Sponsored by:

Comment, blog & share photos

Log in | Become a member
The Honolulu Advertiser
Posted on: Thursday, November 10, 2005

From war to obscurity no longer

By Suzanne Roig
Advertiser East Honolulu Writer

On this Makapu'u hillside can still be found pieces of the Navy patrol plane that crashed on a rainy night more than 63 years ago.


spacer spacer


Two military planes went down on O'ahu the night of April 5, 1942.

In the first crash, a Navy plane went down 200 yards south of the Makapu'u lighthouse. On board were:

  • Ensign William Howe of Nashville, Tenn., the pilot.

  • Ensign George Doll of Detroit, the co-pilot.

  • Seaman 1st Class William Allan of California.

  • Radio Mate 3rd Class Charles Andrews of Cleveland.

  • Aviation Munitions Mate 3rd Class Delbert Berchot of Tacoma, Wash.

  • Aviation Machinist Mate 3rd Class Harvey Hayman, of Rye, N.Y.

  • Aviation Machinist Mate 2nd Class Billie Herrin of Malone, Texas.

  • Aviation Radio Mate 2nd Class Jack Parrish of South Nashville, Tenn.

  • Aviation Machinist Mate 1st Class Orren Roberts of Los Angeles.

    Also that night, an Army plane crashed into the Pali. On board were:

  • 1st Lt. Charles Allan Jr.

  • 2nd Lt. James Bushee

  • 1st Lt. Ward Cox Jr.

  • Staff Sgt. Mathias Donart

  • Sgt. Wilbert Gravitt

  • Staff Sgt. Edward Hakes

  • Cpl. John Morris

  • Cpl. John Muckey

  • Staff Sgt. Luther Perry Jr.

  • Master Sgt. Jesse Schneider

    The Hawai'i Aviation Preservation Society plans to place a granite marker at that site next year.

    Source: WFI Research

  • spacer spacer


    For more information on historic World War II airplane crash sites, go to www.hiavps.com.

    spacer spacer

    The slab at lower left marks where a monument will be put up to honor the nine men who died in the 1942 crash at Makapu'u. The Hawai'i Aviation Preservation Society has been behind the recognition project.


    spacer spacer

    MAKAPU'U It was April 5, 1942, four months after the Pearl Harbor attack, and a Navy flight crew of nine men patrolled the waters off O'ahu.

    The weather was bad rainy, windy, with poor visibility. They had flown more than 12 hours on a long-range patrol, searching for enemy subs and ships.

    The crew was aboard one of four Navy planes that flew out of Kane'ohe Naval Air Station that day. One returned to Kane'ohe before the storm worsened. Another went to Kaua'i, and a third touched down at Pearl Harbor. But the crew of the PBY-5A "Catalina" was dangerously off course.

    In their confusion, the crew mistook the lighthouse beacon from Makapu'u for the Barbers Point lighthouse.

    The plane slammed into the hillside 200 yards south of the Makapu'u lighthouse.

    All nine men died in the crash, which has remained shrouded in obscurity.

    At the time, the Islands were under martial law and the military didn't report such accidents to the newspapers, said Colin Perry, a historian with the Hawai'i Aviation Preservation Society. During the war, there were crashes almost daily on O'ahu. From 1942 to 1945, there were about 800 aviation deaths on the island, Perry said.

    "No one has ever done anything for these men," he said.

    The preservation society doesn't want those deaths forgotten. After months of planning and working with the state Department of Land and Natural Resources, the society has obtained permission to erect a granite monument listing the men's names and ranks.

    The monument marker will be installed at the site Wednesday.

    At first, the society didn't know the home states of the Navy men. That information came from WFI Research Group, an Internet aviation database of more than 700,000 World War II aviation and at-sea casualties.

    To this day, one can find some rusted-out landing gear, engine parts, and small pieces of metal at the crash site. The society was able to determine the type of plane by matching aircraft data plates found at the site, said Perry, a retired Air Force and airline pilot.

    "I've looked at all the archive stuff in Washington, D.C., and in Florida (the Naval Air Museum in Pensacola), and the only documentation I've found is the War Diary that gave the account of the crash," he said. (The War Diary is a military log documenting World War II flights).

    But with the strict wartime censorship that was imposed on the media and personal mail, there isn't much information on these military crashes.

    The Navy plane wasn't even the only one to go down that night. An Army plane crashed into the Pali, killing all 10 aboard. The preservation society plans to place a granite marker at that site next year.

    The small group that makes up the Hawai'i Aviation Preservation Society has worked for the past eight months to mark the spot at Makapu'u. The society is responsible for other such markers along the 'Aiea Loop Trail, the Pali Lookout and the Honouliuli Contour Trail and at the former Barbers Point Naval Air Station.

    No date has been set for a dedication, but the group hopes to have a Navy chaplain say a prayer for the men who died.

    "They died in obscurity," Perry said. "It will be nice to know that someone doesn't forget."

    Reach Suzanne Roig at sroig@honoluluadvertiser.com.

    • • •