honoluluadvertiser.com

Sponsored by:

Comment, blog & share photos

Log in | Become a member
The Honolulu Advertiser

Posted on: Friday, May 20, 2005

Home again

By Catherine E. Toth
Advertiser Staff Writer

At 25, Kristina Chang is already making more money than most college graduates her age.

The Chang family: Sheri, 21; Annette, 60; Kristina, 25; and Richard, 62, talk about Kristina's living at home.

Jeff Widener • The Honolulu Advertiser

But despite her above-average salary, she still lives at her parents' home in Salt Lake — in the same bedroom she grew up in — hoping to save enough money to buy her own place someday.

She doesn't want to throw money at rent. And she doesn't want to buy a fixer-upper.

So for now she's hunkering down, stashing her extra cash for a down payment on a two-bedroom condo somewhere between 'Aiea and Kahala. With air conditioning and parking. Away from the freeway. With a full kitchen and a washer/dryer in the unit. Pool optional.

"I want something nice," said Chang, an account manager for Kraft Food Service Hawai'i. "I'd rather save up for something I want."

She wants to move out, be independent, have some privacy. But for now, she's OK with living with her parents. The extra money she has available from living rent-free, she spends on herself. A new laptop here, a trip to Singapore there.

These are luxuries she knows she couldn't afford if she were paying off a mortgage.

"It's totally frustrating because you're in a Catch-22," Chang said. "I can't rent because I won't save money. But if I buy something, I'd be starving. I just don't understand why (home prices) are so high. Maybe it's the cost of living in paradise."

Across the United States, parents are seeing their empty nests fill back up — with their own kids. Some call these returning young adults the "boomerang generation." They leave and they come back, often because they can't afford to live on their own.

Soaring prices

"Because I've lived here my whole life, I don't feel very restrained," Kristina Chang says.

4 million

Number of Americans ages 25 to 34 who live with their parents

16 million

Number of American families who have at least one child older than 18 living at home

57

Percent of 2004 college students who planned to move back home after graduation

50

Percent of 2003 graduates who are still living at home

$19,000

Typical undergraduate college loan debt

Sources: 2000 Census, MonsterTRAK, Census Bureau's American Housing Survey, United States Student Association

Nationally, there are about 4 million Americans ages 25 to 34 who live with their parents, according to the latest Census.

They return home — or, in Hawai'i, often never move out — because of a tight job market, high housing costs, debt, divorce or health problems.

In Hawai'i, it's not uncommon for kids to live at home until they're married, and the trend is becoming even more pronounced. One major cause: real-estate prices, which have hit all-time highs in recent months.

The median price for a single-family home on O'ahu jumped to $550,000 in March, 25.3 percent more than a year earlier. The median price for a condo reached $230,000, 21.1 percent higher than March 2004.

Compare that to average salaries: In Hawai'i, the average annual pay is about $33,700, according to the Bureau of Labor Statistics.

"You can't have people working minimum wage and buying million-dollar homes," said Christine Heath, executive director of the Hawaii Counseling and Education Center and a licensed marriage and family therapist. "Something has to change ... or this will become more common."

Money is tight

These adult children who live with their parents aren't all single.

Denny and Luana Yoshikawa went house-hunting in Kane'ohe about two years ago, when Luana was pregnant with their son. They found three homes they liked, all around $400,000. But Denny Yoshikawa, a 36-year-old aircraft mechanic with Hawaiian Airlines, was scheduled to deploy for six months with the Air National Guard — just after his wife was scheduled to give birth. The couple decided it would be better to live with his parents in Kane'ohe until he came home.

It's two years later and they're still living with his parents, crowding into a small bedroom in the three-bedroom home.

"I didn't want to be in a new home by myself," said Luana Yoshikawa, 26, who's finishing up her bachelor's degree in family resources at the University of Hawai'i-Manoa this year. "We decided that then was not the time (to buy)."

The Yoshikawas also thought they could save up money for a down payment and lower their bills by staying with Denny's parents. But regret is now setting in. At least one of the homes they had considered is now valued at $700,000.

Even with Yoshikawa's two incomes, the pair can't afford the kind of home they want, with enough space for a growing family, without having to invest a lot of money in major renovations.

