[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 10:14 pm HST]
Visiting Europe's WWI & II graveyards you see crosses for 1000's of US soldiers who NEVER came home.Punchbowl: more buried from Europe's, Pacific battles,Vietnam, Korea. Graves of those who served honorably, undefiantly loyal in both 'just' and 'unjust' battles. If you visit veterans hospitals go - see our maimed dismembered mentally shattered warriors. So much sacrifice given by so many truly courageous, loyal, devoted strong men and women who were REAL heroes who didn't hesitate to give lives, despite personal distaste for war which is hell. As I look at those graves: which one would have deserted their unit after deciding on their own that these battles were "illegal" and turn his back on their fellow men getting on the bus? Ehren Watada's real crime: betraying his men, duty, country.
USAFVeteran
Honolulu

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 10:00 pm HST]
"Illegal war"? Then why did Congress approve it? Watada has no authority to "decide" whether or not it is illegal to take military action against a nation that funds or harbors terrorists as Saddam did. There are many facts that Watada is not privy to because it's not his job. Was George Bush supposed to call Watada on the phone and ask his opinion before we went in? I'll NEVER forget 9/11 and how I salivated at the thought of destroying anyone connected to the terrorists attacks including Saddam. (Yes, there WAS a connection!) It's called "Harboring Terrorists". Like our Commander In Chief said, "We will make NO distinction between terrorists or those that harbor them". Saddam was a "harborer" so he had to be dealt with. (Legally, by the way) Watada is a coward.
ikaika
kahaluu

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 9:56 pm HST]
As Americans of the US, we have rights! The rights were designed to protect and provide guidelines. What's wrong with standing up for what you believe in? Dont you still have rights when you join the military? Is everyone okay with adding 20,000 more troops to Iraq to fight this Bush war on oil? its not about terrorism, its about who have more oil barrels?
kaena
hawaii

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 9:47 pm HST]
Wow, he is one lucky Lt. that the prosecutors and their team is somewhat incompetant if he manages to slide pass this one. You sign up during the time of war, you should expect to go to combat if if you think the war is not going smoothly. When you sign the dotted line, you sign up ti protect the constitution and everything that comes with it. He disrespected my brothers brigade and all military personnel. The American public is so counter-culture that they let gutless cowards get away with this. Hope you decay in Ft. Levenworth you turkey, i meant sir!
Kaniele
Honolulu/Abyss

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 9:43 pm HST]
It's not our war? They made it OUR war when they decided to fly OUR planes into the twin towers and MURDER all those innocent people. Right or wrong Bush was put in his position because we VOTED for him to be there. For people to go against what Bush CHOOSES to do because we gave him the ability to RUN this country is WEAK. He raised his hand to serve his country. Did he think he was going to get free housing, full medical, dental, vision, and cheap groceries for nothing? Let's not forget that hefty paycheck. A 1ST LT with a few yrs under his belt makes as much as a SSG with 12 yrs in. My husband did his duty and did his 13 months in Iraq with pride. WATADA NEEDS TO SUCK IT UP AND DRIVE ON! Watada has given every US Military Serviceman a reason to question his/her loyalty to this country.
Army wife
Oahu

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 9:24 pm HST]
Could\'nt handle school, Eagle scout flunkie (Rofl),Watadad out as a catch phrase, & leaving the rest of the Watada clan to defend its surname. I hope his father is proud.
dad
aiea

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 9:20 pm HST]
Watada is a joke!! What kind of poor, selfish, ignorant, lack of courage upbringing this guy was raised in. DANIEL INOUYE gave an ARM for this Country!!, and here we have this worthless slime who defies, rebels, and fabricates fairytale stories cause he's too much of a coward to serve this country in which he VOLUNTEERED for, all on our taxpayer monies. Your a joke Watada, hope you get locked up and they throw away the keys. Your lucky you didnt do this in WW2 era. There would be no trial, just a hole in the ground with you in it!!!
BRAVEHEART
Honolulu

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 9:12 pm HST]
I'm starting to realize it was a good thing Watada made a cowardly move and refused to fight...would you want a worthless, sorry excuse for a human being leading 30 men into combat? I know I wouldn't. I hope he is given the death penalty. That pathetic traitor!
Jeff
Honolulu

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 9:09 pm HST]
I can't believe the people that support someone who would train soldiers and then desert them, to let them deploy and fight on their own! My husband is on his second tour in Iraq; he also doesnt believe the war is right....but is still there because he signed a contract- and he READ his contract!! If "LT" Watada didn't want to fight an "illegal" war, then why did he enlist in the first place? He enlisted in 2003- well after 9/11 and the deployments to Iraq and Afghanistan. He HAD to have known it was coming....if not, then he is stupid and deserves the worst punishment!! How can you say he is a HERO???
veteran and wife of a true soldier
ewa beach

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 9:08 pm HST]
Gee...he sure knew how to read when it came time to cashing those paychecks. I mean he had to read where to sign, read the street signs on the way to the bank, and yeah he had to read the sign on the bank to make sure he was at the right branch. Funny when you get caught lying and being a coward for the whole world to see, you blame it on not reading what you signed. I do not agree with the war going on, but that is why I choose not to join. Does it mean I stop praying for the troops, NO! It doesn't matter what his nationality is, it's plain and simple he is an AMERICAN who got scared when it came down to it and left his guys behind.
Noelani
Wahiawa

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 9:05 pm HST]
I heard the news here in the mainland, and its sad that I am reminded that I knew this person. Or thought I did. Like it's been said time and time again, Mr. Watada like everyone else in life makes choices. He made his choice during a time of war, signed on the dotted line and enlisted, benefitting from a govt paycheck. Now, with the knowledge of being deployed overseas, he runs. Although I personally have strong reservations about why we went to war (fully supportive of our troops serving), I still believe there are other ways to stand up or speak out. He now wears a uniform that he shouldn't, holding a rank he shouldnt and such. From what I know first hand from Mr. Watada... he couldn't make Eagle so he left BSA, he couldnt handle one school so he left. Pattern no? Disappointed. ~m
M
303

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 9:04 pm HST]
Mr Watada enlisted in the Army knowing that in a time of war he would have to go defend this country. Regardless if he thinks the war its right or wrong, he should have went and severed like he said he would in the oath he took. This mistrial thing is proof that in any justice system a weasel can always find a hole to wiggle out of. I think he should go to jail for the maximum sentence then be placed back on active duty and sent to a combat zone for two years. Will it ever happen, not in a million years.
Chris
Honolulu

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 9:00 pm HST]
Watada shouldn't be let free. He needs to face some kind of punishment. Don't understand why there are people who call him a Hero. He took an oath and should abide or take the punishment, instead of finding an easy way out. But then again he is human. They should have men who is serving and served in Iraq who signed the same oath give him his punishment.
ar
hawaii

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 8:53 pm HST]
Watada is not brave! He was scared to fight so he looked for a way out, hoping people would support him. And personally I don't think many people do. I have a professor who is one of the most liberal minded individuals I have ever met and he can agree with me that Watada is a coward and should have never enlisted! Watada should lose all rights, including his life. FIRING SQUAD!
Gary
Honolulu

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 8:49 pm HST]
Lt. Watada is brave to refuse to lead others in an illegal war and occupation that has included the killing of many innocent civilians and even torture. I'm surprised so many people find it so easy to condemn him. Some seem to be angry on behalf of their sons or daughters who are in the war; I hope they're behaving honorably and that they come home in one piece. But I know that American soldiers are getting killed and wounded almost every day. The anger should be directed at the Administration who rushed into an unecessary war without a realistic plan. Lt. Watada does not belong in prison for refusing to be part of this war. Let the consequence be that he won't have a big career in the military. Unnecessary war is a wrong way for the government to use people willing to serve their country
Gayle
Keokea

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 8:44 pm HST]
Go Dorothy! Think of all the money poured into this little war, and still, obviously, all that is occurring is hurtful violence. Reconstruction? Nope; swimming pools for the rich. This whole war only builds up further the rest of the world seeing US as bullies without a clue. Why haven't we joined the vast world efforts these last few days to get some real work done on global warming? Of course, because our government can't make those decisions; the corporations and teeny super-rich guys would not stand for this. So hooray for anyone who stands up and tries to get us all to think!
respect!
big island

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 8:38 pm HST]
One has to ask the question... If you were a German soldier under Hitler's command and you were ordered to kill or torture Jews what would you have done? To disobey orders would make you a coward and criminal under military law. I know some of you cannot understand analogies so if that is so please just ignore this post. I personally think that Watada should never have enlisted, but he did, and he will have to face some consequences for his stand. I hope he takes his punishment like a man.
BB
Waialua

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 8:36 pm HST]
It is profoundly disturbing that the very few Watada supporters keep insisting the war in Iraq is illegal. This is not a moral issue and it amazes me that watada and his supporters have issues between what is right and what is wrong. Their way of thinking is anti-american and creates less loyalty to this free and great country. People, when you join the military be ready to serve and make sacrifices and don't expect decide where and what you want to do. This guy brings an enormous shame to the state of Hawaii and our Nation. He basically let down all the brave men and women who served in the past and present. But the most disappointing part is the damage that he will do to the legacy of the true war heroes, japanese-american war veterans.
JR
LA

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 8:35 pm HST]
So sad to see so much hatred towards another human being. Name calling, disavowing him of being Japanese and kama'aina no less--this makes me sick!! If we tolerate comments such as these, then a backwards State we have become. Let him who is without sin cast the first stone! Who gives you the right to persecute him? It is a disgrace to read such attacks on his personhood. I am not in the military. But it certainly appears that those who are or are affiliated with the military are suppose to be perfect--in their thinking and in their actions. That in itself decries men to be real men. I for one, would rather have him challenge his oath now than to take it with him onto the battlefield, for fear that his team would be more in harms way as a result of his feelings towards this war.
Not proud of Hawaii!!
"State" of Hawaii

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 8:28 pm HST]
Excellent. Don't be a Watada; serve with pride.
Wisdom
O'ahu

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 8:28 pm HST]
First of all, America is only a democratic society by name; in reality, it is a consumer society. Our government's foreign policies are dictated by the market, and to think that the primary reason for sending thousands of troops and spending billions of dollars just to help out a third world country isn't very realistic. People need to stop throwing around the word "democracy" because they act like they know what it really means. It's wonderful how citizens who are proud to be a part of a governing state stressing social equality resorts to racism and violence when there's a sudden rift in their daily lives. Using violence and intimidation for political means is nothing new in our history. Watada's error was thinking that the military's existence is motivated simply by altruism.
Dorothy
Honolulu

