honoluluadvertiser.com

Sponsored by:

Comment, blog & share photos

Log in | Become a member
The Honolulu Advertiser
Posted on: Wednesday, February 4, 2009

TASTE
A FEW TWEAKS MAKE A KITCHEN WORK
Kitchen aid

 •  Culinary calendar
 •  Got recipes? Am hoping you'll share
 •  Sweet reward for your honest babe
 •  Following a destiny of wine
 •  Get ready to dish on 'My Island Plate'
 •  Muffins a sweet Valentine's treat

By Wanda A. Adams
Advertiser Food Editor

ASK DESIGNERS

To contact Clayton-Taylor & Co. designers: 808-823-9660; erikt@clayon-taylor.com; though based on Kaua'i, they work on all islands

spacer spacer

For Daniel Leung, it's gas (or the lack thereof).

For Frank Gonzales, it's counter space (ditto).

For Gloria Chee, it's hard-to-reach cupboards.

The subject: What bugs home cooks about kitchen design.

For me, it's just about everything — so much so that I spent part of the New Year's holiday writing a foaming-at-the-mouth rant about why home kitchen design hasn't changed substantially in my more than 50 years of standing at the stove, counter and sink (unless, of course, you can afford to have your kitchen custom-designed — and even then, it's often more show than go).

It begins, "My kitchen is my office. I only wish it was organized as efficiently as my other office."

I'll spare you the rest.

"The use of the kitchen has evolved, socially and cultural speaking," said Leung, an educational specialist in Kapi'olani Community College's culinary program.

Rather than being a set-apart workspace where Mom or a hired cook prepared food, it's become the social center of the household — the place where most families eat daily meals, where friends gravitate, where cell phones are charged, laptop computers perch on counters and a growing number of countertop appliances from microwaves to stand mixers, Cuisinarts to panini grills crowd the space.

"I don't think the people who design kitchens for the average home or condo really give much thought to the practical use of the room," said Gonzales.

The bachelor condo owner is a passionate home cook and culinary school graduate who runs the non-credit class program for Kapi'olani Community College's culinary school.

He tells of attempting a multicourse dinner and having to cache prepped food, finished food, serving pieces and ingredients throughout his Kapahulu condo — in the sink, on the pull-out cutting board, in and on the stove, in the living room, one on top of the other. The cupboards in his kitchen hang out so far over the counter that he can't get over the workspace or he'll bang his head on the cupboard doors. He's trained to do mis en place (the pre-cutting, measuring and so on of ingredients) and to arrange everything close to the cooking or assembly area to save steps, but his single 16-by-16-inch countertop frustrates him.

Gonzales' office-mate Leung, who grew up in a restaurant family in Hong Kong and loves to prepare meals for family and friends, recently completed remodeling his kitchen. Tops on the list was to install a gas-powered wok well for the high temperatures and instant heat control required for proper stir-frying. But the gas line stopped three houses from his home and would cost $6,000 to extend. Leung bought a propane tank instead and installed a "serious" hood and ventilation system.

"Kitchen designers are not necessarily cooks. If they liked to cook, they would think of the ergonomics, the space, the safety issues, the way the kitchen is really used. They don't ask anything about how you cook, what you cook," said Leung.

His designer wanted to provide only a narrow space next to his cooktop and to plant a large island in the middle of the room.

"But my wife and I like to cook together, and whenever we have people over, the kitchen becomes the entertainment center. People like to hang around and talk while we're cooking," Leung said.

If the space around the island is too narrow, there's danger from hot pots and extra steps for the cook — and all those people socializing get in the way. And space next to the cooking area is vital.

Chee, a Mililani mom who works part time and cooks from scratch for her family most nights, doesn't like it that she has to bend double or haul out a step-stool to reach the back of her cupboards.

"Why aren't they like drawers, that pull out?" she asks, plaintively. "And they assume everyone is the same height, but if you're short, like me, or if you're very tall, like my 6-foot-2 husband, the counter height isn't comfortable."

THE MAGIC TRIANGLE

One pair of home cooks who do understand the kitchen are Erik Taylor and Raymond Clayton, partners in life and in Kapa'a-based design firm Clayton-Taylor & Co. Taylor is a serious baker and Clayton loves to cook. He says the problem with Island kitchens isn't strictly one of space.

"Kitchens are usually too small but you can make a small kitchen work if it's laid out right," said Taylor in a phone interview. "You have to remember the triangle — a straight line from the refrigerator to the sink to the stove. If you don't have a good triangle, you're going to spend more time walking around the kitchen than you need to."

