honoluluadvertiser.com

Sponsored by:

Comment, blog & share photos

Log in | Become a member
The Honolulu Advertiser
Posted on: Monday, March 10, 2008

Letters to the Editor

EDUCATION

BUDGET HIGHER BECAUSE OF PROGRAM TRANSFERS

I would like to provide Hawai'i's taxpayers and Sen. Fred Hemmings with facts about the Department of Education operating budget in response to his March 5 letter to the editor.

The DOE's $2.4 billion budget can be broken down into general funds (86 percent), federal funds (11 percent) and other funds (3 percent).

Sen. Hemmings noted that enrollment has decreased while funding has increased. This is true. What he failed to point out is that since 1999-2000 the DOE budget has increased more than $1 billion due to sizable program transfers from other state agencies, federal mandates and general fund-pass-through costs.

Entire programs that were budgeted to and performed by other state agencies are now included in the DOE's budget, such as student transportation services ($45.7 million), school health aides ($5.6 million), and minor repair and maintenance funding ($25.7 million).

Under the Felix consent decree, special-education services, programs and expenditures increased more than $400 million during the past decade.

Previously reported under the Department of Budget and Finance through fiscal year 1999-2000, general fund-pass-through costs for DOE employee benefits, debt service and risk management now represent 31 percent of the DOE's general fund budget. This year, general fund-pass-through costs totaled $619 million and are expected to rise.

Sen. Hemmings also stated that DOE funding is unevenly distributed between the bloated bureaucracy and the classroom. Excluding debt service, 24 percent of DOE funds are spent on central services such as student transportation, school food services, utilities, and minor repair and maintenance, 2 percent on instructional support, and 2 percent on state/complex area administration.

The bulk of the budget, representing 72 percent or $1.5 billion, is spent by schools, with the weighted student formula portion totaling $908.9 million.

Superintendent Patricia Hamamoto did not "spin the matter" on a comprehensive management audit for the DOE in her letter to the editor. The superintendent clearly voiced her support for independent audits.

James Brese
Assistant superintendent, Office of Fiscal Services, state Department of Education

TRANSIT

THERE'S STILL TIME TO HALT COSTLY RAIL PROJECT

Stop! Look! Listen! Remember the danger signs at railway crossings. This rail transit scheme is not a done deal. Many crossings are to be made before any rail project can pound a spike.

The following preliminary steps are still legal requirements:

  • A draft environmental impact statement is due in July, followed by public hearings and comments.

  • Then a supplemental draft EIS incorporating public comments.

  • Next would be a final EIS.

  • Only then can the City Council vote to spend the money.

  • At that stage, a record of decision by the federal government would be required.

    We have ample time to keep the boilers of this engine from firing up and chugging us to local bankruptcy.

    The bus rapid transit (BRT) in Honolulu took three years between the draft EIS and the final EIS.

    We have the time to look more closely at any rail project that has historically had consistently high cost overruns, as this appears to have.

    You can stop, look and listen, too, before we make a costly mistake affecting every taxpayer on O'ahu.

    Gordon Damon
    Honolulu

    GERIATRIC SERVICES

    LOSS OF HOME-CARE PROGRAMS DISMAYING

    I am dismayed that the Hawai'i Health Systems Corporation has decided to close the Maluhia Home Care and Maluhia Geriatric Physician Services as of June 30, 2008. This follows the closing of what once was the PACE program, which provided comprehensive care to elderly patients.

    As the sole caregiver for my mother, I found PACE to be the only place I could turn to for help to keep my mother at home rather than put her in a care home. To further maintain my mother at home, I also had to use the in-home care services.

    The closing of the PACE program last year was made palatable by the continuation and expansion of the medical geriatric and in-home programs to outside patients who did not have to be part of PACE.

    Given more time, I think this would have served the community well. I was surprised that after less than a year, HHSC has decided to close the medical and in-home services programs.

    While I realize there are economic realities to running a medical program, there are also social needs to be met by government programs. The state's need for geriatric and medical services is well documented and is growing geometrically.

    To have programs like this close only worsens the problem.