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 8:27 pm HST]
Mr. Watada signed the agreement and cashed his paychecks. If he was so conflicted, he should have relinquished his comission earlier and not accepted the pay. He's just another coward and his actions are an absolute disgrace and disrespect to all who serve. Now when someone decides that they don't want to go on a particular deployment we can just say he did "a Watada" or he "Watadad out." I guess he did give the country something. We have a new catch phrase. Don't be a Watada; serve with pride.
Ray Franco
Waikiki

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 8:22 pm HST]
Shame on Watada. I agree that Watada should end all this now and off himself.
PFC Kirk
Schofield

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 8:17 pm HST]
I for one respect Mr. Watada's strength in standing up for his beliefs as a man; we are all human before and above being in the military or whatever else we do in our lives. We need to show respect for each other, and for the people of the world. I am saddened with the harsh and violent reactions of so many on this blog today. Frame this situation as a comparison to the corrupt, money-seeking sugar planters and their use of the american military to take over Hawaii... There are times when someone needs to stand up and make noise about what they see is right. This helps all of us to consider the situation. We can learn from Mr. Watada's bravery in standing up, despite the clear and knee-jerk disrespect of his humanity he knew would be expressed by so many.
respect!
big island

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 8:16 pm HST]
My Son is in Iraq probably scared but detirmined to come home in one piece. His faith is in his fellow soldiers , his commanders his country and in that mix his god of choice.He isnt a mindless robot but a person stuck in a political mess.Nor is he a warcriminal. He is my Hero and probably yours too but you just dont know it yet.
Dad
Aiea

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 8:16 pm HST]
Don't kill the messenger. Listen to his message. For a clear and comprehensive article on Watada, read LATimes.com/columnone before you throw the stone. FYI: the mistrial reflects badly on the MILITARY/prosecutors. Personally I would like to see this case argued in front of the Supreme Court. In my opinion, this case affects each of us and our basic Constitutional rights. Those who express negative comments haven't gotten the message.
PatY
Seattle

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 8:15 pm HST]
Watada is neither a coward nor a hero. He is simply a protester and a calculating fool. Today's societal climate easily suffers fools, and these fools think they can speak their minds with no consequences. Unfortunately, Watada hired a lawyer who doesn't understand the UCMJ and now Watada does in fact face consequences for his actions. He violated the UCMJ for not deploying with his unit and that bears consequences. He was banking on getting a slap on the hand and lots of publicity. He got the publicity, but not just the slap on the hand. Look for him to run for office in the future-these seem to be the most popular and successful politicians lately.
Al
Mililani

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 8:12 pm HST]
If 1LT Watada has not brought enough shame to his name, he now to changes his story that he didn’t know what to expect when he join the Army is a further disgrace to his honor as a coward trying to weasel out of the consequences he knew from the start when he made up his mind to refuse to serve in Iraq. His punishment should not be 4 years in jail, but 4 years as a buck private in Iraq on a route clearance detail clearing IEDs - that is the only way he can regain his honor and live in Hawaii without embarrassment. If not, he might as well move to San Francisco with his new so-call fair-weather friends.
Iraq Veteran
Honolulu, Hawaii

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 8:09 pm HST]
I\'m so proud of you Lt. Watada. Honor is doing what is right especially when it is difficult. Where is the honor in mindless obedience? I see none especially where this misbegotten war is concerned.
D
Honolulu

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 8:07 pm HST]
I’m actually very disturbed by a comment made by a “huha” [Posted on February 7, 2007 at 5:09 pm HST] on this page. Kind of response I really do expect from someone who has no idea what the Japanese Americans have fought for in Hawaii. Watada a coward? I could argue but not worth the time…but please, don’t make such a sad attempt to discredit our veterans who you accuse of being screwed over by the government and are old and bitter…aside from accusing you own family of being stupid. I’m disgusted by your remarks. If Watada is such a hero, why aren’t you or any other clever private citizens out there doing the same thing he has…sign up for the army so you can make a supportive statement and stand tall with watada like you “would do.” Just do it already.
I Support our Combat Veterans
Honolulu

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 8:07 pm HST]
Why is there so much press coverage on this so called “Hero,” who refused to honor his commitment, when there are other Servicemen/Service women who gave the ultimate sacrifice to our country, especially like our most recent local boy SSG Henry Kahalewai who lost his life with 20 years in the Army? 1LT Watada has brought shame to his family and Hawaii. He can not be compared to his WWII Nisei ancestors in the 442nd RCT, since they volunteer and served while their families were discriminated and in interment camps. I can remember reading books and hearing stories from these veterans and how their parents gave them one word of advice “Don’t bring shame on the family.” Well, obviously he did not follow the same advice. What a fool and embarrassment to Hawaii.
Iraq Veteran
Honolulu, Hawaii

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 8:05 pm HST]
Son's of Hawaii are proud to serve, so he must be a son of Watada!
Moke Galletes
Aloha,oregon

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 8:05 pm HST]
Thank God for brave soldiers like Lt. Watada. Sure, when a young man or woman signs up for duty, he knows that there may come a time when he will be called to active duty, but that is not the point of the argument here. The fact is and it has been proven that this so called war was based on lies and is illegal. Anyone who reads and follows the news can easily see that. The Bush Administration has lied and bullied us into thinking that Iraq was and still is the cause of this war and so we occupy a country that doesn't even want us there. If you are looking or the real cowards, then look at the President and our Administration. Thank you Lt. Watada for showing us what a real American should be and for protecting our constitutional rights. Shame on the military and that fool named Bush.
B. Acadia
Honolulu

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 8:04 pm HST]
Pvt. Watada you are hereby ordered to serve 10 years of hard labor at Fort Levenworth. So let it be written, so let it be done.
The Judge
Fort Lewis, Washington

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 8:04 pm HST]
Watada should not be called a Officer or LT. He shouldn't be even allowed to put on a uniform. I served 26 years in the Army. I was ready to do and go anywhere. All you people go to your jobs everyday and complain about you Boss or whatever and still do the job your paid to do. Watada, like everyone I know in the military, took a oath and made a promise to God! He should be punished. End of story.
Kona
Kaimuki

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 8:04 pm HST]
If you didn't want to go to war, why did you join the military? I know plenty of men who have been to Iraq even though they NEVER wanted to go but they came back with a better understanding and a greater appreciation of life. You are a coward ...not a hero. A hero sacrifices for others not himself and this protest is all about you and not your fellow soldiers or the citizens you represent. Enjoy your five minutes of fame because when you are sent to jail, no one will remember you nor what you attempted to do.
Josh
California

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 7:59 pm HST]
The greatest IDIOT of all times.....
MH
Leeward area

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 7:57 pm HST]
Watada is a discrase to his race. Do your duty and off yourself tonight at your home. Thanks you.
Bob. M.
Honolulu

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 7:56 pm HST]
He was called to serve and yet he failed to live up to his obligations...we don't need people like Watada in the military. What a disgrace!
Keli'i
Honolulu

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 7:53 pm HST]
Ehren Watada is a disgrace! The military should make an example of him! And shame on his father Bob allowing his son to break the rules and go against his orders! I remember the kind of office Bob Watada used to run, BY THE BOOKS! and now look at him that he is retired and it involves his son. Now we know where Ehren learned his OUTSTANDING values from...NOT!
Born and raised in Hawaii
Hawaii

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 7:44 pm HST]
No matter what the circumstance he was and officer and he took and oath to serve our country. It is sad that he and his family think that after all this time taking OUR money that he wouldn't some day be called to actually do his job. This is like a teacher one day saying what do you mean I have to actually teach. What did he think joining the military meant? If he wants out maybe he should be asked to repay the military his entire salary since he broke his contract. All this BS of not fully understanding what he was doing is bunch of bologna. He knew exactly what he was doing he went straight to the press. He should be punished to the fullest. This disgust me to think that he and his family are representing Hawaii.
S. Chang
Honolulu

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 7:44 pm HST]
I think he is right about the war we dont belong their.IT Isnt our war.
tanaka sherman
honolulu hawaii

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 7:44 pm HST]
Watada\'s fault is reaching out to the looney toon characters that comprise that anti war movement.It\'s one thing to have reservations about the war, it\'s totally another to attach yourself to dumbasses who disrect our soldiers! Jail the lot of them!!
realist
USA

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 7:37 pm HST]
\"Not a coward\" -- your message says it all... Look at yourself in the mirror and tell me if you don\'t see a moron. You know what I mean: even you can tell that you don\'t understand anything that goes around you. Do you think this war made you \"safer\"? Or leaving in \"freedom\"? Come on, use your brain. Your racist, homophobic comments just emphasize your own lack of control and placement in society. If you were not a looser by nature, you would try to understand the reasons for things that go way above your head. To ask for the death of Mr. Watada is just as a stupid comment as one can make. You are the best example of a Pavlov sheep -- no thinking of your own, just a machine to repeat and \"follow orders\"... Not a Coward nor a Genius ...
Jackal
California

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 7:36 pm HST]
Shame on the system for failing to uphold the oblgation of the Soldiers and the right to serve of our fellow SOLDIERS. TO WATADA AND THOSE WHO SUPPORTS HIM, "SHAME ON YOU FOR NOT SUPPORTING THOSE SOLDIERS SERVING IN THIS WAR". HE IS A DISGRACE TO THE MILITARY SERVICES OF ALL BRANCHES BOTH OFFICERS & ENLISTED. Your a disgrace to HAWAII, please move off this ISLAND you are no longer considered a Kamaaina to our brohterhood of Combat Veterans. He deserves to serve time in prison for deserting his fellow Soldiers, send him thru school and all he projects is the case DUMB---!!! Why are we wasting money on individuals like this, HELLOOOO!!! Wake up and smell the coffe people. Serving in IRAQ or Afganastan is no different you are stil fighting terroist. COMBAT VETERAN, IRAQ Aiea, Hawaii
IRAQ VETERAN
AIEA

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 7:35 pm HST]
This is one person that should get a re-trial and spend the rest of his time in prison. He has let a lot of people down. I for one am glad that this person was never put incharge of people and their lives. I think that he should also be made to pay back the government for all of his schooling, which he will most likely try to use to the fullest. Maybe he didn't know that he was signing up for schooling also. Does he even know who his parents are, and how he got to where he is? Does he even know that he is in the United States? What a SHAME you have brought on yourself, and you FAMILY- WATADA- Dirty name. ARE you fore sure that you are from Hawaii? If so, i would be ashamed to even know you!!!!!!!!
SALESMAN
JAPAN