Like Leung, he's not a fan of kitchen islands. Or, if you need the workspace, he said, "there are some beautiful rolling butcher-block islands available that can be pulled into place when you need them and pushed out of the way when you don't."

I ran down my rant list with Taylor:

  • Surfaces that grab liquids, resist scrubbing, hold moisture, promote rust and are generally impossible to clean — such as textured refrigerator doors, painted glass-top stoves, stainless steel anything.

  • Rear stove controls that force you to lean over the hot burners and boiling pots to adjust the heat. Burner wells that incinerate spills and are fussy and difficult to clean (why can't electric stoves follow the gas model, in which the entire cooktop is finished with heavy-duty nonstick paint and lifts out for cleaning in the sink?)

  • Oven doors that open out and down, making it nearly impossible to reach the rear of the oven for cleaning. (Why can't they open to the side, like a car door? Professional bake ovens have double French doors that open to the side.)

  • Shallow sinks, surfaces that readily crack and chip, grout that stains and molds.

  • Counters that can't stand up to use: Formica and its cousins are easy to cut and chip, can't stand up to hot pots, stain easily and bond to grease and cookie dough but can't be scrubbed with abrasives or they'll lose their finish. Granite and marble are too expensive and show every dried-on drop of water; they also pit in the presence of acid. Corian stains. Woodblock is attractive in a country-hippie-folksy-'60s kind of way, but it, too, stains, burns and is easily sliced, so requires constant care.

  • Tile floors so hard your ankles ache after cooking a meal and anything you drop breaks into a million pieces; linoleum or tile criss-crossed with joints or grout crevices that attract spills and dirt and don't give them up easily.

    In a science-fiction novel I once read, they had invented a truly nonstick surface used for bathrooms and kitchens. Nothing, not even the tiniest bacteria, would adhere to it. Now that's the kind of creativity that needs to be turned on in the kitchen.

    KNOW WHERE TO SPLURGE

    Even though we were on the phone, I could see Taylor nodding as I ticked off the list. But he was full of suggestions, beginning with: "Know where to spend your money. Spend it on comfort and practicality if you're really going to use the kitchen."

  • Instead of expensive finished cabinetry, he recommends plain doorfronts and drawers painted in oil-based paint with no fancy moldings or trims. Oil-based paint is readily cleaned and long-lasting, relatively inexpensive and you can change the look and mood merely by changing the handles and drawer pulls or repainting in a different color — work you can do yourself.

  • One thing to spend money on is real wood flooring, preferably with a distressed look so that hard use just blends right in. "If you can salvage wide planks from an older home, it's wonderful. Wood is very forgiving, a bit springy, you can stand on it for hours. And if they start looking too messed up after a few years, you can always refinish them," said Taylor.

    If you can't afford wood, old-fashioned, joint-free sheet linoleum is environmentally friendly, and it can be installed over a pad for added comfort.

  • For counters, Taylor likes river-wash stone — a sort of formed cement less expensive than granite or marble, easy to clean and durable, and able to be textured to fit any design style.

  • To solve the cupboard problem, he recommends slide-out, drawer-type shelving for the lower cupboards and placing lazy susans in the upper. If you have a pantry, it should be no deeper than the length of your arm.

  • A tip: Order twice as many shelves as recommended along with your kitchen cabinets — then you can customize the heights to your dishes, equipment and products. If you can't afford that, buy brackets at the hardwood store, cut shelving at home and build your own extra shelves.

  • As to sinks, he's in favor of a deep, single-compartment design with an arching faucet that swings out of the way. "Make a fist and let your hand fall to your side. Where your hand is, that's how deep your sink should be, so you're not stooped over."

  • Countertop height should be where your lower arms and hands are if you bend your elbows at a right angle, again, so you needn't stoop over or reach up when you're chopping or kneading.

  • For Taylor,"The most important thing you can spend money on in the kitchen is lighting": individual recessed halogen spots every 2 or 3 feet, aimed so that the light spills down on the workspaces, and undercabinet lighting for shadowy corners. If you want to get fancy, dimmer switches are nice. A central overhead light casts shadows. If you can't afford this much electrical work, install adjustable, low-voltage track lighting from the hardware store. Fluorescent lighting is a bad idea: "They flicker and change the color of the food and they are hard on the eyes," he said.

    Taylor suggests you think of your kitchen as a 20-year investment. "It's expensive and you're going to be spending a lot of time in there," he said. "Pick things you're not going to get bored with, that aren't going to get dated quickly."

    This means neutral counter and floor surfaces, appliances built to last, no fancy moldings or trims. Paint and decorative items can inexpensively add style and be changed whenever you like.

    Reach Wanda A. Adams at wadams@honoluluadvertiser.com.

    • • •