Few consumers abuse bankruptcy, new report says
By Michelle Singletary
By Michelle Singletary
WASHINGTON — In what will undoubtedly be the first of many "I told you so" reports, the National Association of Consumer Bankruptcy Attorneys has found that, overwhelmingly, people who file for bankruptcy protection aren't deadbeats who went on shopping sprees with the intention of shirking their debts.
That's quite contrary to what was being claimed by supporters of a new federal bankruptcy law that went into effect in October.
For years, those proponents argued that billions of dollars were being lost because people were simply being allowed to walk away from their debts.
"As retailers, we have seen first-hand the dramatic effect bankruptcy has had on both consumers' finances and on our ability to serve the public," wrote Steve Pfister, senior vice president for government relations of the National Retail Federation, in a letter to House members as the bankruptcy bill was being debated. "These filings ultimately cost the tens of millions of households we serve hundreds of dollars each in unseen costs every year. Unfortunately, many of those losses are the result of misuse of the law by irresponsible, higher-income filers."
On the day President Bush signed the bankruptcy bill, he said: "In recent years, too many people have abused the bankruptcy laws. They've walked away from debts even when they had the ability to repay them."
The new law now requires people to get credit counseling before they can file for bankruptcy protection. The premise behind this provision is that by forcing people to get counseling, it will show that many bankruptcy filers in fact have enough money left over after taking care of their essential expenses to repay creditors.
I spent several years reporting on bankruptcy, and I saw no evidence (academic or anecdotal) to support claims that scores of people were gaming the system.
Now, in the first analysis of the tens of thousands of people who have undergone credit counseling since the law passed, the bankruptcy attorneys association found that nearly all (97 percent) of the debtors really and truly couldn't pay their debts.
The association examined data provided by six large and small credit counseling firms from a cross section of the country. All of the firms have been authorized by the U.S. Justice Department's Executive Office for U.S. Trustees to provide the required prebankruptcy counseling. In total, the firms that were surveyed counseled 61,355 consumers.
Four out of five filers felt forced to seek bankruptcy protection because of a job loss, catastrophic medical expenses or the death of a spouse, according to the report, "Bankruptcy Reform's Impact: Where Are All the Deadbeats?"
Fewer than one out of 20 consumers (3.3 percent) were candidates for paying off what they owe under a debt management plan, the report indicated. With a plan, a debtor makes one monthly payment to a credit-counseling agency. The agency then distributes the money according to a payment schedule worked out with the person's creditors.
Creditors may agree to reduce interest rates or waive certain fees if you are repaying through a debt plan, although this is happening less and less as more people sign up for such plans. Typically, it takes 36 to 60 months to repay debts through a debt management plan.
The highest estimate of consumers being able to make repayments under a credit counseling debt plan was 5 percent, with the low being in the 1 percent to 2 percent range, according to the report.
"The masses of expected deadbeats who were supposed to be identified under the new law and forced into debt management plans have not materialized," the association's report concludes.