honoluluadvertiser.com

Sponsored by:

Comment, blog & share photos

Log in | Become a member
The Honolulu Advertiser
Posted on: Tuesday, January 22, 2008

Child welfare visit to toddler's home too late

StoryChat: Comment on this story

By Peter Boylan
Advertiser Staff Writer

Hawaii news photo - The Honolulu Advertiser

Nancy Asiata Chanco

spacer spacer

CYRUS BELT'S FUNERAL

Visitation will be from 5 to 6 p.m. Thursday at Nu'uanu Memorial Park and Mortuary, West Chapel. Service begins at 6 p.m.

spacer spacer

SILENT MARCH, VIGIL TONIGHT

The state Legislature's Keiki Caucus has scheduled a silent march and candlelight vigil in memory of Cyrus Belt and Janel Tupuola beginning at 5 p.m. today at the state Capitol.

Belt, who would have turned 2 on Feb. 7, died Thursday after he was thrown from a pedestrian walkway onto H-1 Freeway. Tupuola, 29, was beaten to death last Wednesday in Kailua.

Arrests have been made in both cases.

spacer spacer
Hawaii news photo - The Honolulu Advertiser

Cyrus Belt

spacer spacer

A child welfare worker was assigned to go to Cyrus Belt's home after his mother tested positive for crystal methamphetamine six days before the toddler was thrown to his death from an H-1 overpass, a source familiar with the case said.

The visit was scheduled for the afternoon of the day he died.

It would have been the latest of several contacts Nancy Asiata Chanco had with child welfare services before her son died. The visit would have included a full assessment of the boy's living conditions and the parenting at home.

The visit was ordered after Chanco went to The Queen's Medical Center emergency room complaining of "a sore eye" on Jan. 11, state Department of Human Services records show.

While there, she was screened for drugs and tested positive for crystal methamphetamine or ice, said the source, who spoke on condition of anonymity because the information hasn't been formally released.

Chanco told hospital employees of her history with state Child Welfare Services and said her child lived with her grandfather and his wife, the records show.

CWS officials had taken Cyrus into protective custody for four days on June 19, 2006, because Chanco had left the boy with his father and his father's girlfriend in a residence without electricity. He was 4 1/2 months old then.

The hospital reported the mother's drug test results to the state, which immediately began a review of Chanco's CWS file and raised questions about her ability to maintain a safe home for Cyrus, the source said.

Catholic Charities of Hawaii was scheduled to go to Cyrus' home the afternoon of the day he died to conduct a full assessment of living and parenting conditions, the source said.

Chanco, who has a history of ice use, would not comment yesterday at her 'Iolani Avenue apartment.

Matthew M. Higa is being held on $1 million bail on a charge of second-degree murder in Cyrus' death.

Witnesses told police they saw Higa throw the child off the freeway overpass about 11:43 a.m. Thursday. Higa was arrested a short distance from the overpass, at 513 Prospect St., at 12:15 p.m., police said.

He is scheduled for an initial court appearance today.

Higa was tested for drugs after his arrest, and police said yesterday they are awaiting the results.

He lived with his father in the same Punchbowl-area apartment building as the child.

SUSPECT SEEN EARLIER

Police records show Higa was seen in the boy's neighborhood by police officers who first responded to reports that the child was wandering in the street.

At 11:12 a.m., Officer Bryson Romain, responding to the call of a wandering toddler, arrived and saw off-duty Officer Darryl Jones standing next to a "male family member" of the boy who was "holding a child," according to court documents.

Jones had found Cyrus wandering in the middle of the road in the area of 330 'Iolani Ave., near Chanco's apartment building, police said. Jones called in the report, retrieved the child and went looking for the boy's family.

Jones found the boy's grandfather, Lilo Asiata, and returned the child.

When Romain arrived, he saw Jones and Asiata, and also observed "a heavyset male, later identified as Higa, opposite 330 Iolani Avenue, wearing green hospital scrubs," the affidavit said.

DID POLICE CALL CPS?

Child welfare records state "no known call made to CPS (Child Protective Services) regarding wandering child."

Had the state been aware that Cyrus was found wandering that Thursday morning, officials would have intervened but they were never called by police, said Lillian B. Koller, director of the state Department of Human Services.

"This really was an unforeseeable type of thing," Koller said. "Stacked up with what we have in our records, it would have inflated our response."

When officers find a wandering child, they have the discretion to find a family member or other guardian or to call Child Welfare Services, police said. If an officer can find the child's family quickly and determines the child is not in danger, the officer has the discretion to return the child to the home, police said.

If the officer decides the child is in an unsafe situation, the officer can take custody of the child on behalf of the state, police said. In Hawai'i, police officers and deputy sheriffs have the authority to remove a child from the custody of guardians.

Honolulu Prosecuting Attorney Peter Carlisle had "no comment" yesterday when asked if criminal charges could be brought against family members or caregivers of Cyrus, but legal experts say possible criminal liability for Cyrus' death does not seem to extend beyond the person who threw him from the bridge.

HARD TO CHARGE FAMILY

It is a crime under state law to endanger the welfare of a minor by knowingly or recklessly allowing someone else to "inflict serious or substantial injury" on a minor.

Knowingly allowing such conduct is a third-degree felony punishable by up to five years in prison. Recklessly allowing the conduct is a misdemeanor punishable by up to a year in prison.

Criminal defense lawyer Howard Luke would not discuss the Higa case specifically but said that in cases with similar circumstances, prosecutors would be hard-pressed to bring charges against relatives of a murdered child.