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 7:33 pm HST]
The main point that we are missing here is that as a Lieutenant in the Army, Watada was responsible for approximately 30 or so young, scared, and homesick soldiers, some of which were straight out of Basic and Advanced Individual Training. Whether the war in Iraq is illegal and that you do not believe in it doesn't change the fact that the rest of your Unit IS going there, in this case without you. How can you help them from home,oops i meant jail. A true "hero" and "leader" would look past the politics of the war and focus on doing everything in his power to make sure that all his troops were taken care of and hopefully all make it back home. The sad thing is that he abandoned his unit, even though he might not think it.
nerb
Honolulu

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 7:30 pm HST]
Heroes come in many forms. Some do give up their lives for country. Others sacrifice their liberty for their beliefs. I am thankful that our constitution still permits dissent, even if many citizens believe that dissent equals treason or a reason for exile. Iraq is now the nation of Thoreau's Civil Disobedience: "In other words, when a sixth of the population of a nation which has undertaken to be the refuge of liberty are slaves, and a whole country is unjustly overrun and conquered by a foreign army, and subjected to military law, I think that it is not too soon for honest men to rebel and revolutionize. What makes this duty the more urgent is the fact that the country so overrun is not our own, but ours is the invading army." America's military is to be honored, not worshipped.
Shannon
Honolulu

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 7:29 pm HST]
1st Lt Watada is a brave man. This war is not WWII, it's pretty obvious by now that this war in Iraq was started with lies. I want a soldier who can think - not a robot. Wish would have had a few Generals who put their career on the line to say this war was a mistake. But they didn't they wanted to save their careers and get promoted (trust me it ain't all about patriotism and serving your country. I've seen it from the inside.)You want a robot. Look at the enemies we fought in Europe and WWII. You support this war then you go join, you have a child or grandchild and you support this War in Iraq then drive them down to a recruiter and get them to sign up. Watada made a decision - a tough one- and he didn't run. He stood up for what he believed. It's as simple and as hard as that.
Rod
Waikele

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 7:29 pm HST]
Watada is a worthless coward
Noble
Honolulu

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 7:28 pm HST]
I feel sorry for all the people who are backing this coward. The military is here to DEFEND DEMOCRACY, NOT PRACTICE IT. When you sign up, your duty is to follow the orders of the legal government, not debate the points on whether the war is legal. That decision is above his pay grade. Fag-Tada is a coward and his friends, family and supporters shld be ashamed of themselves. The reason you are living in freedom now is NOT because of chicken-sh*ts like him, but of the brave men and women who serve in our military. Jackal, the better question to ask is, where are the days of summary executions of traitors like this? They need to have him dig his own grave, have him stand over it and just shoot him in the head.
Not a Coward
Hawaii

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 7:26 pm HST]
Watada is a Coward. He new what he was getting into when he entered the armed forces. People that can actually call him a hero just sicken me. Ehren Watada needs to be dealt the ultimate punishment for the crimes he has committed against his country, death!
Noble
Honolulu

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 7:24 pm HST]
JAIL WEASAL WATADA !!!!! JAP....
Tax Payer
Honolulu

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 7:22 pm HST]
I feel sorry for all the bitter people who posted accusations of cowardness in this site. It takes a lot of courage to take a stand. The whole concept of modern war and the "new military" is a shame. There is no honor and no courage involved in bulldozing a poor country with hi-tech equipment that leaves no chance for the locals to defend themselves. Where is the honor in the modern Generals and "Commander-in-Chiefs" who order the young to die from their air conditioned offices with a pen? Long gone are the days that the Generals would walk the talk and lead the man into battle. For the modern military to claim any honor these days is really an infamy. Try living like the Masai -- look for your courage within, not by pointing fingers on others who have the courage to take stand
Jackal
California

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 7:22 pm HST]
I JUMPED FOR JOY WHEN I HEARD THE NEWS. I WILL CONTINUE TO PRAY FOR MR. WATADA, BECASUE GOD IS GREATER THAN THE GOVERNMENT.
LEIMOMI BORDEAUX
HAWAII

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 7:18 pm HST]
It's insulting to hear the anti-war folk put Ehren Watada on a pedestal and worship him as a hero just because he shares their views.Watada may be many things but a hero he is not.Heroes are those that give up their lives in service to their country.Heroes are the families they leave behind who have to live with that loss for the rest of their lives.Heroes are those that wake up every day in Iraq not knowing if each day will be their last.Heroes are those,who irrespective of their views on the war,continue to serve their country because they feel an obligation to honor their oath.
Keanu Young
Makiki

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 7:14 pm HST]
Lt. Watada is a hero. He is standing up to a corrupt system in a way that our politicians have not. Of course there is a mistrial, because he is not being allowed to present the evidence that this war is illegal. We can't have true evidence of an illegal war presented in court because we would have to impeach the traitors to our constitution that have taken possession of the executive branch of our government. History will look favorably on this brave young man.
patriot
Kaneohe

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 7:13 pm HST]
This LT knows exactly what he was doing when he raised his hand and took the oath as an officer and being in the military. Part of the oath says "I will obey the orders of the President of the UNITED STATES OF AMERICA and the officers above me".. .Plain and simple, if this was an enlisted Soldier, that Soldier would have been in Fort Leavenworth, with no questions asked. That Soldier would have been given the UCMJ punishment. He did not understand what he was signing for? What a laugh! He is an officer! He should have been taken to Fort Leavenworth, lock him up and throw away the key and leave him to rut for the rest of his life. FREEDOM IS NOT FREE!!! I just hope that he will get the full penalty; put him to jail; demoted all the way to PV1 and dishonorably discharged.END OF STORY
PC
PEARL CITY

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 7:09 pm HST]
Manini is to tight wad; Watada is to "coward"; You've just wrote yourself into the Hawaiian Dictionary
masao
honolulu

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 7:09 pm HST]
Watada took an oath. We as private citizens paid for his education, housing, meals,and salary. He took an oath to protect against us from all enemies, foreign and domestic. He took an oath saying that he will follow the orders of the President of the United States. So now he wants to say "Just kidding, I didn't mean it if I am going to war, I just wanted the free money." As a veteran myself and serving in the Panama, the Gulf War and Bosnia, I thick he's just plain CHICKEN. He should go to prison for ABANDONING his men, pay back all the money the military WASTED on him and do community service at a VA hospital. CRY BABY.
ml
kapolei

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 7:03 pm HST]
shame on him, shame on his dad for what his dad did. give back the military benefits. leave our country.
citizen
mililani

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 6:51 pm HST]
I fail to see the reason behind the decison of mistrial. I have witness Soldiers that have medical issues which preveted them from going to Iraq but did there best to proceed foward after facing medical reveiw boards to join the fight with their fellow Soldiers. Regardless of the issues LT Watada projects to the public, he knew what he was getting into upon enlisting in the first place. The issue should solely be based on missing movement with his unit and nothing else. Think of the many lives lost in support of this effort, our unit lost a fellow Soldier from a IED and he was only 23yrs old. People are we going to let Terroist control the world, NO!! the US should not lead this effort it should be a joint effort by all nations. Bless those Soldiers who are still there.
Kamuela
Halawa

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 6:42 pm HST]
I was born and raised in Hawaii and am truly sorry that Lt. Watada is from Hawaii. Thank God not all of our men and women from Hawaii that are in the miltary forces are like him. Those who sign up for the military know what they are signing up for. If Watada does not beleive in war he should never have signed up in the first place. He knows what the army is all about.As a wife of a retired military man and a mother of a son on active duty I am proud of both of them.And my son has been overseas once and would do it again. To all of the men and women in the military services I salute you.A court marshall is exactly what Watada deserves.
mh
silverdale,WA

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 6:37 pm HST]
lst Lt. Watada is a hero. Despite the bainwashing every member of the military goes through, Watada has maintained his ability to determine right from wrong. He has acted with courage and integrity. I am sickened and ashamed that the Bush Administration has manipulated our America into attacking a foreign nation on the basis of a lie. The attempt at a coverup and justification has caused the deaths of thouands of innocent children, women and men and the sacrifice of thousands of American troops. This war is illegal and immoral. Lt. Watada is a credit to his family and to America. Thank you, Lt. Watada.
Mel Kernahan
California

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 6:37 pm HST]
Watada should be shot not put in prison.
Wong
Honolulu

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 6:33 pm HST]
He would have gone to Afghan cause....there is no roadside bombs?...fighting going on every day....maybe he would like to have a job stationed in the Caymans fighting off the sand crabs and bad Mai Tais. OK we the people your right we should join the military and tell them what we want and will do and then we will call the military.....what?
Jac
Kaneohe

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 6:28 pm HST]
The outcome of this case is going to set the precedent for all other "missed movement" from other soldiers who chooses not deploy when called upon. His actions may cause some soldiers their lives because they may think to themselves, "if he don't have to deploy, then why should I have to" and have their focus elsewhere other than their mission.
SPC PACBA
FORT HOOD, TX

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 6:27 pm HST]
I love how 90% of the posts here are against the traitor, yet the America-hating liberals still insist public opinion is in favor of the traitor.
smoke grenade
hawaii

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 6:21 pm HST]
As another Republican president, Ronald Reagan, once said, "Trust, but verify." Had Congress, the media, and the American people taken President Reagan's advice, we would never have been in Iraq in the first place, and Ehren Watada would never be standing trial for "abandoning his unit." Indeed, the abandonment that is criminal here is that of this government's abandoning the trust of those it governs. Watada's stand against being a pawn in the Machiavellian game of a superpower run amok is something that future generations will see in much the same way as we remember courageous acts of civil disobedience by men like Patrick Henry. Should this courageous young man be convicted, this president, and his military, will, for generations, bear the guilty verdict of history.
We The People...
Honolulu

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 6:20 pm HST]
Keep in mind that Lt. Ehren Watada is not afraid of combat; he said he would be willing to fight in Afghanistan. He is opposed to the war in Iraq and is speaking out against this administration's campaign to deceive the American people. Watada is not the first to say, "hell, no, we won't go;" many enlisted service members have faced disciplinary action for doing the same; he is only the first to do so publicly. We will need more Watadas in the months to come if, as neoconservative Richard Perle suggests, the president intends to attack Iran before his term ends; and, in light of Senator Chuck Hagel's disclosures that the president attempted to get a resolution through Congress, in 2002, which would have allowed him to pick a fight anywhere in the Middle East. Stop this madness. Continued-
We The People...
Honolulu

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 6:16 pm HST]
Now I'm wondering...should have I cried foul when I was STOP-LOSS just days before my retirement? NOT! When you work as a team practicing day after day, knowing each other's abilities, knowing what as a team we can accomplish and then one day you dropped from that team. I really wonder what you did to those young men and women that you were suppose to lead felt that day you abandoned them. That to me was and is the real threat. I pray to God that not one scratch happened to your team. You talk about heroes like Dan Inouye, charging and protecting his team, where will you be in history?
Kyle
Aiea

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 6:14 pm HST]
definitely watada family are not from samurai family, no honor, change your last name, you don't deserve to have japanese name
kevin
hawaii kai

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 6:14 pm HST]
Notice that the prosecution is the party which requested the mistrial, so I am confident Watada will have his day in court (and in Leavenworth). Regardless of the politics of his actions, he has dishonored himself, his family, his comrades, and his country. He is a coward and a disgrace. By failing to do his duty, he will be dishonorably discharged. For those who don't know, that makes him a felon until the day he dies. He can't vote, he can't own a firearm, and he will have to disclose his cowardice on every job application he ever submits. In my opinion, he's getting off easy. The prison time is nothing. He should be forced to repay the Army every penny ever paid to him. He failed in his assigned role and he let his men down. It's as simple as that.
Jason, disabled veteran
Waianae, HI

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 6:13 pm HST]
he is a disgrace and a piece of filth. If he thinks the war is so illegal and immoral maybe he would feel better joining up with the terrorists and fight against the imperial US troops. Watada should have been in front of a firing squad months ago
Ai Kanaka
hawaii

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 6:08 pm HST]
It doesn't take a brave man to protest the war and call his fellow soldiers war criminals ... why is it everytime you liberals dissent against our country, you think it's bravery? Hello ... we are the ONLY country in the world in which you have a protected freedom of speech, making it possible for any one of us to speak out.
Rene
Maui

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 6:07 pm HST]
Ok, let's for the sake of argument follow Lt. Watada's logic that he has a moral obligation to disobey an unlawful order, which I also agree with in principle, transfering from his base in WA to Iraq, in and of itself, is NOT an immoral order. Once in Iraq, he may be given an immoral order -- i.e. "go shoot those individuals over there" or "motar that house," in which case he MAY have a moral obligation to disobey... To simply miss troop movement, because he did not approve of the way the war occurred, does not provide him with a legal defense to miss troop movement. Further, from a practical standpoint he confuses the issue of moral obligation when he stated he would serve in Afganistan. Many people in Afganistan don't was our troops there either, but he says he would have served.
jimmy
honolulu

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 6:01 pm HST]
i wouldn't call him a coward, but a backstabber. he deserted his men in time of need, and there's no honor in that. if he admits that he's so stupid that he didn't know about a war when he enlisted, maybe he could be forgiven. his father obviously thinks that it's a worse crime to commit campaign spending violations than to turn his back on his men. hang both of them!
joe
honolulu

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 5:57 pm HST]
Hate to break it to some of you, but this mistrial is a disaster for Watada. the Army can now bring more charges against him as the plea deal is gone and there is some debate about if he ever intended to follow orders at all on June 26th. His lawyer made a HUGE error today in letting Watada talk himself into this mistrial......WOW
Jay
Makaha

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 5:57 pm HST]
He is a very smart man who became an officer. He knew exactly what he was signing. He was happy when he was getting all the military benefits for many years. Now he does not want to meet his obligations. He truly is a bad example to all others who have already given their lives or are fighting the war. He needs to go before the firing squad for treason to his country. If this was another person, they would have been sentenced to 20 years, but because his father is the big shot, WATADA who worked for the state and audited high ranking government officials, he will absolutely get away with a slap on his wrist.
Debra L. Jardine
248 Elelupe Road

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 5:52 pm HST]
Which is better? Great courage and conscious or no honor and words with no meaning?
who cares
honolulu

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 5:47 pm HST]
Watada on Hitlers side or Allies ..I dont get it. I think Hitler would have said forget it give me the jew to command. I dont see how it could have helped the Allies cause we won with scared but men with Loyaly to their comrades.
walt
kapolei

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 5:32 pm HST]
Courtmarshall him !
David Glover
Hawaii Kai, HI

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 5:31 pm HST]
I hope the mistrial is step one of an outright dismissal of all charges. The entire court-martial process is rigged against the defendant. One day our grandchildren will look back on Lt. Watada as a man of conscience and great courage who exercised his first amendment right to be free to criticize the government. The war in Iraq is a travesty and we need more officers like Lt. Watada. I wish there had been some like him during Hitler's reign. We will never advance as a "kindler, gentler nation" if we do not recognize that blind obedience to orders is a character defect.
Jamie
Honolulu

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 5:30 pm HST]
It's most unfortunate Watada doesn't have a father as President of the U.S.A. or in some high political office, otherwise none of this would be happening. Where was W. Bush when Vietnam was happening ? ? ? ?
PKM
HONOLULU

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 5:29 pm HST]
He knew that by signing into the military, there is the risk of being deployed. What did he thinks it means when he signed up? To serve and protect the United States of America. I was in the military for 24 years and never once questioned my obligation and duty to my country! What a coward!!
Lloyd
Anaheim, CA

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 5:28 pm HST]
He is a disgrace to the troops that represent Hawaii. If he can't understand a document that he signed, we don't need him "commanding" our troops in battle (as an officer).
MM
Honolulu

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 5:27 pm HST]
it's not fair all the publicity that he is getting. He needs to pay for his actions. If he does not get punished this will set-up for others to follow this is just what the terroists want us to give in. He is spoiled and is no leader and should apologize for his actions.
Paul
Honolulu

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 5:25 pm HST]
If you want your life to be 100% controlled by the U.S. government ... join the military. I don't think Watada is a coward, what military personnel would openly say that they detest the war. Come on now, are you being a coward for standing up for what you believe in. A coward would keep his mouth shut. At least he didn't go AWOL or did something stupid deliberately to be discharged (and you know there's many that did!!). And should we call those that deserted the Vietnam War (drafted or not) cowards too? No, because that war was wrong too! People make mistakes, his mistake was joining the military.
oh boy!
oregon

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 5:19 pm HST]
if you don't support our government, don't ever expect it to support you. move somewhere else
koa
honolulu

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 5:18 pm HST]
Moved from Hawaii to Oregon,he a COWARD!
Mike
Oregon

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 5:15 pm HST]
are you sure about that Dan? I haven\'t seen any accurate numbers on \"Watada Supporters\"
jd
hnl

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 5:14 pm HST]
COWARD!!! What did he think he was signing up for when he joined the military? Was he just after the education, status, and something to put on his resume after discharge to better his carreer opportunities? He should go to prison and receive a dishonorable discharge. I smell a book or movie deal in the making. Therefore the judge should also rule that he can not profit from any of the activities associated with this case.
Dale
Mililani

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 5:11 pm HST]
Although I can see many posting against this guy are from military backgrounds, but the truth remains that most people support him(Hawaii and elsewhere), however much the posting say here say otherwise. Maybe it is a military thing, but the military leadership and culture is not something I look up to or support.
Dan
Honolulu

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 5:11 pm HST]
like father like son quitters
mel
makiki

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 5:10 pm HST]
What it comes down to is not what he believes, it's about a man turning his back on his oath and publicly praising himself for it. Plenty of soldiers out there do not agree with the war, but they are honorable enough to suck it up and fight because they know that's what they have to do.
uh huh
mililani

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 5:09 pm HST]
I am pleased to see watada closer to freedom. I would have done the same as he has. And even tho I respect those who have gone to war, this is a unjust war. The bottom line for me, is that all the vets and others who are saying watada is a coward, are ones that are old and bitter, from being screwed by the govt themselves in the veterans system, who wont take care of you when you come back crippled, and these same watada haters are the very idiots who refused to vote for Kerry in '04 for similar reasons. open your eyes. look where we are now. example: iran and n. korea. i knew bush was a idiot from his father's presidency, and from his texas governor days. I know, because my uncle, and my father in law are vietnam vets, who are stupid, and barely or didnt even grad high school. nuff said.
huha
hon

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 5:07 pm HST]
I am totally and utterly disgusted with this army officer. He joined the army as a Commissioned Officer knowing exactly what it entails. What kind of example are leading for your troops? They have been out there fighting for our country while you sit back and complain about it. This is very personal for me; I too am from Hawaii and my spouse is serving overseas at this time, the same unit that Mr. Watada is a part of. My husband has served more than a share of his time in the army and made many of trips overseas never once complaining about it because he and I both knew what being a part of the United States Army really means. So Watada, get out of the army and give back all the money you are being paid as an OFFICER and go stand on the bridge with your supporters!
Disgusted
Fort Lewis

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 5:07 pm HST]
Boohoohoo. This wannabe GIjoe lieutenant has NO Guts. And so, he uses some lame ass excuse to try to get out of the army. What happened? You got your college degree paid for by the citizens of the U.S. and now when its time to pay the piper, you CHICKEN out and cry "Bwaah, it's an illegal war. Mommy, I want to go home to Hawaii." Put him in Gitmo with the other terrorists so they can swap stories about the "illegal war".
retired senior chief usn
california

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 5:05 pm HST]
I am embarrassed by his actions and ashamed to say I am from Hawaii as he has made it public knowledge he is Hawaii Born as well. My father is a retired Master Sgt of the Army and because of the Army he lost both of his legs as a result of being in Vietnam. But even though his scars are permanent he states he took an oath and made a promise to serve the United states government and if that meant loosing his legs so be it. the man gave his word!
Maile
Kailua

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 5:04 pm HST]
Well Lt., you and your family will have to live with this for the rest of your life. Good or bad, you made a choice that will affect your loved ones also. Sure they'll stand by you, but the point is you joined and you quit on your fellow soldiers and country. Yes i've served in the military just to clear that up. Whatever happens it's your life. Just to remind you, illegal or not, you swore in to defend this country.
Don
Windward

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 5:00 pm HST]
That Lt.Watada elicits such venom from the public sector for his stand on Iraq is always a bit surprising to me, inasmuch as the majority of the people in our coutry see Irag as a tragic situation that needs to somehow end. What Lt.Watada is doing is perhaps reminding us that there has been a peridine shift in the world...that we no longer are worshipping at the shibboleth of the "nation-state war system" that ruled the nations for centuries. What is needed,is a fresh approach to our problems, that of recogizing that the difficulty behind all of the worlds problems is 'disunity', based religious and political diversity. We need to talk to one another, not wage war. Perhaps Lt. Watada in his own way was trying to demonstrate that.
Steve Paschal
mililani Hawaii

