Candidates disagree on who's to blame for crisis
By David Lightman and William Douglas
McClatchy-Tribune News Service
GRAND RAPIDS, Mich. — John McCain blamed Wall Street's "casino culture" and Barack Obama blamed Republicans — including McCain — yesterday for the financial turmoil that led to the government's takeover of the nation's largest insurer.
"The government was forced to commit $85 billion," McCain, the Republican presidential nominee, said in a statement about the Federal Reserve's loan Tuesday night to American International Group. "These actions stem from failed regulation, reckless management and a casino culture on Wall Street that has crippled one of the most important companies in America."
Obama, the Democratic presidential nominee, pounced, calling McCain's views "an 11th-hour conversion to the language of reform" after decades of support for Republican policies deferring to markets and cutting government regulation of them.
The Fed's takeover of AIG "is the final verdict on the failed economic philosophy of the last eight years," Obama charged in a statement. "This crisis serves as a stark reminder of the failures of crony capitalism and an economic philosophy that sees any regulation at all as unwise and unnecessary ... Sen. McCain has subscribed to this philosophy for 26 years in Washington."
McCain supported 1999 legislation that tore down Depression-era legal walls separating commercial banks, investment banks and insurers from one another. However, President Clinton, a Democrat, signed it into law.
Throughout his congressional career, the Arizona senator usually has backed cutting federal regulation of industries in the name of promoting free markets and ending government interference, which is Republican ideology. However, he's sided with Democrats in voting for HMO regulation, background checks for sales at gun shows and tougher fuel-economy standards for autos.
In the closest modern parallel to recent government intervention in Wall Street's crisis, McCain voted in support of the 1989 bill to clean up the debt-ridden savings-and-loan industry, which passed the Senate 91-8.
McCain was one of the "Keating Five" senators whom the Senate Ethics Committee investigated for their relationships with Charles Keating, the chairman of the failed Lincoln Savings & Loan Association. Keating gave McCain's campaigns about $112,000 in contributions, and they were friends; McCain and his family took lavish trips with Keating.
Keating served five years in jail after being convicted of corruption charges in connection with his management of Lincoln. The committee cleared McCain, who met with federal regulators to discuss Keating, of acting improperly but said he'd exercised poor judgment.
The Federal Reserve Board said Tuesday night that it would give AIG a two-year, $85 billion loan and take a nearly 80 percent stake in the firm, which has lost billions because of mortgage-bond defaults that it insured. The action followed the Fed's and Treasury's recent takeover of mortgage giants Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac and engineering of the sale of investment bank Bear Stearns.
McCain and Obama stressed that the Fed should aim most to protect taxpayers, not financiers.
"The focus of any (government) action should be to protect the millions of Americans who hold insurance policies, retirement plans and other accounts with AIG," McCain said. "We must not bail out the management and speculators who created this mess."
Said Obama: "The Fed must ensure that the plan protects the families that count on insurance. ... It must not bail out the shareholders or management of AIG."