"Realistically, in a case involving a terrible family tragedy, particularly the death of a child, I think a prosecutor would take great pause before bringing a criminal charge against a family member who did not harm the child," Luke said.

"What does the prosecution gain from that? What is the benefit to society?

"I don't see anything to be gained from bringing a criminal charge against someone who's already going through the agony of losing a dearly loved child."

Private attorney Frank O'Brien, who practices family law and who has sued the Department of Human Services and Child Welfare Services agency in the past over child custody and endangerment issues, was also unwilling to speak specifically about the Higa case.

"Let's assume that a mother left her child at home in the care of a responsible adult," O'Brien said.

If the child then was harmed by a third party, "I don't see how there would be any degree of legal jeopardy" for the mother, he said.

"Or let's suppose the mother knew the responsible adult was asleep at the time she left. That's obviously not the best situation for the child," he continued.

"If the child then somehow got outside, fell down the stairs and was injured, then the department (of Human Services) would probably view that as a case of neglect, but not a crime."

But if a third party harmed the child, charging a family member with a crime would be difficult, he said.

STATUS OF TWO OTHER KIDS

Koller, at the state Department of Human Services, said Child Welfare Services is currently looking for Chanco's two remaining children to ensure their safety.

Chanco is not living with or raising her other two children, but because of the circumstances surrounding Cyrus' death, the state wants to ensure the children are being cared for, Koller said.

"We have not received any complaints involving the other two children, but we don't want to take anything for granted," Koller said.

• • •

TIMELINE LEADING TO CYRUS' KILLING

April 14, 1997: Police report that Chanco and her eldest son, then 7, were fighting and Chanco put a rope around the child's neck and allegedly tried to kill him. The child was described as "incorrigible and beyond parental control," according to a report by social workers.

Aug. 13, 2002: Child welfare officials receive a complaint that Chanco neglected her eldest son. Chanco left the boy in the care of her mother-in-law to look for housing but did not provide for her son's care. The boy was later placed in the care of a hanai "auntie."
A report by social workers noted that Chanco had a history of violent relationships with three different men and that she had a history of drug abuse, including marijuana, crystal methamphetamine and cocaine. She was unemployed but was attending weekend classes at Chaminade University.

Aug. 13, 2002: Social workers called Chanco, who was willing to give power of attorney over the boy. Social workers then determine that Chanco is "no longer believed to be using drugs."

Child welfare officials determine that the potential for harm to the boy is "moderate" given that he is not living with his mother. They add that "threats of abuse based on mother's drug abuse are vague and that information is insufficient to warrant a former Child Protective Services investigation."

Dec. 26, 2002: The hanai auntie returns the boy to Chanco.

Dec. 28. 2002: During a routine traffic stop, police find Chanco's eldest son in a car with an unrelated man who had drugs in his possession. Social workers cite Chanco's history of drug abuse and begin a new inquiry.

HPD turns the boy over to his hanai auntie. Two days later he is given back to Chanco.
December 2002: Chanco gives birth to a second son.

Social workers' report noted that Chanco "has not bonded" with her newborn. She also exhibits inappropriate parenting skills like almost dropping the infant, holding the baby incorrectly and feeding the baby over-heated formula, the report said.

Jan. 10, 2003: Social workers meet with Chanco, counsel her on her newborn and conclude they have "no major concerns" about her.

May 5, 2003: Social workers determine that "despite past history of substance abuse, (Chanco) is clean and sober." Social workers close the case in September.

Feb. 7, 2006: Cyrus N. Belt is born. The Department of Human Services opens an investigation shortly after his birth.

Social workers reported that Chanco cut short her prenatal care "because of relapse on crystal methamphetamines." They said Chanco said that she smoked marijuana during her pregnancy and smoked ice "at approximately 5-6 months pregnant."

Feb. 10, 2006: Social workers close the case after they refer Chanco to family counseling services and assign her a family services assistant.

April 6, 2006: Social workers and Healthy Start workers make unannounced visits and find a clean apartment that Chanco shared with her father, stepmother, Cyrus and Chanco's boyfriend, who was Cyrus' father.

The baby appeared to be thriving, although he suffered from colic. Social workers, however, couldn't meet with Cyrus' father as he had been arrested and jailed for parole violations. Chanco's two other children were not living with her.

June 19, 2006: The Department of Human Services takes Cyrus, then 4› months old, into protective custody, after receiving reports that Chanco leaves her son in the custody of her father and "uses her government assistance to purchase drugs."

June 22, 2006: Chanco signs a voluntary custody agreement, allowing the state to place Cyrus in a foster home for 90 days. Social workers also note that Chanco's home is "without electricity" for several days and that members of her household fight and argue a lot.

June 26, 2006: DHS returns Cyrus to Chanco.

Aug. 10, 2006: Social workers meet with Chanco and feel that the baby appears healthy and thriving.

Jan. 11, 2008: State social workers make new inquiries after receiving a complaint about potential child abuse and neglect when Chanco is admitted to The Queen's Medical Center emergency room for a sore eye. Explanation for the referral redacted in copies of documents released to the public.

Jan. 17, 2008: Cyrus is killed when he is thrown from an overpass onto H-1.

Source: Documents released to media by the state Department of Human Services

Reach Peter Boylan at pboylan@honoluluadvertiser.com.

• • •

StoryChat

From the editor: StoryChat was designed to promote and encourage healthy comment and debate. We encourage you to respect the views of others and refrain from personal attacks or using obscenities.

By clicking on "Post Comment" you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Service and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator.