honoluluadvertiser.com

Sponsored by:

Comment, blog & share photos

Log in | Become a member
The Honolulu Advertiser
Posted on: Monday, October 16, 2006

Automated system cut power to all

By Rick Daysog and Rob Perez
Advertiser Staff Writers

Traffic signals all over the island went dark, including this one at the intersection of Kapi'olani Boulevard and Kalakaua Avenue.

JOAQUIN SIOPACK | The Honolulu Advertiser

spacer spacer

18 MINUTES TO BLACKOUT: HOW O'AHU LOST ITS POWER

The earthquake that triggered the daylong, islandwide power outage occurred more than 150 miles from O'ahu, but it set in motion an automated shutdown of the entire power grid. At 7:09 a.m., the shaking from the magnitude 6.6 quake off the Kohala Coast of the Big Island shuts down two of 13 generators operating at the time. To avoid overloading and damaging the Hawaiian Electric Co. system, computers automatically start shedding customers to try to match demand with generating capacity of the remaining units. When that doesn't work, more generators automatically shut down — a process that repeats itself until the entire system goes offline at 7:27 a.m., leaving all 291,000 HECO customers without power.

CHRONOLOGY OF THE BLACKOUT

7:09: A 90-megatwatt generator at HECO's Kahe power plant shuts down, along with a 55-megawatt unit at its Downtown Honolulu plant.

7:12: A 142-megawatt unit – one of the two largest HECO-owned units in the system – shuts down at Kahe.

7:14: Four more units – three owned by companies from which HECO purchases power – trip off:

  • A unit owned by Kalaeloa Partners that was capable of generating 90 megawatts at Campbell Industrial Park.

  • A 46-megawatt HPOWER unit at Campbell.

  • An 180-megawatt unit, owned by AES, also at Campbell.

  • A 142-megawatt HECO unit, one of two that are the largest the utility owns, at Kahe.

    7:17: A 90-megawatt Kahe generator.

    7:18: Four units – two 90-megawatt and two 60 megawatt – at HECO's Waiau power plant.

    7:27: A 90-megawatt Kahe unit knocks off.

    HOURS TO RESTORING POWER

    While the shutdown was automated, restoring power is not. HECO does it manually to protect the system from damage. Generators slowly are powered up, and customer circuits are pulled off the main transmission lines to avoid overtaxing the system as it is brought back to life. As each generator comes back online, pockets of customers systematically are added. Here's the running tally:

    By noon: 571 customers in Pearl City.

    1 p.m.: 5,100, including those in 'Aiea and Pearl City.

    3 p.m.: 34,000, mostly along the Leeward Coast (including Nanakuli, Wai'anae, Makaha and 'Ewa Beach).

    4 p.m.: 46,000, including 'Ewa, Kunia and parts of Mililani.

    5:30 p.m.: 74,000-plus, including Wahiawa, the airport area, Hickam Air Force Base, Pearl Harbor, Waialua and Makakilo (about 25 percent of the island)

    6:30 p.m.: 83,000, including Sand Island, Iwilei and parts of Kaka'ako.

    8 p.m.: 95,000, including Kahala and more of Kaka'ako.

  • spacer spacer

    Hawaiian Electric Co. officials said all 291,000 O'ahu customers lost power after yesterday's earthquakes because an automated system shut down the grid to prevent severe damage.

    HECO said the earthquakes, one with a magnitude of 6.6, caused two generators on O'ahu to shut down. The two — one at Kahe Point and the other at Aloha Tower Downtown — accounted for about 12 percent of the generating capacity of the system at the time.

    Once those generators stopped producing, HECO's automated system started shutting off power to customers, so demand would not overwhelm the 11 generators that were still working.

    HECO could not say last night why the automated system needed to shut down power to the entire island 18 minutes after the two generators went off line, instead of just shutting off just 12 percent of the island.

    Once the power was off, it took HECO more than 12 hours to restore electricity to most of O'ahu.

    "We appreciate everyone's patience, and we know it is frustrating. We're doing it carefully and slowly because of the need to ensure that we do not create outages that are longer term," said HECO spokeswoman Lynne Unemori.

    "That is why we have to do it very slowly and methodically. You don't want to create imbalances and end up with problems that are longer term," said Unemori.

    HECO said it had to bring neighborhoods back incrementally to avoid overloading their circuits and causing a more prolonged blackout.

    As of 10 last night, about 46 percent of O'ahu customers were still without power, while electricity had been restored to most of the Neighbor Island areas hit by outages.

    T.C. Cheng, a University of Southern California electrical engineering professor with expertise in power systems, said he wasn't surprised that O'ahu's power was down for most of the day while service was restored more quickly on the other islands.

    Cheng noted that New York experienced a citywide outage in the 1960s, and it took five days to get that system back online. The overall technology hasn't changed much since, said Cheng.

    "The bigger (the system), the worse it could be," said Cheng, who noted that Hawai'i, unlike California and other Mainland states, cannot tap nearby states for their power needs.

    Although the utility was hoping to have all power restored by last night, there could be pockets of the island without electricity for longer periods, and the utility would have to check those areas to find out why, HECO officials said.

    The utility also had to manually disconnect circuits of customers hooked to the large transmission lines to prevent damage as the system was brought back online, HECO officials said.

    Neighborhoods closer to the main power plants at Waiau, Kahe Point and Aloha Tower were restored first because of their proximity to those plants, Unemori said.

    The company then began restoring electricity to more distant neighborhoods.

    Yesterday's power outage knocked out street lights and shut down grocery stores, retailers and gasoline pumps. Heavy call volume also clogged O'ahu's wireless networkings, making it difficult to place cell phone calls.

    In explaining why O'ahu customers had to wait longer than Neighbor Islanders to get power restored, Unemori and company spokesman Jose Dizon said O'ahu's system relies on larger, more complicated generating units that take longer to return to normal operations than the smaller, diesel-powered ones on the other islands.

    If generators are brought back online too quickly and something happens, the utility would have to start the process all over again, they said.

    "It could cause damage that can take weeks or months to fix," said Dizon.

    According to Unemori, the power failure occurred when earthquakes knocked generators off line at HECO's Downtown and Kahe power plants.

    HECO's computerized system immediately began to shut down customers. The imbalance caused by the downed generators prompted HECO's computer system to began a process of automatically shutting off customers to try to match demand with the remaining generating capacity.

    When the shutting off of customers failed to adequately reduce demand, the system started automatically shutting off other generators to prevent damage to them. That process was repeated several times until all of O'ahu was without power at 7:27 a.m.

    "This is a situation where the system worked as designed," Unemori said.

    Reach Rick Daysog at rdaysog@honoluluadvertiser.com and Rob Perez at rperez@honoluluadvertiser.com.

    • • •