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 4:57 pm HST]
Watada should be ashamed! He is a COWARD. He should not be wearing the Army uniform. He took an oath when he was commissioned an officer and he should read and understand that the oath is something sacred. This guy thinks that the Army is like going to a fast food joint, you get what you want. The Army and all the other services don't operate like that. How did you become an officer in the fisrt place, if you can't even understand what you read and sign. You should look up the word COWARD in the dictionary and write an essay. Maybe then you know what it means.
Danile
Kaneohe

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 4:56 pm HST]
Watada's attorney says "this may be over because of double jeproady". If that was the case, the judge wouldn't have set a new court date. At least we can see what strategy is next.
Justin
Mililani

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 4:56 pm HST]
Imagine if all the Sailors and Marines in Hawaii decided to stop following orders. This isn't about the Iraq War, this is about an Officer who swore an oath to serve his country. Did this "officer" not realize that he would potentially serve in Iraq when he joined in 2003? Whatever happens, this guy should never be allowed to call himself a soldier again, and should never benefit from having been in the Army.
esemef
windward

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 4:50 pm HST]
I say just court marshal him already, I myself is against the war, however how can he be an officer of the Army, enjoy or shall I take advantage of all benefits of military life and refuse to fulfill his end of the bargain. to put it in perspective, it is like the George Bush accepting the position of president, then telling the citizens of the united states, he didn't understand the oath he was taking and doesn't want the job anymore, but wants to continue to live in the white house and retain the private plane and the status of president.
Sharon
Honolulu

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 4:50 pm HST]
I don't get it...He joined after I had served in Iraq, as an officer to lead troops. I don't care where, when, or how...He wanted to be commissioned as a leader, to be followed and looked up to by the same soldiers as him who know their place of duty. So when he was to lead his soldiers that needed his guidance, and leadership, he bailed and claimed something far greater than him was illegal? Mind you, he is a petty lower commissioned officer, with 3 years in the Army. I have Privates who have more integrity, and time in service than this lieutenant. None the less…Privates that need support leadership and guidance from lieutenants…to serve on the battlefield with them. You see…it isn’t about the war…it’s about those who count on you to be there with them and get them back home safe.
iraqi vet
waikiki

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 4:41 pm HST]
WE ALL ARE ONLY HUMAN. WE ALL MAKE OUR OWN CHOICES AND HE MADE A CHOICE TO JOIN AND FOLLOW ORDERS. HE SHOULD NOW HAVE TO PAY BACK ALL THE MONEY THAT HE MADE AND ALSO WHAT COST THE GOV. TO TRAIN HIM AND LET HIM BE ON HIS WAY. I DO NOT THINK HE SHOULD GO TO PRISON BECAUSE HE WOULD GET A FREE RIDE IN THERE. HAVING TO PAY BACK ALL THAT MONEY WOULD TAKE FOREVER AND WOULD BE MORE HURTFULL FOR THIS YOUNG MAN. MAKE HIM PAY FOR HIS LIES.
Patrick Tocher 2nd
ORANGE, CALIFORNIA

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 4:37 pm HST]
Seems that Watada has a lot of issues with "misunderstanding" what he reads (kind of like the oath he took when he went into military service). Doesn't seem to stop him from signing anything as long as he thinks he can take it back later. Next time, give this guy a pencil, not a pen!
Mel
Wahiawa

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 4:33 pm HST]
Will the people who scream IN CAPITAL LETTERS that the war in Iraq is illegal show the rest of us some proof of that? Congress authorized the President to prosecute the war and has never defunded it and so, ipso facto, the war is legal until they take such action. The war might be inadvisable or imprudent, but that's not the same as illegal. If Watada chooses to view the war as illegal or immoral as a matter of principle, then I defend his right to do so. He and his supporters should now accept the legal consequences of that choice.
skeptic
Honolulu

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 4:30 pm HST]
I think Watada is a coward. He knew that when he became a commissioned officer, the possibility of being sent to a combat zone is real. It was okay for him to be in the Army as long as it's convenient for him. I think he has brought discredit to himself and the the U.S. Army.
Freddie Eder
Waipahu

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 4:28 pm HST]
He is a total disgrace to the japanese-american soldiers who exemplified bravery, pride and respect. The true heroes. As an army veteran from Hawaii and having served in Iraq, I can say that its a shame that there are people out there who thinks he's a hero. When you join, you follow orders. When you get out, you do your thing. The most disheartening thing about this guy is that he brings shame to soldiers and veterans of Hawaii and especially the valiant japanese-american veterans. He should pay back every penny invested in him and then send him to jail. Maybe he can get stationed at Ford Island so Bob can be closer to him.
JR
CALIFORNIA

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 4:28 pm HST]
I'll Keep it Short and simple. I was discharged from the Army back in 1986. At that time I was paid to follow orders, and I was taught to carry out those orders to a flyn tee and to do it with a smile!!!! and I will be Happy! When you attempt grow a brain and don't follow orders...people die! The ARMY does not care what your views are or how you feel about WAR.. you are now a G.I. "Government Issue" Ehren you should have followed orders and did your thing, I am ashamed that you are from Hawaii...WHAT IS YOUR MAJOR MALFUNCTION?
Kohea
Kailua

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 4:25 pm HST]
I am an officer in the military and Watada is a disgrace to all of us who serve. Apparently,he did not understand his oath of office,when he raised is right hand and said,"I, _ having been appointed an officer in the Army of the United States, as indicated above in the grade of _ do solemnly swear that I will support and defend the Constitution of the United States against all enemies, foreign or domestic,that I will bear true faith and allegiance to the same;that I take this obligation freely,without any mental reservations or purpose of evasion;and that I will well and faithfully discharge the duties of the office upon which I am about to enter;So help me God".He should rot in a cell and think about how his comrades are doing the job he signed up to do and dying for his freedom of speech
SH
Waikiki

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 4:23 pm HST]
I'm not sure where Watada's attorney went to law school but he doesn't seem to understand how double jeopardy works. There are three essential protections included in double jeopardy: protection from being retried for the same crime after an acquittal; protection from retrial after a conviction; and protection from being punished multiple times for the same offense. As double jeopardy applies only to charges that were the subject of an earlier final judgment, there are many situations in which it does not apply despite the appearance of a retrial. For example, a second trial held after a mistrial does not violate the double jeopardy clause, because a mistrial ends a trial prematurely without a judgment of guilty or not guilty. Since this was a mistrial - double jeopardy does not apply!
Nikolas
Manoa

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 4:23 pm HST]
To Watada's supporters: the question isn't if the war is illegal or not or if you agree with war. The problem is that he agreed to serve in the military, signing paperwork to defend his country, then decided not to do it. What else is the military for? Everyone knows the military is to defend the US - no matter what the call of duty is. It's not his right to question once he joins and although he says he tried to get out, he signed a contract to be there! Watada should pay the government and tax payers back for all the money he earned (stole) by joining by military and not supporting its ultimate cause. Also, I understand he's still being paid. Let him go and let his supporters support him out of their own pockets - not mine!
Jail Him!
Honolulu

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 4:19 pm HST]
Here is to our Judicial system. It seems that the majority is upset and against Ethren Watada's decision, yet, he seems to be winning in the court of law. We should have the people of America vote on whether he is guilty or not guilty. EH Honolulu
EH
Honolulu

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 4:19 pm HST]
This guy is a disgrace to all branches of the United States Military! Just looking at his face makes me cringe. He is just scared and is trying to find a way out. They should slam this guy with the most harsh sentence possbile. "Hang him out to dry" like he did to his fellow soldiers that he failed to go to Iraq with. Did he forget what he swore to when he raised his right hand? Let me remind him: "I will support and defend the Constitution of the United States against all enemies, foreign or domestic, that I will bear true faith and allegiance to the same; that I take this obligation freely, without any mental reservations or purpose of evasion; and that I will well and faithfully discharge the duties of the office upon which I am about to enter; So help me God."
Kevin
Waikele

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 4:17 pm HST]
I Spoke with a 442nd member( Go for Broke Unit) one night at dinner while he wore a 442nd designed shirt so proudly. He was big time against Watadas actions.Curious.. was it his personal views or was it the 442nd view. Go for Broke. They didnt say " Ill go fight in the Pacific instead of Europe" they just went!
Walter
Makakilo

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 4:16 pm HST]
COWARD!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Warrior
Hawaii Kai

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 4:13 pm HST]
COWARD!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Plain and simple. I would have more respect for him if he said he is a coward then hide behind liberal values!
bill
honolulu

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 4:10 pm HST]
Hey SD, do you honestly think that the Majority of hawaii supports and is proud of him? I thought that was pretty funny. 2nd of all this comment page is just a comment page take it easy, its not an official survey. Man its funny how much time people have on their hands.
JJ
Waipahu

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 4:09 pm HST]
Put the traitor in jail and make him pay the taxpayers back for money wasted. He is a disgrace as he is the first traitor of Japanese American Ancestry. He volunteered .. Ehrin should realize that the lawyer is just there to make a name for himself by defending him. He should have become a politician.
Ashley
Wahiawa

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 4:09 pm HST]
Everday we read about the death toll in Iraq. But the numbers are deceiving, because a lot of those deaths come from friendly fire and accidents. The one thing that the media doesn't not put out is this: Since the Military went to the Middle East, there have been 0 terrorist attacks in America. I like to thank all the Military and National Guard people who sacrificed themselves for this cause. Ethren Watada is a selfish discraceful human being. If he were drafted, then I would understand but he is a Military officer! War is the down side of being in the Military and he should have known that when he entered. He also puts shame on the Japanese people too. The Iraq war is not illegal. EH Honolulu
Ernest Hasegawa
Honolulu

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 4:05 pm HST]
My son is a soldier in Iraq.... If something bad was to happen him... It was his choice.It would be hard but yes I could live with that.He volounteered to serve in the Worlds best Country/Army. God Bless our Warriors.
walter
Makakilo

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 4:05 pm HST]
Ho, brah, that guy making us look bad. He just sked. Since he no like, leavum in jail. What dis, I sign one pepa and make like I dunno what I signing. His fault. He shoulda got one lawyer with him befo signing. He not one kid anymore, no can play dumb and get out of one contract just cause you thought was something else. Read the fricken thing. No understand, get somebody else for understand for you. That guy one idiot cuz.
Braddah
Honolulu

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 4:04 pm HST]
Watada and his attorney are showing, as other cases have shown, that our judicial system one of gamesmanship. Aside from the underlying complaint, some charges were dropped in exchange for a stipulation, the prosecution then relies on the stipulation to prepare its case for trial, then at trial Watada claims he did not understand the stipulation, leaving the prosecution no choice but to move for a mistrial, and Watada is waiting to claim double jeopardy. The system needs to be cleaned up, as even the military tribunals are proving to be somewhat dysfunctional. People like OJ walk free, and people like Charles Manson remain alive. The system does not work.
lava
honolulu

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 4:03 pm HST]
Unfortunately, there is no other way to categorize him other than a disgrace to his uniform, his service, his state, his country, and his manhood. It's is the ultimate selfish act that disrespects all those who laid the foundation for the freedom of this great nation!
D. Bullock
Pearl City

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 4:03 pm HST]
Mr. Watada was looking for a loophole and found one. If he gets off on a technicality then the judge should be disbarred. The Army needs to hold its ground on this individual who knew the consequences and made his own decision to put himself before the committment he made. If folks like Mr. Watada were the norm in WWII the Nazis would have won thus erasing the Jews from the world. Mr. Watada you knew your commitment, now know the payment for your dessertion/treason and pay your price. Ask yourself Mr. Watada, Why don't the Iraqis deserve freedom? I assure you if Mr. Watada gets away with this it will not be cheers in the the streets of Honolulu he hears, it will be the tears of the ones who paid the ultimate sacrafice before him to further Freedom. Mr. Watada you are Disgraceful?
Speedy
Mililani

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 4:03 pm HST]
This comment page is not accurate. The same person could be leaving comments under different names. The Honolulu Advertiser doesn't require any full name, address, or email to leave a comment. This is the fault of the Honolulu Advertiser. But, to any readers, I find these comments astonishing, because I am certain most of Hawaii supports Ehren Watada and is very proud of him.
sd
diamond head

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 4:00 pm HST]
As a military person especially an officer who misses troop movement, he is an absolute disgrace to the Nation. He should be punished for his behavior and made to pay the taxpayers for money wasted on him. Irregardless of whether the war is right or wrong, he failed to his part as an enlisted officer. He should be referred to as the first traitor of "Japanese American decent" .
Leonard
Oahu

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 3:56 pm HST]
A mistrial is declared due to technical reasons, in this case Wartada claimed he did not know what he was signing. You would think an officer with his rank would carefully review anything before signing, but I guess he was distracted because he was concerned for his unit who he let go to Iraq on their own. Therefore he was never tried with a jury rendering a decision. The statement that his attorney made about double jeopardy does not apply here. A new trial will be scheduled and he will be found guilty and sent to prison.
aburage
bayfront

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 3:55 pm HST]
I am very dissapionted, Watada must have understood that our country was at war and runing away from his duties had to have consiquences. This another sad day for the United States!
Ed Fenwick
Kane'ohe

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 3:55 pm HST]
This is my first comment ever on this. It's just a matter of time before he gets his just reward. Like it or not he volunteered, you obey orders, that's it. What about all the other gallant men and women serving, who didn't want to go either. I think he should apologize especially to the families who have lost dear ones. He should be dishonorably discharged and put away. I don't feel he should get away.
Moses
Maui

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 3:53 pm HST]
He should have run for politics rather than be a soldier. Soldiers do the walking. Politicians do the talking. Should have gone to war first and then come home and run for office. Now he has become a dishonored soldier and no respect if he try and run for office. Japanese soldiers are known for their bravery and honor. Kamakazi and "GO FOR BROKE" Thousand do not agree with the war, but that does not mean you make excuse. Many locals have given their lives since the second world war. But this story is too shameful and too hard for many locals to read. Why not bring news about our brave men and women out on the field. This story overblown for political reasons? '
FT
Ewa beach

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 3:48 pm HST]
your update at 3:24pm says that Watada's lawyer thinks today's mistrial means that this case is likely over. I will be absolutely livid if this is the end of it, and he walks away a free man! he couldn't serve his country by going to iraq, then serve this country now and do us all a favor and rot in prison for a while.
k
waikele

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 3:47 pm HST]
Whatever the outcome, this will be something he will have to live with for the rest of his life. He will not be remembered as a hero but someone who let his troops and most of all, the Americans of Japanese ancestry who fought so courageously and gallantly in WWII down. He is able to reap the rewards and live freely at the expense of others who sacrificed. How disgraceful! He claims he researched but, he looked for and found a way out. He will forever have to live with the fact that he is never to be trusted. What a sad life.
K
Pearl City

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 3:46 pm HST]
He is a coward send him to prison, its a disgrace to say he is from Hawaii. Hawaii has lost a lot of good men who believed and fought for this country.
RP
Hilo

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 3:45 pm HST]
He knew what he was getting into when he joined. He needs to stop making excuses. We don't have to know him to agree or disagree with what he's doing. Plain and simple, he didn't want to go to Iraq. Plain and simple, do his time in jail. Plain and simple, we all have choices in life. Plain and simple, he made the wrong choice for his life/career. He should have remained a civillian if he didn't want to go to war. Plain and simple...
C
Honolulu

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 3:42 pm HST]
He is still in the Army and lots of Army members have been to Iraq more than once. Write him a set of orders and send him to Iraq. If he refuses again, give him 20 years jail time.
Bob Roast
Waikiki

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 3:40 pm HST]
The man HAD a duty to serve the Army and go where he would be sent. Period. As an Army officer you're bound by contract to serve. That being said the war in Iraq is not illegal as it is WRONG. It has ZERO to do with the war on terrorism as it was more Bush's biggest publicity stunt blunder. Watada SHOULD serve some time for the way in which he broke a legal binding contract. He should not be considered a traitor though because the war is just wrong. Finish what we did in Afghanistan or go INTO Pakistan and get those al-Qaeda scum RESPONSIBLE for 9/11 and not some sideshow turned quagmire because it looked like a "cakewalk" to spoonfeed American citizens. All you Bush supporters are in the MINORITY because Iraq is unraveling to be a joke-at the expense of US soldiers!
Marcus
Ewa beach

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 3:38 pm HST]
I think it's ludicrous,he should be charged and also given a dishonorable discharge from the military.
DEREK
KANEOHE

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 3:37 pm HST]
GH, Yes it's true that watada said he would take a combat post in Afghanistan or elsewhere. And he also said, if you don't then I'll talk to the media. What does he think of our military? And what do you think?
Jillian
Aiea

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 3:36 pm HST]
I'm born and raised here in Hawaii and I realize Hawaii residents like to cheer for their HOMEBOY. But this incident needs to be very clear in its procedure. Watada should not be allowed to walk away from this free as a bird. The whole structure of the military, government, business needs to follow orders and assignments. It would be chaos if every military personnel or public sector employee could pick and choose what they want to do. He knew what he was getting into when he enlisted. I am against the Iraq conflict, my son went their, my daughter and son are still on active duty. By the way, I cheered for Indianapolis Colts and not for Olin's team!
pikoni
honolulu

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 3:35 pm HST]
This isn't about whether the war is justified or not. It's a about a soldier's decision to disobey an order. He knew when he enlisted in the Army that there would be a time when he would eventually have to follow his fellow soldiers into combat whether he thought it was right or not. Bottom line is he disobeyed a direct order and now he must accept the consequences of his decision.
keith
mililani

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 3:33 pm HST]
Its a volunteer army. He volunteered but decided he didnt want to go. No good to have someone there that doesnt want to be there. Let him pay back the benefits and be a free man. I'm surprised anyone would volunteer for such a senseless and unnecesary war. Let them all come home if they want. Let Bush and his cronies go fight instead.
town girl
honolulu

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 3:33 pm HST]
I totally DISAGREE with "a servicemember of the military must obey orders at all times". Servicemembers have the right to make the RIGHT DECISION. But I do agree that Lt. Watada should be punnished to preserve the "Chain of Command".
PR
Waikele

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 3:32 pm HST]
Watada, his lawyer, his father and anyone supporting him miss the point. He is not being tried under the constitution. He is being tried under the UCMJ (Uniform Code of MILITARY Justice). According to that code he is guilty. He is not brave, he is dumb for listening to his father and lawyer. His reading comprehension also shows he is dumb. Maybe he did save some soldiers by not going! However, in the military you follow orders, not evaluate them. The legality or morality of the war won't be an issue. Not following orders and conduct unbecoming an officer is what he is being tried for. According to the UCMJ he will get a dishonorable discharge, become a felon, no government job like Daddy and he will spend time in a federal prison. They will like him there!
Kamuela
Oahu

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 3:32 pm HST]
What happened to all the people with the passion and heart of the 60's? They changed the world. Now we are left with idiots who talk a lot of smack while watching from the sidelines! Watada has passion and heart and stood up for what he believes in. The war is illegal!! President Bush is a liar! If the US military has orders to kill everyone who lives in Hawaii, would all you idiots just roll over and take that also?
dk
honolulu

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 3:30 pm HST]
I hope this mistrial leads to lesser punishment, or even a dismissal of the action. Ehren Watada is a true American patriot, and will be recognized as such in the years to come.
Jay
Kaimuki

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 3:30 pm HST]
Forfeiture of all pay from day one, total dishonarable discharge, and send him to Sand Island for treatment....
SmokingBatuinKalihi
Kalihi Valley

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 3:30 pm HST]
He was not forced or drafted into the military. He voluntarily signed up after 9/11. Surely he knew there was the possibility of war. Also, he says he is willing to go to Afghanistan. You can't pick and choose where you want to fight in the military. He should just plead guilty and accept the consequences.
kh
Honolulu

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 3:30 pm HST]
Fry Him!!! As an officer of the United States Army, it is not for you to determine wether the war that you are ordered to fight is right or wrong. That's a political matter. There are certain privileges that you give up by being in the military, and those are one of them. Mr. Watevah knew this going into the serice. So, Fry Him, Fry Him, Fry Him. That's what he deserves.
Felix San Roque
Palo Alto

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 3:27 pm HST]
For those of you who are saying the war in Iraq is illegal.....HELLO. Its a war on terrorism. Iraq supported terrorist groups with training camps, money and weapons.
dlo
Honolulu

