honoluluadvertiser.com

Sponsored by:

Comment, blog & share photos

Log in | Become a member
The Honolulu Advertiser

Updated at 4:02 a.m., Sunday, November 4, 2007

Mamiya Theatre proves to be intimate symphony venue

By Ruth Bingham
Special to The Advertiser

Last night's concert by the Honolulu Symphony continued the theme that circumstances have imposed on the first half of the season: exploring the relationship between venue and repertoire.

The venue this week was Chaminade's Mamiya Theatre, a hall too small for a modern symphony orchestra but just right for what we now call a chamber orchestra – 12 to 30 musicians.

Fortunately, that was the usual size of orchestras in the Baroque and Classical eras. Saturday's program offered audiences an opportunity to hear live performances of works that are most often heard only in recordings today, works usually bypassed by chamber ensembles as being too large, and by orchestras as being too small.

In the first half, two concertos featured Honolulu Symphony musicians: oboist Scott Janusch and violinist Claire Sakai Hazzard in Bach's Concerto for Violin and Oboe, and 'cellist Mark Votapek in Boccherini's Concerto in G. In the second half, Pachelbel's Canon led into Dvorak's genial Serenade for Strings, a work that ought to be wildly popular and that provided an upbeat finale.

The most well-known work presented was Pachelbel's Canon, which was popularized by social service commercials on television: offers of help for abuse, addiction, and depression were conveyed along Pachelbel's soothing lines.

The Canon is a prime example of how crucial tempo can be. Played slowly, it flows calmly and tenderly; played faster, it becomes sprightly, exuberant. Too fast or too slow, and it morphs into manic or lugubrious.

Honolulu Symphony's version on Saturday evening was moderately slow, gentle and lilting. Standing in groups of threes, the violins wove lyrical lines around the recurring bass line in the 'cellos and harpsichord, while the three violas provided a touch of humor – standing in a row, plucking pizzicatos in turn throughout: plink - plink - plink.

Following Baroque and early Classical tradition, the musicians performed without a formal conductor; instead, concertmaster Ignace Jang and harpsichordist Thomas Yee of the University of Hawaii at Manoa shared leading the ensembles while playing.

The effect, especially in works using smaller ensembles, was exciting: musicians listened intently to each other, balance was excellent, and every voice was audible. The only work large enough to need a conductor was the Dvorak, with just under 30 musicians, and no conductor meant its ensemble occasionally frayed around the edges during tempo shifts.

Each work on Saturday turned out to be delightful, but the highlights were undoubtedly the featured soloists.

Hazzard's and Janusch's duets proved winsome, especially in the slow movement, and especially those by Janusch. Their timbres contrasted rather than matched, presenting two distinct voices in dialogue. Votapek, too, excelled in his slow movement and dazzled in the faster movements.

Yee was not listed in the program, but as the harpsichordist, he was essentially a fourth soloist, providing a bass-line foundation for both the Bach and the Pachelbel, fleshing-out chords, and often leading the ensemble as well.

As difficult as this season is for the Honolulu Symphony, moving between venues and creating non-standard programs to match venues that were never intended to house orchestras, Saturday's concert suggests new possibilities for future seasons.

Nothing quite matches the thrill of a modern symphony orchestra performing live, but these smaller works for chamber orchestras are well worth experiencing. They may even be worth the effort of programming occasional concerts in an intimate venue such as Mamiya Theatre.