Evangelicals, Jews seek a bridge
By Paul Nussbaum
Knight Ridder News Service
NEW YORK — The emergence of conservative evangelical Christians as a potent political force has made many American Jews deeply wary. Divided by history, culture and geography, the two religious groups find common ground on Israel, but often little else.
Leaders of two major liberal Jewish organizations recently said conservative Christians were trying to impose their religious beliefs on the rest of the nation. And Jewish scholars who met with evangelical thinkers in New York last week found the gaps between the two world views difficult to bridge.
"What evangelicals don't seem to understand is that when Christians are on the march, Jews tend to run the other way," said Mark Silk, director of the Leonard E. Greenberg Center for the Study of Religion in Public Life at Trinity College in Hartford, Conn.
Michael Alexander, the new director of the Feinstein Center for American Jewish History at Temple University, one of the sponsors of the conference, said his experience as a college professor in Oklahoma taught him that Jews and evangelicals saw each other through different prisms.
Many evangelicals, especially in the South and Midwest, see Jews as exotic anachronisms, while Jews look at evangelicals "like they're out to get us," Alexander said.
Evangelicals are a theologically diverse and numerous group, with perhaps as many as 40 million to 50 million in the United States, compared with only about 5.5 million Jews. Politically, evangelicals tend to be conservative and Jews liberal. Jews are most prevalent in the Northeast, while evangelicals are most numerous in the Midwest and South.
Despite the differences, the two groups share one attitude: They both feel threatened.
Evangelicals, especially white conservative evangelicals, tend to see their religious beliefs as under attack by news media, Hollywood, television and universities, according to surveys presented by John Green, director of the Ray C. Bliss Institute of Applied Politics at the University of Akron and an expert on evangelicals.
Jews, on the other hand, are much less likely to blame America's problems on moral decay and much more concerned about efforts to lower the walls between church and state, the surveys show.
Evangelical leaders meeting last week at the Jewish Theological Seminary sought to emphasize common ground and greater understanding of each other's theology. And several suggested that the religious right may have passed its zenith.
"The core of who I am as an evangelical is not about these political movements," said David Neff, editor of Christianity Today magazine. The religious right, he said, "has, at least, recognized some of its limits. It expected Bush to give it everything it wants because it was a key part of his victory. But he hasn't. It is just one player among many."
Rich Cizik, vice president of government affairs for the National Association of Evangelicals, told the gathered Jewish scholars that evangelicals "are not a threat to Jews. ... You have nothing to fear from evangelicals."
Cizik distributed copies of his organization's new blueprint for civic action, with its emphasis on family life, environmental protection, social justice, religious freedom, human rights and peace.
And he said: "I'm not convinced that most evangelical politicians know much about Evangelicalism today — they're living in the old paradigm. Most evangelical politicians don't have the theological expertise to express what Evangelicalism is today.
"And that has hurt our movement, because they have typecast us."
But Cizik ducked one of the thorniest questions put to him: "Can a Jew go to heaven?
One of the core beliefs of evangelical Christianity is in personal salvation through a "born-again" conversion to Jesus, and believers are instructed to evangelize — to spread the word — to nonbelievers so they can go to heaven, too.
That claim of an exclusive path to paradise rankles Jews, who also object to Christians trying to convert them.
"We want them to leave us alone," said Rabbi Yehiel Poupko of the Jewish Federation of Metropolitan Chicago. "Aren't there enough unchurched Americans for them to evangelize?"