honoluluadvertiser.com

Sponsored by:

Comment, blog & share photos

Log in | Become a member
The Honolulu Advertiser
Posted on: Thursday, June 18, 2009

Trial opens for man accused of beating 7-month-old daughter


Advertiser Staff

Hawaii news photo - The Honolulu Advertiser

Prosecutors say Pulumataala Eli savagely beat his 7-month-old daughter during an argument with the girl's mother in a van at Ala Moana Park two years ago.

DEBORAH BOOKER | Honolulu Advertiser

spacer spacer

Trial began in Circuit Court today for a homeless man accused of savagely beating his 7-month-old daughter in a van at Ala Moana Beach Park nearly two years ago.

Pulumataala Eli, 34, was charged with attempted murder following the incident on Oct. 24, 2007.
Deputy Prosecutor Jeen Kwak told jurors that the girl’s mother, Sarah Fuller, had been arguing with Eli in a Nissan Quest van in which the mother, father and daughter had been living.
At one point, the tot, Alice, began crying and Eli first yelled at the girl to shut up, and then moments later hit her on the head four times.
The argument stemmed from Fuller, who is now 18, telling Eli she wanted to leave him, Kwak said.
When the baby began to cry again a short time later, Eli snatched her out of her car seat and threw her toward the back of the van, Kwak said.
She said he reached back and grabbed the child, throwing her a second time and then throwing the carseat on top of her.
Eli picked the tot up again and Fuller realized the girl had stopped breathing, Kwak said. She said the mother took the girl away from Eli and began to perform CPR on her while en route to Kapiolani Medical Center.
As a result of the beating, the girl who is now 2, “can’t walk ... can’t put two words together” and suffers from permanent brain damage, Kwak said.
In his opening statement, defense attorney David Bettencourt told jurors “that what happened in the van wasn’t pretty” and that it may have been a crime, but that there was never any intent on the part of Eli to kill the girl.
Eli gave a statement to police after his arrest, but police did a poor job of recording the statement and tried repeatedly to get Eli to restate things to their liking, Bettencourt said.
Some of the witnesses who will likely testify against Eli have contradicted statements they made while the case was being investigated, Bettencourt said.
The case is being tried before Circuit Judge Randal Lee.