyors
By Michael Gormley
Associated Press
ALBANY, N.Y. — The windowless, cluttered 10-by-15-foot storeroom on the third floor of a Manhattan government building seems an unlikely setting for Attorney General Eliot Spitzer's next big thing.
Julie Jacobson • Associated Press "There has been a vacuum of enforcement to date," said Benjamin Edelman, a Harvard University student who specializes in researching spyware.
Though Spitzer may get complaints that he is attacking legitimate companies, Edelman said, the "fact is, there are lots of surprisingly big companies making serious money from these tactics. So Spitzer's intervention in users' defense is much appreciated and quite helpful."
The problem has become epidemic as people spend more time online and spyware developers get more aggressive.
Some repair shops blame spyware, particularly the subset of adware, for more than half the trouble they're seeing. Although users still get such programs attached to games, screensavers and file-sharing software, often without their knowledge, newer techniques need no user intervention whatsoever and rely on security flaws in Microsoft operating systems and browsers.
THE PEST: Spyware and adware, which sneak onto computers without their owners' knowledge, often causing systems to slow or crash.
THE BATTLE: New York Attorney General Eliot Spitzer has sued one company he considers a spyware distributor. His office suggests other cases are on the way and no company is immune, not even those that advertise using such techniques. THE PATTERN: The investigation recalls crusades against conflicts of interest among Wall Street stock analysts, dealers of mutual funds and insurance brokers. Spitzer is running for governor. Enter Spitzer, a candidate for New York governor in 2006 who is best known for his high-profile crusades against conflicts of interest in business but hasn't ignored cyberspace. Last year, he settled a spam suit against OptInRealBig.com of Colorado, and his year-old probe of a "spam ring" continues. In pursuing spyware, last week's civil lawsuit against Intermix Media Inc. of Los Angeles is likely just the opening salvo.
Spitzer accused the company of secretly installing software that delivers nuisance pop-up advertisements and can slow and crash personal computers. Spitzer said such programs are fraudulent and threaten to discourage e-commerce.
"Mr. Spitzer has put a match to this and it will be interesting to see just how many volleys take place," said David Moll of Webroot Software Inc., an anti-spyware vendor.
Intermix denies any fraud or use of spyware, saying many of the practices in dispute were established by previous leadership. The company insists it is committed to the Internet's best practices.
Its competitors, meanwhile, insist their programs do not spy.
"We strongly support efforts to clean up spyware and rid the Internet of malicious software," said Daniel Todd of 180 Solutions, a major adware company. "As a company that is providing free software and products to consumers, we think that working with technology experts, legal scholars, researchers and anti-spyware companies to establish such standards is a top priority."
Good thing, Spitzer said.
"People are fed up with adware and spyware," he said in an interview. "They feel as though they've lost control of their computers, and they want something to be done."
While Congress and about half the states — including New York — debate legislation to clamp down on spyware, Spitzer is taking business fraud and consumer protection investigation into the 21st century.
But purveyors of spyware and adware and even companies that advertise in the surreptitious downloads fear exactly that from the Democrat dubbed the "Sheriff of Wall Street."
Eliot Spitzer's team battling illegal spyware and adware include, from left, Ken Dreifach, chief of internet bureau; Vanessa Ip, chief investigator; and Justin Brookman, assistant attorney general.
The Federal Trade Commission filed a major spyware case last fall. But it is understaffed, said Ari Schwartz of the Center for Democracy and Technology in Washington, D.C.
CYBERSPACE WAR
