honoluluadvertiser.com

Sponsored by:

Comment, blog & share photos

Log in | Become a member
The Honolulu Advertiser
Posted on: Monday, November 14, 2005

Bill would control CEO pay

By GREG FARRELL
USA Today

In response to public revulsion over the astronomical pay packages awarded to some chief executive officers, a House Democrat introduced legislation last week that would force companies to let their shareholders vote on executive compensation.

Citing statistics showing that CEO salaries rise dramatically even when a company performs poorly, Rep. Barney Frank, D-Mass., said more disclosure of executive compensation was necessary.

"This bill does not dictate pay levels for corporations," he said. "It sets rules for public corporations about how to go about things."

Frank's proposed legislation calls for large public corporations to include detailed summaries of CEO pay contracts in the annual proxy statements sent to shareholders. Shareholders would then have to approve those contracts. The summaries would include:

  • Full disclosure of compensation, including extra goodies such as pensions, personal use of company jets, apartments and other now-hidden compensation. This proposal came in response to the revelation two years ago that former General Electric CEO Jack Welch had been granted a generous farewell package upon his retirement. The SEC sanctioned GE for not fully disclosing the details of Welch's deal.

  • Full disclosure of golden-parachute agreements. Frank criticized the $153 million payout awarded to James Kilts, former CEO of Gillette, who received the windfall after selling Gillette to Procter & Gamble.

  • Disclosure of the corporate policy for recapturing incentive pay awarded for faulty financial results.

    Frank said this portion of his proposal was designed to force CEOs to give back any bonus payments they received for hitting their numbers in a particular quarter if the results that quarter subsequently had to be restated.

    This portion of the bill was based, in part, on the fact that former Fannie Mae CEO Frank-lin Raines was allowed to keep some of his incentive pay for hitting his target numbers even though the company eventually announced a $9 billion restatement.

    Nell Minow, editor of the Corporate Library, a corporate-governance watchdog group, praised the bill. "What's sexy about this legislation is that for the first time, it gives shareholders some veto power," she said. "If you look at people whose pay is in the stratosphere, they are movie stars, rock stars, athletes, investment bankers and CEOs.

    "One of these things is not like the other. The first four are paid for their performance. Why is it that CEOs are the only ones who have absurd contracts? They're not negotiated in arm's-length transactions."

    The Securities and Exchange Commission is expected to propose rules requiring fuller disclosure of CEO compensation early next year.