honoluluadvertiser.com

Sponsored by:

Comment, blog & share photos

Log in | Become a member
The Honolulu Advertiser
Posted on: Friday, April 27, 2007

Teachers contract hinges on last ballots

StoryChat: Comment on this story

By Dan Nakaso
Advertiser Staff Writer

Special education instructor Gwen Yoshizawa, left, third-grade teacher Sharon Kunihisa and second-grade teacher Nolan Nakashima voted at Kaimuki High School yesterday afternoon. They all work at Wilson Elementary School in Kahala.

REBECCA BREYER | The Honolulu Advertiser

spacer spacer

Hawai'i teachers will have to wait for absentee ballots to be turned in by Wednesday before they'll know whether they have a new contract that calls for pay raises and random drug testing.

Some 60 percent of Hawai'i's teachers — or nearly 8,000 people — cast ballots at 25 polling places on all islands yesterday on whether to accept a new two-year contract.

But 1,900 absentee ballots are still outstanding and "could sway the outcome of the vote," the union's president, Roger Takabayashi, said last night.

Teachers have until Wednesday to turn in their absentee ballots, when the results of the votes will be announced, he said.

If approved, the contract would allow mandatory random drug testing of teachers and drug tests for cause.

The proposal also would give the more than 13,000 members of the Hawai'i State Teachers Association a 4 percent raise at the start of the next school year, a step movement in the second semester and another 4 percent raise at the start of the second semester in 2008.

Teachers who serve as band directors, drama coaches, chorus directors, grade level chairpersons and agricultural teachers also would see their supplementary pay increase by 25 percent per year under the agreement.

But the issue of teacher drug testing divided the HSTA, which decided not to endorse the latest offer.

Takabayashi believes this is the first time the union's board of directors has sent a tentative contract to its members without a recommendation either for or against a contract proposal.

Delegates to the HSTA's annual convention this month were divided over the Lingle administration's drug-testing proposal.

Yesterday, Ai Curt and Rita Kalaukoa, both social studies teachers at Kalani High School, voted against the proposed contract because of the drug-testing provision.

"Our arms are being twisted by the governor," Kalaukoa said. "It's basically take it or leave it."

Kalaukoa believes that the 13,000 unionized teachers are "being used as political pawns in this game. That's what's angering so many teachers."

"I'm a parent, too, and I understand what they're trying to get at with drug testing," she said. "But I'm not playing this game."

Debbie Nishihira, a computer teacher at Kuhio Elementary School, voted for the contract proposal but wants to see clear procedures for addressing the issue of false-positive test results among teachers.

"I'm hoping they work out the kinks for false positives," Nishihira said.

If ratified, the agreement will require the HSTA to work with the state to design drug testing procedures by June 30, 2008. Takabayashi said the union would press for safeguards in the program.

HSTA officials have been working to debunk false information that the proposal requires retirees to pay for their own medical coverage.

But Nolan Nakashima, a second-grade teacher at Wilson Elementary, still voted against the contract proposal "just to get some more time" to ensure the contract does not jeopardize retirees' medical coverage.

The contract would raise starting pay for new teachers from $39,901 to $43,157. For teachers with about 15 years of experience, a master's degree and some additional credit hours, annual pay would increase from $59,566 to $66,359 at the end of the contract.

Pay for the most experienced teachers with more than 33 years experience would rise from $73,197 to $79,170.

Sharon Kunihisa, a third-grade teacher at Wilson Elementary, voted for the contract, even though she would have preferred a bigger pay raise.

The issue of drug testing didn't factor into her vote, because Kunihisa understands that "it gives parents peace of mind."

Mark Brilhante, a peer education teacher at Kalani High School, also voted for the contract and has no issue with the drug-testing provision.

"I'm drug-free so they can test me any day of the week, any day of the month," Brilhante said.

He understands that other teachers have concerns over false results. But overall, Brilhante decided, "It's a pretty fair contract so I voted yes."

Brilhante served as a strike captain during the the statewide teacher strike that paralyzed public schools for three weeks in 2001.

Like other teachers, Brilhante said he voted for the contract rather than risk another strike.

Yesterday's 60 percent teacher turnout surprised Takabayashi.

"We thought it would be higher," Takabayashi said, considering how controversial the contract has been.

Reach Dan Nakaso at dnakaso@honoluluadvertiser.com.