honoluluadvertiser.com

Sponsored by:

Comment, blog & share photos

Log in | Become a member
The Honolulu Advertiser
Posted on: Friday, December 19, 2008

Fall Out Boy maxes out with aesthetic gluttony

Los Angeles Times

Hawaii news photo - The Honolulu Advertiser

The All-American Rejects, led by Tyson Ritter, performed Sunday at the sixth annual Video Game Awards at Sony Picture Studios in Culver City, Calif.

Associated Press

spacer spacer
Hawaii news photo - The Honolulu Advertiser

Members of Fall Out Boy, from left, Joseph Trohman, Andy Hurley and Patrick Stump, at MTV's "TRL Total Finale Live" in November.

spacer spacer

"Folie a Deux" by Fall Out Boy; Island Records

Fall Out Boy isn't one to thwart its fans or the fame machine. The band's fifth album, "Folie a Deux," is a pleasure bot of right-now pop, adroitly programmed with crunchy 1980s melodies, emo's dark prowess and symphonies a la "Sgt. Pepper's." A little something for everyone, all of it played to the max.

"Folie a Deux" imagines itself in the stadium. "(Coffee's for Closers)" marches in, tattered but resplendent, and closes with a playful bounty of horns and a suite of strings. "Disloyal Order of Water Buffaloes" soars and struts with a newfound love for vocal harmonies and club bathroom graffiti such as "detox just to retox."

But for all the steps forward, "Folie a Deux" also seems to contain a microchip for its own destruction. Friends drop in, Debbie Harry, Elvis Costello, Lil Wayne, but they barely surface above the album's aesthetic gluttony. Pete Wentz's lyrics flit from celebrity snark — "throw your cameras in the air and wave them like you just don't care" — to inane lines possibly cribbed from a soap opera script: "Does your husband know how the sunshine gleams from your wedding band?"

Some songs, like "Tiffany Blews," are meant to be vampy but suffocate instead. There are moments when the oxygen floods in — like the Pharrell-assisted "w.a.m.s.," which unexpectedly ends in stripped-down a-cappella blues — but they are all too rare.

It's not that FOB can't have grandiosity, but every stadium needs open air.

— Margaret Wappler

"When the World Comes Down" by All-American Rejects; Interscope

The best thing about the All-American Rejects is how unambitious the pop-emo quartet is. The Rejects' supremely bratty yet relentlessly hooky singles each have seemed destined to score teenage rom-com dance-party sequences for time immemorial, and it hasn't hurt that their emo-Adonis front man Tyson Ritter has cheekbones that could slice bread.

The band's new record, "When the World Comes Down," broadens the palette a bit, leavening typically cocky choruses like "I want to touch you / you want to touch me too" with synthesizer pricks and jaunty string arrangements befitting Ritter's avowed love of musicals.

Ponderous and overproduced moments like "Damn Girl" and "Back to Me" suggest soaring earnestness and slower tempos are a drag on the band's sense of spunk. But the kick-start rockers like "Fallin' Apart" and the gleeful kiss-off "Gives You Hell" benefit from the new breathing room.

Modern emo bands tend to treat breakups with a severity worthy of Wagner. Ritter's penchant for hummable nastiness is a vast improvement, and lines like "Truth be told I miss you / truth be told I'm lying" are a better representation of actual teenagedom: snide and rarely unentertaining.

The Rejects are best at small ideas with a long shelf life. "World" forgets that at points, but pretty people always get away with everything, don't they?

— August Brown