    It seems unbelievable that HHSC cannot see the need to continue these types of programs in a state where we can devote millions of dollars to athletic programs.

    Why was the PACE program in Hawai'i the only PACE program in the nation that closed?

    Where else can family caregivers turn for a comprehensive program in one place to help them with their overwhelming burdens of caring for loved ones?

    Milton Hee
    Honolulu

    VETERANS CEMETERY

    RULES MUST BE BETTER ENFORCED AT GRAVE SITES

    I visited the Hawai'i State Veterans Cemetery in Windward O'ahu recently and I was a bit disappointed.

    So many of the grave sites have been modified by family members of the deceased that areas have an uneven, jumbled, patchwork look. One need only compare this with the National Memorial Cemetery at Punchbowl to see the difference.

    In the "80's area" there were more than a half-dozen grave sites that had been trenched around the marker and different grass planted that rose several inches above the surrounding area.

    I understand the desire of relatives to make a grave site special and part of a personal memorial. But the end result is a ratty, jumbled look, which detracts from the quiet dignity all our veterans should be afforded. Several sites had balloons, windmills and other items, none of which is appropriate.

    In the distance, several people were also using the roads as a jogging track. There must be a better place to get one's exercise.

    I realize some people who have family members buried there would not be happy with the rules enforced. But they must be — for all our heroes who rest there.

    Jason Kokaaina
    Waipahu

    SUPERDELEGATES

    DON'T LIKE THE RULES? WORK TO CHANGE THEM

    Some people have attacked Sen. Daniel Inouye for his pledge to support Sen. Hillary Clinton despite the overwhelming caucus support for Sen. Barack Obama.

    Under the Democratic Party rules, superdelegates have the prerogative to vote for whomever they think will be the best, the most experienced and winningest candidate.

    Can't we trust the judgment of Sen. Inouye, whom we have elected since statehood by huge majorities?

    Let us play by the rules, or if you are not a Democrat, join the party and help change the rules.

    Mark Litchman
    Honolulu

    GENETIC ENGINEERING

    MAINTAIN INTEGRITY, SIGNIFICANCE OF KALO

    The kalo farmers have made their eloquent plea. Voices of concern have been raised about the sanctity of kalo in respect to its cultural significance and its botanical integrity.

    I join the chorus of support to maintain that sanctity, that significance and that integrity: Kalo, as is!

    Jose Bulatao Jr.
    Kekaha, Kaua'i

    ADVERTISER RALLY

    ABERCROMBIE CAN'T SEE GIVE AND TAKE NEEDED

    For whatever the reason, I've found The Advertiser over the years to be more than fair in allowing U.S. Rep. Neil Abercrombie editorial space.

    How ironic, then, that while The Advertiser and its workers are in negotiations, Rep. Abercrombie showed up at the workers' rally in his usual fashion, according to the Honolulu Star Bulletin on Feb. 11, "shouting" his distaste.

    But then that's classic Abercrombie. It's the only way he knows how to speak, by intimidation, i.e., a truculent man who seems to always be angry at big business.

    Currently, the issue he addressed was healthcare but, as The Advertiser has pointed out, healthcare costs are completely out of control and worsening.

    There needs to be a give and take on both sides, that is from management and the union. However, Abercrombie fails to see this.

    It was quite clear Abercrombie would rather play the role of the provocateur.

    But then I believe Abercrombie has had little or no experience in business, yet always seems to have one-sided opinions.

    One wonders whether Sens. Daniel Inouye and Dan Akaka and Rep. Mazie Hirono support his approach, or are trying to distance themselves.

    Jack H. Scaff Jr. M.D.
    Honolulu

    HAWAII MEDICAL CENTER

    APPALLED AT TAX-BREAK REQUEST FROM HOSPITAL

    I am appalled with the Hawaii Medical Center asking the state for tax breaks because it is having a hard time making a profit.

    If this particular group would invest in their operation as agreed upon, perhaps their bottom line would improve as well.

    If this group is able to get any tax breaks or relief from the state, so should countless numbers of small companies facing the same difficult business environment we are in. I see no reason why this should take place and set a precedent.

    Jeff Yuh
    Mililani