honoluluadvertiser.com

Sponsored by:

Comment, blog & share photos

Log in | Become a member
The Honolulu Advertiser
Posted on: Friday, August 18, 2006

Reagan collection pays tribute to Gipper

By Terry Lawson
Detroit Free Press

Ronald Reagan as George Gipp in the 1940 film "Knute Rockne: All American." The flick is part of a collection of Reagan films released on DVD this week.

Advertiser library photo

spacer spacer

It is one of the great movie-biz gags, and probably entirely apocryphal: Upon learning that Ronald Reagan would be running for office, an aide to Warner Brothers head Jack Warner informs his boss.

"Get this: Ronald Reagan for governor."

"Nah," says Reagan's former boss, making a snap casting decision, "Bob Cummings for governor. Reagan for best friend."

The joke refers to the perception that Reagan, despite his all-American good looks, was never really a leading man, that he had neither the versatility, depth nor charisma to seduce audiences. His presidency certainly dispelled the opinion about the third failing. Now a new "Signature Collection" (Warner) of five features Reagan made during his 1940-1952 tenure lets us address the first two.

The best known of the five is the earliest (1940), "Knute Rockne: All American," with Pat O'Brien as the famed Notre Dame coach and Reagan in the supporting role of the ill-fated player George Gipp, the man who provides the team's inspiration and Reagan's eventual tagline "Win just one for the Gipper." If less than Capra-esque in its sentimentalized review of Americana, it remains an inspirational entertainment.

In just about everybody's opinion, including his own, Reagan's best role and best performance were in 1942 "Kings Row," in which he shares the screen with Cummings. They're best pals in this small-town melodrama, replete with secrets and revelations, given gravity by Sam Wood's direction and James Wong Howe's terrific cinematography — and by a shattering twist that most people already know, but won't be spoiled here — just in case.

"The Hasty Heart," a story whose origins as a stage play are all too apparent, has Reagan again in a supporting part and back in the hospital. This time he's a wounded World War II soldier in the same ward as Scottish officer Richard Todd, who has not been told his diagnosis. Patricia Neal, in one of her earliest appearances, is the unit nurse. Reagan's in yet another uniform in 1952's "The Winning Team," a lackluster sentimentalized biography of legendary baseball pitcher Grover Cleveland Alexander; Doris Day portrays his supportive wife.

The most intriguing title in the set is 1951's "Storm Warning," a noir-ish drama starring Ginger Rogers as a woman who discovers the husband of her sister (Doris Day) is a Ku Klux Klanner. Reagan's the crusading DA attempting to bring him to justice.

The set contains Warner's usual array of well-chosen, matinee-style extras — a Porky Pig cartoon tips the cap to Reagan's stint as baseball announcer, while an Oscar-winning short featuring the Marine Band hits the patriotic note.

The other new "Signature Collection" set (Warner) with six films starring James Stewart is a serious bargain, considering it contains a new remaster of 1953's "The Naked Spur," directed by Anthony Mann.

Filmed in gorgeous Technicolor, it sets a bitter-to-the-point-of-sociopathic bounty hunter Stewart on the trail of outlaw Robert Ryan, and on an odyssey in which he will rediscover his humanity with some help from Ryan's Calamity Jane-style sidekick, Janet Leigh.

Filling out the package:

  • 1957's "The Spirit of St. Louis" with aviation-loving Stewart cast as Charles Lindbergh, despite being about twice the age Lindy was when he attempted his Atlantic crossing.

  • 1949's "The Stratton Story," in which he plays Monty Stratton, the White Sox pitcher who didn't let the loss of a leg keep him off the mound.

  • 1959's "The FBI Story," an officially sanctioned and sanitized account of the birth and history of the G-Men as seen through the eyes of agent Stewart.

  • Two late-career Westerns in which he was teamed with Henry Fonda, the 1968 drama "Firecreek" and the 1970 farce (directed by Gene Kelly) "The Cheyenne Social Club."

    Extras again include period-specific cartoons, shorts and newsreels.

    ALSO NEW THIS WEEK

    French director Eric Rohmer began grouping his observational, naturalistic and richly detailed dramas about human relationships into groups with 1963's wistful "La BoulangEre de Monceau" ("The Bakery Girl of Monceau"). It was the first of what would compose "Six Moral Tales," now collected by the Criterion Collection. "BoulangEre" starred future director Barbet Schroeder as a law student whose affection for pastries is a consequence of his crush on the Parisian who sells them.

    It would be followed the same year by "La Carriere de Suzanne," about two friends' attraction for the same woman, then the 17th-century period piece "La Collectionneuse," and then the three films that made his international reputation: 1969's "My Night at Maud's," 1970's beguiling "Claire's Knee" and "1972's "Love in the Afternoon." Only the last three have been available on DVD. Now all six films have been impeccably restored, remastered and outfitted with commentaries, interviews and more extras.

    TV ON DVD

  • "The Simpsons — The Complete Eighth Season" (Fox).

  • "Surface — The Complete First Season" (Universal).

  • "The Weird Al Show" (Shout! Factory).