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 3:24 pm HST]
Although I don't agree with the President's decision to invade Iraq, I must agree that Lt. Watada should be imprisoned to the maximum extent of the UCMJ. Watada knowlingly joined the Army after the initial plans of the invasion and should have expected to deploy there or Afghanistan. Even though he offered to deploy to Afghanistan, as a servicemember of the military he must obey orders at all times. Imagine if every servicemember tried to determine where they should serve or deploy. The entire obedience that all of the military services are founded upon would erode. The chain of command is what keeps our military in order and the men and women who are REALLY willing to fight for our freedoms are what keep it strong. Punish Watada according to the law.
B
Honolulu

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 3:21 pm HST]
bumbye he learn!!!!.....lol
mike
honolulu

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 3:21 pm HST]
This from Watada supporters' website: To prepare for deployment, Lt. Watada initiates research to learn more about the region and its people; how and why the war began; and the evidence presented for the U.S. Congress to approve the war. Over time, he becomes convinced that Congressional approval of the war was based on manipulated intelligence and the war is, in fact, illegal. If he obeys orders to fight in an illegal war, it will constitute an illegal act. He must therefore resign his commission. This is his rationale. It's not about being afraid to go to war, it's about going to war for the right reasons. Can't pick and choose, well maybe Watada will teach America that we should hold our government accountable for choosing for us. We sure chose wrong in Iraq.
Aloha
Honolulu

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 3:21 pm HST]
We did find WMDs. A month or two back it was announced the US had uncovered over 500 shells loaded with mustard and Sarin gas. True, not the mass quantities we thought we would find but still enough to kill thousands. This fact was under reported or ignored by the mainstream media. Others were probably hidden and still more sent to Syria. Regardless - WATADA broke his contract with the Army. He failed to live up to his duties as an officer and should go to jail for doing so. He is no hero. What's more is he shames Hawai'i, his family and all oour other Brave men and women who signed up to serve their country honorably.
Fred
Kailua

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 3:18 pm HST]
If the Lt didn't "understand" the document he signed, our troops don't NEED him, as an OFFICER, leading them in battle. It is a good thing he didn't go to battle. Hopefully he will be discharged from service.
MW
Honolulu

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 3:17 pm HST]
Watada is too conscientious and free-thinking to serve in the military. The chain of command is set up to deter independent thought and values. While I agree with the argument that the Iraq War is illegal, Watada will need to be punished to preserve the chain of command. I do believe, though, that history will be kind to him and he’ll be able to find suitable employment when he gets out with someone with left-leaning tendencies.
Steven
Waipahu

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 3:13 pm HST]
I can't believe how ignorant some of the people that posted comments are; it's disgusting! Lt. Watada did the right thing, the war in Iraq is illegal, there are no weapons of mass destruction and no conection to Bin Laden. Bush released false information to get us into this MESS. Lt. Watada clearly stated that he would deploy to Afghanistan to fight the war on terror, not to fight the illegal overthrow of Hussein. Doesn't this sound familiar? Like the overthrow of the Hawaiian Monarchy? And what is with the judge saying he can't use an Amendment 1 case? Doesn't military personal have the same freedoms as the rest of us? Or by protecting your country, do you give up your rights as a U.S. citizen? This whole case is terrible and so are the people that think he is a coward!!
K
Pearl City

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 3:13 pm HST]
I am absolutely amazed at how heated, judgemental and hurtful these comments are. Regardless of your opinion about Lt. Watada's decision to not deploy, the viperous comments on this site speak more of your character than it does of his. I wish for each of us that we will choose our words carefully.
ld
Kalihi Valley

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 3:13 pm HST]
He is a coward! Lock him up and throw away the key! He is a disgrace to everyone who every served in the military or died for their country!
Ann
Honolulu

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 3:12 pm HST]
Whether the war in Irag is illegal or immoral is not the point. This "man" took an oath as not only a soldier, but as an Officer. He is only using his "conscience" as an excuse for his cowardice. Whether he is imprisoned or not, the fact is, he is "safe" while his comrades are dying while fulfilling the oaths they took when joining the military. The mistrial only allows him to avoid the consequences of his actions and enjoy the freedom the "REAL" soldiers are fighting and dying for.
Disgusted
honolulu

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 3:11 pm HST]
Isn't this current war that we are involved in about terrorism? Did Saddam attack the U.S.? Did we find any WMD? Do we really know that he was harboring Bin Laden or Al-qaeda? Most terrorist in Iraq are forien fighters from Syria, Pakistan, and Sudan. The answer ladies and gentlemen is no. Was it not the main points in this current administrations reasoning to go to war with Iraq? You tell me.
DJ
Manoa

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 3:10 pm HST]
This just shows that Watada is either an idiot or his attorney is really smart. He doesn't deserve to be called "Lieutenant." He's an insult to the military.
LS
Hawaii Kai

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 3:04 pm HST]
Lt Watada broke his vows and pledge to his country. He knew what he was signing up for and he knows what the circumstances are. Stand up and be a man and take your punishment without shaming your family, heritage and state in this attempt to find a 'loophole' and weasel out of your commitment.
E Morimoto
California

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 3:00 pm HST]
He CHOOSE to join the military. He was not forced to do so. By joining he accepted his responsibilities to serve hi country. He made ut with all those perks of joining our armed services and not when asked to repay it he coughs out. What a coward. He cheated the system, he cheated his country, worst of all he backed out of heis fellow service men and women.
chris
Pearl City

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 2:52 pm HST]
Lt. Watada has far more courage than anyone one of us posting on this site. He signed up for the Army, he would gladly go fight in Afghanistan (where all of our troops should be), and he refused to deploy because he feels the Iraq war is illegal even when he knew it likely meant a court martial and time in prison. I wish I had the guts to stand up for what I believe in as much as he does. As far as the trial goes, it seems to be stacked very much against Lt. Watada. None of his proposed defenses were allowed, and when he gets a break, the judge declares a mistrial rather than proceeding with the prosecution at a disadvantage. Soldiers are humans before they are soldiers and have just as much of a duty to ignore illegal orders as they do to follow legal ones. I salute you Ehren.
dmcd
honolulu

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 2:51 pm HST]
What most of America does not know is that it is possible to [B][U]immediately[/U][/B], now and not in six months, bring the troops from Iraq without any adverse consequences or civil war occurring in Iraq. I think that all of the comments left here about Watada have merit and I feel that all of our military judges are very good and fair judges. It is unfortunate that Watada did not have a better attorney, who could have correctly advised Watada. It seems that both Watada and his attorney are not very well-informed! Lester D.K. Chow and Associates P.O. Box 4604 Honolulu, Hawaii 96812
Lester D.K. Chow and Associates
Honolulu, Hawaii

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 2:50 pm HST]
LT Watada should spend his time awaiting trial in jail. This will get him ready for his the next five years in a cell. He is a coward - plain and simple!
aa
Hawaii

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 2:50 pm HST]
What facts did we miss? Enlighten us.
tk
honolulu

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 2:49 pm HST]
I am a Hawaiian/Japanese American and I serve proudly in the US Air Force. I'm ashamed by the whole situation involving Lt. Watada, he makes other guys from Hawaii look bad. His actions are selfish and bring discredit on the armed forces. I do respect his opinion, but there is a proper way to voice your opinion. As members of the armed forces we must conform to the UCMJ, and his actions are a deliberate violation of those laws. I hope he thinks about how this reflects upon himself, and more importantly his family and where he comes from. He is, in my opinion an embarrassment to the people of Hawaii, especially to those who have given there lives for this country.
SSgt Tsukiyama
Panama City FL

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 2:48 pm HST]
Wow, how bitter the residents of Hawai`i can be when they are ignorant of the facts in this case. Since when did you all become such experts in military justice? You need to learn how to respect people even as you have a difference of opinion with them, rather than sinking to adolescent name-calling.
Embarassed for you
Kane`ohe

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 2:48 pm HST]
Whatever his reasons for not going, I just know that someone else had to go in his place - someone with a wife, kids, etc.
TK
Honolulu

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 2:47 pm HST]
Watada should #1 Go to jail, or #2 pay back all the money us taxpayers gave him (except for minimum wages). If thats the case everyone could join the military and then decide not to go to war if they are ordered to do such. We do not pay soliders to think, they are to do what they are told by the government. That is why most of us will never join the military in the first place. He should have known what he was getting into. That is why most citizens aren't in the military. Watada is a coward and an idiot. He didn't think when he joined the military and now all of a sudden when he's sent to the front line, he wants to think, give me a break.
Travis
Honolulu

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 2:45 pm HST]
I think all of this that Watada is doing was premeditated. It's not like he didn't know he was going to be sent to war eventually. I mean, he swore in after 9/11 happened. He must've known there was a good chance he would be deployed one day. You would have to be living under a rock to not know what was going on in this country. I think that Watada joined the military just so he could have this opportunity to refuse to be deployed. I think he's trying to prove a point. However, I think he's going to suffer some major consequences to prove that point.
gg
honolulu

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 2:45 pm HST]
Watada is lucky he lives USA. Does he really expect the American people to believe that he didn't know what he was signing - oh, I forgot probably those Hollywood types would. God Bless America and all our brave men and women who did follow what they signed up for.
Mary
Honolulu

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 2:36 pm HST]
WHAT PART OF THIS ILLEGAL WAR DON'T YOU WARMONGERS UNDESTAND? IF OSAMA BIN LADEN (HE ORCHESTRATED 9-11) PUNCHED YOUR MOTHER IN THE MOUTH, WHO WOULD YOU GO AFTER OSAMA BIN LADEN OR SADDAM HUSSEIN? AND IF ANY OF YOU "COWARDS" READ ON LT. WATADA SAID HE WOULD TAKE A COMBAT POST IN AFGHANISTAN OR ELSE WHERE. SO SALUTE THIS!!!!!!!
GH
HONOLULU

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 2:32 pm HST]
Ignorance is a lack of knowledge, most of you bloggers don't really know what he's fighting for. All you know is that he didn't want to deploy to Iraq. Before you judge someone, get to know a little about them.
Denny
Honolulu

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 2:27 pm HST]
Lt. Watada is an embarasshment to Hawaii and all the brave men and women from Hawaii who haved served honorably in the military. In 1969 I went to Vietnam; I didn't want to go but believed I had a duty and obligation as a citizen to serve and I did. Well after his 4 years at Leavenworth is up and with his dishonorable discharge he will see how difficult the rest of his life will be.
Ron
Manoa

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 2:22 pm HST]
Amen Law Abiding Citizen! NO TRUE AMERICAN WOULD DO THAT!
Drock
Honolulu