"It's ridiculous," said Luana Yoshikawa, watching her son, Dylan, 2, play with blocks on the floor. "I can't see an end to it. How will Hawai'i families continue to make it here? I don't see it getting better. Everyone's not getting paid more to live here, but living costs are going up.

"You have to be a millionaire to buy a home and raise a family here."

Home comforts

While most college-educated boomerangers aren't making six-figure salaries, they are getting paid more than those who graduated a year before.

The National Association of Colleges and Employers says annual salaries in business, accounting, economics, finance, engineering and computer science have increased this year, and that has benefited Hawai'i residents.

That might sound promising to twentysomethings, but they have to consider Hawai'i's cost of living.

"Prices keep going up, and for people starting out, it's hard," said Kristina's dad, Richard, an engineer who used to work in real estate. "But once they make the leap, they'll be OK. It's that first step, that's the hardest."

The allure of staying home is obvious. Dinner's always ready. The fridge is full. Mom and Dad help foot the bills.

But there are down sides, the most apparent being a lack of privacy and a return to traditional family roles. They'll always be kids to their parents.

"The biggest (challenge) is who's got the power," Heath said. "With parents with underage children, parents have the power. But with adult children, there's always a question of who has the power and control. Adult children tend to resent their parents still parenting them. But they don't see things that need to be done around the house. ... Children are blind to what parents have always done, and that causes some resentment in the parent.

"There is a shift in thinking that has to occur," Heath added. "Who's taking care of me? Me or you?"

Living with her in-laws has worked out well for Luana Yoshikawa. For one, she has free baby-sitters on the weekends.

"They've kept me sane," she said. "They're really helpful. To have them around is a huge relief for me. ... It's really important for Dylan to spend time with other people than just me. And as grandparents, they have a whole different perspective on life. They provide great insight for me and a solid foundation of morals for him."

In fact, the living arrangement has worked out so well, the Yoshikawas are considering building an extension to the family home so they can live there permanently. They're waiting to talk with the entire family — including her husband's two brothers — before making a decision.

"This is their house," Luana Yoshikawa said. "I think it's important to get everyone's feeling on this."

In Kristina Chang's case, her living at home isn't a concern to her siblings. All but one live there, too. Including her parents and grandfather, six people live in the Salt Lake house. Her older sister is in a separate unit on the property with her husband and their two children. In all, 10 of them live on the property.

"Because I've lived here my whole life, I don't feel very restrained," Kristina Chang said. "(My parents) are very accepting. They don't make me feel like I'm a child. We do have dinner together. And if I'm not going to be home, they ask me where I'm going. But we're pretty close, so I don't mind. If I were in New York, though, I would be a totally different 25-year-old."

Chang has been looking at condos in her price range — $150,000 to $200,000 — but hasn't found one she likes.

Luckily, she gets along with her parents and siblings, though the crowding can be stressful. And of course, there's no privacy.

"You can't have a romantic dinner with a date or anything," Chang said, laughing. "But at least you can get your whole family's opinion on him."

Reach Catherine E. Toth at 535-8103 or ctoth@honoluluadvertiser.com.

• • •

All in the family

Here's helpful advice for adult children — and their parents — to live together in an adult way:

Shift your mindset: Both parents and children need to recognize that they are all adults now. That means parents shouldn't treat their adult children like 8-year-olds and adult children shouldn't expect to be catered to by their parents. This role confusion can lead to resentment on both sides. "On one level, (adult children) kind of expect parents to shoulder the main costs, but on another level, they want to be independent and not told what to do," said Christine Heath, licensed marriage and family therapist.

Sit down and talk: The first thing families should do is talk about expectations in an open and honest way. "The family has to sit down and regroup," Heath said. "Change the family rules, get everyone to buy into that, so they can all live in harmony and not feel like they're being a burden or being taken advantage of."

Ask for help: If adult children become financial burdens on their parents, it's reasonable for parents to ask them to pay rent or help with utilities. The ideal situation would be for parents to take that money and put it into a savings account for their children, Heath said. That money could later be used toward a down payment on their own place.

Pitch in: In any living situation, recognizing the need to help out is critical in creating a supportive, peaceful haven for everyone. "Children need to understand that their parents are going to need more help," Heath said. "It's what I call being in a state of service to each other, where people are consciously thinking about how they can help. In particular, children have to shift their perception of being taken care of to being helpful."

— Catherine E. Toth