honoluluadvertiser.com

Sponsored by:

Comment, blog & share photos

Log in | Become a member
The Honolulu Advertiser
Posted on: Monday, July 17, 2006

'Project Runway' succeeds, and stylishly

By Robert Lloyd
Los Angeles Times

Left to right, Kate Spade, Nina Garcia, Michael Kors, Heidi Klum; designers are the judges along with the show's hostess, Klum.

Bravo photos

spacer spacer

'PROJECT RUNWAY'

7 p.m. Wednesdays, repeats at 9 p.m.

Bravo

spacer spacer

Model Jia wears a "home-sewn" outfit by one of the contestants.

spacer spacer

HOLLYWOOD — Is this only the third season of "Project Runway"? I feel as if the show has been around forever, a sign perhaps of its cultural penetration, as deep and rapid as that of Sudoku.

It may owe something, also, to the fact that the present season comes only seven months after the last, so that "third season" does not equal "third year." This is the rate at which the Beatles used to release records, and you know how that worked for them.

Of all the and-then-there-was-one competitive reality shows I've seen, this is the one I've been able to sink my teeth into, or which has sunk its teeth into me.

Although many viewers surely come for the soap opera the producers construct around the game, and some may be here primarily for the Teutonic charms of hostess Heidi Klum (not pregnant this time around), it is the crafts element that sets "Project Runway" apart from most of its kind: People make things. (They make clothes, I suppose I should mention.)

Those who compete in this show are not out only to win a lot of money or to be on television — though undoubtedly that's part of it — they all aspire to produce something beautiful and to acquire the means to do it.

Some of them are better than others, and not all are as good as they think they are. And some are as annoying as the most annoying people on the most annoying reality shows. But even the most self-loving and superior among them are scratching a creative itch and are required to produce something inventive, personal and real.

There is a kind of master-class aspect to the show, especially when "mentor" Tim Gunn, chairman of fashion design at Parsons the New School for Design, roams the workroom giving critiques. The contestants tend to nod at his advice and then go on doing what they were doing in the first place, but most of them have been through fashion school and many have been at work, some quite successfully, in the field for a long time.

And from last Wednesday's pregame "The Road to Runway," in which thousands of applicants became 15 contestants and we revisited some faces from seasons past, it's obvious that some "Project Runway" vets are happy to be back where their own opinion is the one that counts. (The new crew members skew a little older and are even more accomplished.)

Given the small budgets and absurd time limits, it's really striking what the best of them produce and how many solutions (and good solutions) there are to a given problem. (Wednesday's challenge: Make a dress from the materials in your apartment: bedclothes, curtains, upholstery, like that.)

I like the fact that what matters on the show is the work — that there's no one to manipulate, no favor to curry, no way to backstab your way into first place.