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 2:21 pm HST]
Lock this guy up and lets move on. I'm tired of seeing him and his dad on the news. Yes the war is wrong but do your research BEFORE you sign up. What an idiot and a waste of our tax dollars. He should just admit he was scared.
Fred
Honolulu

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 2:21 pm HST]
If Mr. Watada is truly the "hero" he and others claim, he would plead GUILTY to all charges and serve his time. He trained with his unit, he ate with them, he slept with them. When they needed him most, he deserted them. No true officer would ever do that.
Law Abiding Citizen
Aiea, Hawaii

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 2:19 pm HST]
Because there seems to be some confusion, I'd like to clarify that the prosecution requested the mistrial, while Watada's counsel opposed it. The mistrial will actually open Watada up to further liability for his actions - in no way is this good for him. Further, while I believe that an enlisted soldier assumes the risk that he/she will be sent off to war at a moment's notice, I do not agree that this assumption includes the risk that the soldier will be sent off to fight in a wholly unjustified and illegal war. Hang in there, Ehren.
Jason
Honolulu

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 2:17 pm HST]
How can you call us cowards for not signing up for the military? It is a choice. He chose his career. No one (but maybe his father) coerced him. He is a grown man and understood fully that their is a possibility he could be called out. Did he think he was going to have a desk job for the rest of his life? He enjoyed all the benefits that were offered to him and when it came down to really work for it, he chickened out. He is a coward and an embarrassment to Hawai`i. If you believe war is wrong then you should have never enlisted. WATADA (notice I left the Lt. out you don't deserve it) YOU SHOULD HAVE GOTTEN A JOB FLIPPING BURGERS AT MCDONALDs! That way if you didn't like the job you could've just quit and not put the rest of your unit in danger when you chickened out. AUWE!
Noelani
Wahiawa

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 2:17 pm HST]
For this coward to say he "didn't" know what he signed just to prolong the inevitable is an act of disgrace. It just makes him look foolish to think that now he can lie to the judge and say he didn't understand what he signed. To me, he's just a conniving coward playing the game to bide his time. What an embarrassment he is to the brave men and women of the armed forces!
A Kama'aina Patriot
Ewa

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 2:15 pm HST]
If he was commissioned through Army ROTC in college, I can see his hesitation in deploying. If he was commissioned through the Army OCS program, no excuse, Salute the flag and serve your country well. If he was a direct commissioned officer, he should know better. Bottomline, he signed and swore to defend the constitution of the U.S. against all enemies, foreign and domestic, etc........... He needs to live up to his commitment and pay the penalty for his embarrassing actions. I am truly ashamed of him, especially coming from Hawaii. Stop wasting our valuable taxpayers dollars and everyones time on this farce. His smokescreen defense must cease immediately. Be a man and face the music, no matter how bad.
Retired Officer
Honolulu, Hawaii

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 2:14 pm HST]
What would the 442nd think?
Jane Doe
Honolulu

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 2:12 pm HST]
All of you who use simplistic slogans and name calling are ignorant of history. When the Allies held the Neuremburg Trials after World War II, the Nazis on trial stated as their defense that they were merely following orders, even if what they did was morally wrong. The Neuremburg decision states that one cannot use that excuse. Lt. Watada's rationale for not going to Iraq is that doing so and fighting in an illegal war is morally wrong. Are we going to agree with Nazis that one should fight for one's country even though one believes the country is engaged in a war that is morally wrong?
Gary
Honolulu

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 2:09 pm HST]
WATABABE SHOULD HAVE BEEN CONVICTED. MANY LIVES LOST ON WAR. HE SIGNED UP KNOWING WHAT RULES AND REGULATIONS SIGNED.BAD DECISION ON JUDGE
EKAHELE
KANEOHE

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 2:04 pm HST]
I'm also embarrassed the Watada is from Hawaii. He voluntarily joined the military and now he claims the war is illegal? What about the rest of the service men and women who are there? They make thing the same thing but they realize that the order comes from their boss and it is their job to follow those orders. So they get on the plane and fight because it is what they are trained and paid to do. Who held the gun to his head and told him to join the Army? I hope they give him more than 4 years for his actions and for shaming Hawaii.
Jennifer
Honolulu

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 2:04 pm HST]
He is a coward, I have served in the armed forces. Saying he didn't understand the charges is just him playing dumb! I hope they add more charges in the re-trial.(can they?) He was fine in being an officer, until he had to serve in a wartime situation. It doesn't matter if he thought the war was wrong, he knew what he was signing up for when he became an officer.
Roy Matsuyama
Kauai

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 2:02 pm HST]
He should be banished from the country.
Keaka
Honolulu

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 2:00 pm HST]
Maka, the constitution does give him the right to stand up for what he believes in. But, it's not his right to pick and choose his assignments as a member of the armed forces. The whole structure of the armed forces is based on following a chain of command and following orders. He broke that chain, and he is going to be punished...it's that simple. Reasons behind the war are not relevant. He was given an order and refused to follow. Can you imagine what our society would be like if every soldier sent off to fight had the option of backing out if they didn't agree with their orders?
No Maka
Kalihi

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 2:00 pm HST]
He took a pledge when he joined the military and knew what he was in for. Then, he broke that pledge. He signed a document acknowledging he did not deploy to Iraq with his unit, and now he says he didn't understand what he was signing. And his supporters say he's a smart man. Give me a break. He's as stupid as an Ass. Lock him up and throw away the key.
A. Amasaki
Torrance, California

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 1:59 pm HST]
How can he claim he did not know what he is signing!? Here I thought Officers are supposed to be intellegent. Well I guess that makes him a STUPID COWARD!
Drock
Honolulu

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 1:55 pm HST]
Picky, picky, picky... a mere technicality. Too bad this wasn't a Navy deployment the coward refused to meet... otherwise he would've been hung from a yardarm by now! I'm so embarrassed this clown is from Hawaii. My mainland relatives have already been giving me an earful of grief regarding Watada.
BigTexKahuna
Honolulu

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 1:53 pm HST]
Just prolonging his trip to Ft Leavenworth. Waste of tax payers money....he's lucky they don't charge him as a deserter in time of war and shoot him.
John Doe Again
Ewa Beach

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 1:53 pm HST]
All he (Lt. Watada) had to do was to report and deploy with his unit. Then he could have protested or objected. That was the order he allegedly received. What was he thinking? Follow the lawful order: report and deploy with your unit. Then if ordered to fight, don't. Or next time, don't join a probable fighting unit. Or better yet, don't join for the perks. There is no draft, so, no fear of being called up.
BD
Honolulu

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 1:52 pm HST]
I'm in the military and I call him a coward. I also call him an idiot. Today's mistrial is bad for him, it negates his plea deal and also opens him up to more charges. He was looking at 4-6 years, if the Prosecution now invokes willifully disobeying a direct order as well as the two charges in the plea deal you can add 10-15 more.
Jay
Makaha

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 1:50 pm HST]
All you people out there who is calling Ehren a coward are you a registered in the military? You all should take the next flight out to Iraq and fight next to your fellow Americans. If you don't have the guts to do this well...guess what, you all are cowards too ha ha ha!!! Be careful what you say about others because you might be talking about your own self.
Faith
Aiea

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 1:45 pm HST]
His actions are a slap in the face to the forces already in Iraq. The people who are protesting on his behalf have misdirected their energies. They should be protesting to bring back the soldiers that are already over there instead of trying to protect this coward. They stand out there and call him a "hero"? He signed a contract (AFTER the war had started), reaped the benefits the military provided, and then when it came time to fulfill his end of the deal, refused to do so. What's so heroic about that? Was it only as his deployment grew nearer that he started to think about the legality of this war? This individual has no loyalty. Not to his country, the men he trained with, or those who trained under him. He should be reviled, not celebrated. He is selfishness personified.
ES
Honolulu

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 1:45 pm HST]
Ehren Watada did his homework and deserves to be free!!!!!
G. Nakazawa
Hawaii

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 1:44 pm HST]
Yet again, Watada failed to READ what's written on the piece of paper. So similar to the reason why he's in this mess in the first place: He thought that his military agreement said it was ok to receive government funds and still refuse to serve when the Government called upon him. What a joke. Throw him in jail.
John Doe
Kalihi

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 1:40 pm HST]
Everyone is so ready to crucify this poor guy who's just going by the constitution. I would have gone to Iraq for my country but get your prioties straight. Afghanastan was who our fight was aimed at in the first place to get Bin Ladden who started this whole terrorists war. We couldn't even get that right because he's still out there. If we stuck it out and got the guy, then and only then I'd go to Iraq. Now everything is so out of control. Remember before we interferred with Iraq, those middle east countries were at war with each other for centuries and that will never change. I love our country but get back on track and honor our constitution...I don't think Watada should be crucified for standing up for what he believes in. Our constitution gives him that right.
Maka
Honolulu

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 1:36 pm HST]
Watada's lawyer understands that this mistrial is the kiss of death for his weasel client. Serves both of them right. Serve your country or serve your time. This should open up the punshiment for a much longer sentence for the liberal coward. Good for him!
Keoni
Hilo

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 1:31 pm HST]
Watada appears to be a "sophisticated head case"...this mistrial just delays the "inevitable jail time he should receive"....and his father was chairman of the ethics spending committee.....what a shame???
Mel Padello
Waipio, Hawaii 96797

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 1:28 pm HST]
Great News! It's not his fault that the President made the Titanic mistake of invading Iraq. History will not be kind to Bush, the Lt. will eventually be a Hero.
Perry Lansing
Princeville, HI

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 1:20 pm HST]
Why join the army and then say you no like fight. Looks like a coward to me! Do what it takes to make an example of him...putting him away for four years seems too short. Hard labor at leavenworth maybe?? Thats justice for a coward.
Kimo
Big Island

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 1:18 pm HST]
Lt Watada once said that he would rather spend the rest of his life behind bars, rather than fight in Iraq. I think they should give him what he wants.
ejy
Honolulu

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 1:17 pm HST]
Weasel
I love the USA
Honolulu, HI

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 1:14 pm HST]
Military Court of Law; you are treated fairly, but not equally. Lt. Watada's defense took a major hit.
Billy Paton
Wailuku, Maui

[Posted on February 7, 2007 at 1:12 pm HST]
It is a mere glitch on the prosecution of an officer, who I think joined the armed forces, on the behest of his, draft dodger father, just so that he could try to make his father's point once more. I think and hope he fries.
Ron Olsen
Honolulu